All good points and I agree. A lot of it is about exam approach and I'm sure when kids are checking at the end they pay more attention to the more difficult questions.
I've been saying to my DD for a while if she does want to check don't necessarily revisit the question and apply exactly the same methodology. Instead try and answer the question using a different method and see if the answer is the same. Not always possible.
I havent looked at the paper apart from Q13 which my DD answered incorrectly because she claims she misread/ misinterpreted the question. It seemed pretty easy. Perhaps one thing my DD doesnt do is just jot down the basics on scrap paper before attempting to answer.
I was never specifically taught exam technique when I was a kid and I kinda learned this iteratively and slowly. I'd guess my DD now is perhaps at the level I was at A level....partly because I'm making her think about it more.
The Olympiad will be a whole different kettle of fish in terms of approach. Double the time of her longest exam in her life to date and just 6 questions. I'm already suggesting an approach of do nothing for the first 5-10 mins apart from read all the questions, then rank them in order best to worst on gut feeling which she likes most and tackle them in that order.
With her normally reaching high percentages in maths exams I seem to have 100% got her head around the fact merit last yr was just 20/60, and bronze 38/60. This yr with the easier section A being dropped these thresholds may be as low as say 15 and 34? So like I said to her this morning, even if she got 8 marks on 3q and 3 marks on 3q she'd be there or thereabouts for a medal.
Overall though it just feels like I'm plucking random figures out of the air. I'm happy she's made it to this stage and anything else is a bonus. All I wouldn't want is the unfortunate situation like yourself that the final mark is 1-2 points off the next threshold. If merit range is indeed 15-33 say I'd be as happy with a 20 as a 32.
I'll admit though, a medal of any colour would be lovely. But my base expectation is a merit.