They both have good reputations. They were both Estyn excellent, equivalent to ofsted outstanding, but Estyn no longer rate schools in this way.
I am probably biased because of my own experiences…..
Bishop Gore is v strong academically, with some fabulous teachers. Their pastoral care and their support for children with ALN is outstanding. They respond really well to concerns re bullying and mental health. They use a ladder system for tutor groups. So each child is allocated to a tutor group with, say, 4 children from each year group going up through the school, so 4 Y7s, 4 Y8s and so on, which helps to build relationships across age groups. They have a fabulous theatre and performing arts department and stage the most incredible musicals.
There is a very diverse catchment area.
However, the Head is, according to my child anyway, a dragon! They are very particular about uniform, and the school buildings are falling down. The canteen is tiny and there isn’t really long enough to queue for food, so best to take food.
Olchfa is known for being excellent academically. So teaching is supposed to be great, and good results, although I am not sure that they are any better than at BG. The school buildings are much newer, fresher, better equipped etc. Grounds are nicer.
The local concerns about Olchfa stem from pupil welfare in that they are not considered to be so good pastorally with managing bullying or supporting students that are struggling. So a LOT of students have moved from O to BG because they were not coping/ bullying/ MH etc.
I think that Olchfa can be a very successful school for able, hard working students and they will do very well there.
My children both have additional needs and therefore we would not have considered it for them.
However, in the grand scheme of things, they are both excellent and family who live in Bristol think we are unbelievably lucky to have such choices.
i don’t know Sketty Primary but it has a good reputation.
Swansea is a fab place to live.