WLFS is strict, but that helps minimise low level disruption. My son was really anxious about getting in trouble, but when he did get a detention in Y7 (forgot his class reader for a second time) he realised it was just not a big deal. Detentions are pretty relaxed, most students will get them at some point and they just do their homework or read a book.
There is a lack of outside space but inside the library is really nice and the classrooms are fine. Classes average at 26, but top sets seem to fit in just over 30 without issues. The hall/canteen are one big flexible space. There can be problems getting them all fed in time, but I think this is a service rather than space issue.
I am not a big fan of either head and can see why they are thought of as arrogant. No school is perfect though and most the teachers my son has had have been very good. The Music Department are excellent and music scholars will be a good way for her to make friends in a smaller group.
We are further East so can’t compare the schools. I would look at the curriculum to make your decision. WLFS suited my son, but Chiswick has a much broader range of options including Food, Textiles, Business Studies etc.
@ladyme My son is currently in sixth form and is really enjoying it. They are more relaxed - they can use their phones for example - but detentions are still a thing. He got one for forgetting his pass, but he hasn’t forgotten it again! There is a quite a few new joiners at Sixth Form and they seem to have integrated well. It is more structured than a college would be though - in addition to your taught classes they also have supervised study sessions timetabled which may not be for everyone.