Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Shopping

From everyday essentials to big purchases, swap tips and recommendations. For the best deals without the hassle, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Mechanics and car sales men. Where do we go from here?

1 reply

Eggfrog · 01/10/2014 14:49

We bought a landrover the other day. 2002 reg, 60,000 miles, looked ok but we don't know anything abut cars. MOT was done in September 2014 and a mechanic was there at the sale who said he had serviced it the day before (which we now know is a lie - he wasn't our mechanic).

We drove the car home and within 4 days it was producing a bad petrol smell from the engine. I took it to a garage who identified a leak, and after fixing that have now told us that the thermostat isn't working (apparently 3 hours labour to fix), the throttle pipe doesn't fit, i.e. the wrong one has been put in (0.5 hours labour, part = £60) and we should probably change the timing/cam belt (£400?).

I don't know what to do. Obviously we've been sold a dud but chances of getting our money back from the vendor are slim (he is swearing blind none of these problems were there two weeks ago - he only owned it for 3 weeks as bought from repossession auction to sell on. He presented himself as a private seller but is more of a trader as he had a few cars lined up).

Do we fix the problems. Or cut our losses and sell the vehicle for whatever we can get for it. Is it pointless spending money on an old car? Or maybe the garage we're using is overstating the problem (e.g. timing belt - do we really need a new one, I just don't know).

I'm so annoyed about the whole thing and also at a loss about what to do. Wish I was a mechanic myself. Any advice or comparable experiences, please share...

OP posts:
WMittens · 01/10/2014 16:09

We bought a landrover

Warning sign!

He presented himself as a private seller but is more of a trader as he had a few cars lined up

Warning sign!

we should probably change the timing/cam belt (£400?)

General maintenance, it's a part of car ownership - 60k sounds a bit early for it but I don't know the service intervals on this model - is it a Defender, Disco or Freelander?

If things go wrong you need to give the trader the opportunity (or 3 opportunities) to fix it before you can reject it. As he's masquerading as a private a seller it sounds like he's trying to avoid this liability. Kick up a stink (politely, to start with), he probably doesn't want to get noticed by the legal system. Give him the option of fixing it or refunding you.

Sale of Goods act doesn't give you much support in these situations as the vehicle is 12 years old (so can't be expected to be perfect; things need fixing on 12 year old cars) and a fraction of its original price.

On the other hand, once these problems are sorted you may have a car that runs without too much issue for a while. As it's a LR that may be a tad optimistic - these things cost a lot to keep going. If you want a tough, reliable 4x4 try a Toyota Land Cruiser.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread