Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Do you really need to announce your credentials for your view to be taken seriously?

5 replies

BerylStreep · 31/07/2012 16:37

I haven't noticed it much before, but it seems that on quite a few of the threads I have read recently, people feel compelled to cite their credentials in order for their view to be taken more seriously (or to try to 'top' anyone who is disagreeing with them).

In the last week alone I have read things like:

Well actually, I have a degree in history & economics and therefore know everything there is to know about the subject.

I have been a practising lawyer for the last 15 years and therefore my opinion on everything legal is correct.

Yes, in fact, I was privately educated from the ages of 3-18 - in, I believe, the top girls' school in the country.

I have the last word on all DV issues because my Mum started a women's refuge.

Maybe it is just the types of threads I have been reading, which turn into bunfights. Now I come to think about it, I haven't seen too much of it on Style & Beauty.

There are times when I am on a thread, and I have a good knowledge on the subject, either professionally or through educational qualifications, but I have never felt the need to announce to MN what that professional experience or qualifications are.

Is it just me?

HellenicGamesMumsnet · 31/07/2012 21:17

Evening. And apols that we haven't replied to this one till now.

In response to the OP's question, we don't have experts on MN (apart from the odd one we invite to hold a officially signposted webchat or Q&A). This is a site where you can seek and receive peer-to-peer support, not expert advice.

We may well have many MNers who are experts in particular areas but we don't check anyone's qualifications or endorse anyone's advice.

So, while it's perfectly possible that the poster declaring they're an expert in paleolithic artifacts is indeed an expert in paleolithic artifacts, they could equally be a 12-year-old in Peckham with nothing but a few hours to kill and a passing acquaintance with Wikipedia.

Which all means that, while we see the most amazing, deeply insightful/hugely wise/knowledge-laden posts on MN every day, no one should really give any one poster's posts more weight than any other's.

And, of course, no poster should think that "flashing their (unchecked) credentials" will mean they can win all the arguments give their posts more weight than anyone else's.

HellenicGamesMumsnet · 31/07/2012 21:18

And yes, chocolate orange definitely at least one of your five a day

HellenicGamesMumsnet · 31/07/2012 21:24

@LRDtheFeministDragon

I am deeply impressed by the quality of 12 year olds in Peckam, then.

Are you an expert in that area, Hellenic?

No but a world-acknowledged expert on the interpretation of 14-year-old surly grunts in norf London....

HellenicGamesMumsnet · 31/07/2012 21:32

That's bless his little heart, innit.

Like obvs.

(Told you was an expert)

HellenicGamesMumsnet · 02/08/2012 16:40

Aw, poor Abs. Shall I start a thread for you?

Watch this thread for updates

Tap "Watch" to get all the latest updates

End of posts

There are no more MNHQ posts on this thread