Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

London 11+ Offers: What did you get and what did you pick?

60 replies

drdee · 02/03/2026 05:48

Calling all mums - let’s talk! Especially September 2026 Year 7 mums - we’ll need this ☺️🌸

OP posts:
MissRB · 05/03/2026 16:40

@drdee yes, we are considering both and will decide before 16th. Also, Indies need a 1 term notice for exit..which means if one dosent decide to attend an indie school ...one has to let them know by the 26th of March or they pay Year 7 Autumn term fees.

That's said, what are your thoughts on Oxbridge or university prospects of a candidate from an indie vs state. In some sectors when it comes to internship/ job...a kid with state sector education is picked.

I am not sure about universities though...

drdee · 05/03/2026 17:22

@MissRB When it comes to Oxbridge or other top universities, the type of school (independent vs state) is usually not the deciding factor. Universities mainly look at academic performance, admissions tests, interviews, and genuine interest in the subject.

Independent schools sometimes send more students to Oxbridge, but that can also be related to preparation and cohort size. For example, last year Henrietta Barnett Grammar School sent 34 students to Oxbridge, and around 20% of City of London Girls students went to Oxbridge. Since City has a smaller year group, I think that percentage is actually very strong.

Independent schools also tend to have strong preparation systems, experienced teachers, and more structured guidance for applications and interviews. So the difference is usually more about preparation and support rather than any direct preference from universities.

Personally, I also think students benefit a lot from the networks and opportunities available in independent schools-this is something I experienced myself.

For us, what matters most is not only grades or future jobs, but also the environment and the opportunities a school provides. The overall atmosphere, resources, and the kind of peer group and encouragement a child receives can make a big difference in a child’s development.

Both options are very good, and you may well be right that in some cases certain companies prefer candidates who come from state schools. However, my personal preference is to choose an environment that can provide my child with every opportunity and resources they might need and support their development in the best possible way.

OP posts:
drdee · 05/03/2026 17:32

@MissRB By the way, I have a relative who is a professor at Cambridge. She mentioned that they don’t necessarily evaluate students from highly selective independent schools in the same way as those from less or not selective ones.

Her point was that if a child manages to get into a top independent school, it already indicates a significant achievement at a young age (natural ability since age 11). However, when a student comes from a less or not selective independent school, admissions tutors sometimes wonder whether that student might have achieved the same grades if they had attended a state school instead.

OP posts:
drdee · 05/03/2026 17:40

Just to be clear, I’m not suggesting that Oxbridge prefers students from top independent schools.

What I mean is that if a girl got a offer from highly selective school like NLCS, admissions tutors would recognise that she is likely to be capable and successful wherever she studies. Attending a independent school like that wouldn’t be seen as a disadvantage or count against her.
🙏🏻🌸

OP posts:
MissRB · 05/03/2026 17:47

@drdee Very well communicated and great points. Thank you for your perspective and your time. It was indeed helpful.

Will keep you posted on our decision.
Thank you once again. And wishing your child and the family all the very best for the next innings.

challengeAcceptedd · 05/03/2026 19:57

@MissRB If money was not a concern, I wouldn’t think twice!
It is a fact that the environment at HBS is very intense. The girls there are all brilliant however the teaching style is unsupportive. Have you checked on the student forum? Do your daughter a favour and search HBS on there and read the accounts of many girls who are studying currently or have studied at HBS.

NLCS is a wonderful school, providing a nurturing environment, there’s something for everyone there and while super academic is definitively not intense. The facilities are also top notch.
They get the results without the stress.

Oh, and there’s tutoring from Y7 at HBS, almost everyone does it. 7 years is a long time to be in a pressure cooker.
HBS is not the bees knees.

drdee · 05/03/2026 20:46

@MissRB No prob at all- I’m glad it was helpful in some way. Good luck with the decision, and I hope your DD loves her new school x

@challengeAcceptedd I totally agree x

OP posts:
MissRB · 05/03/2026 21:18

@challengeAcceptedd Thank you! You know, all these years I didn't think of researching in the students forum! That's such a good tip for everyone!

I think I am getting closer to making a decision.

PlainSkyr · 06/03/2026 09:02

Yoyoflow · 02/03/2026 19:52

DD got into Wallington High School for Girls (Grammar) and Godolphin & Latymer and she is on waiting list for LEH.

Not sure if we should go for G&L or stick to state options. DD wants to go to G&L but fees are too high and we will be stretching ourselves.

Edited

These schools are geographically quite distant; curious to understand will you be moving home? Wallington is quite far from the other 2 schools which are also quite far from each other!

swdd · 01/04/2026 11:32

challengeAcceptedd · 05/03/2026 19:57

@MissRB If money was not a concern, I wouldn’t think twice!
It is a fact that the environment at HBS is very intense. The girls there are all brilliant however the teaching style is unsupportive. Have you checked on the student forum? Do your daughter a favour and search HBS on there and read the accounts of many girls who are studying currently or have studied at HBS.

NLCS is a wonderful school, providing a nurturing environment, there’s something for everyone there and while super academic is definitively not intense. The facilities are also top notch.
They get the results without the stress.

Oh, and there’s tutoring from Y7 at HBS, almost everyone does it. 7 years is a long time to be in a pressure cooker.
HBS is not the bees knees.

If money was not a concern, I wouldn’t think twice!

Surely a top-tier selective private school offers more value than a top selective grammar. If Henrietta Barnett charged the same fees as North London Collegiate, I imagine almost no one would choose HB. The real question is: whether the value added to the DD justifies the significant cost to the parent. Every DD/family is different.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page