Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

GCSE Drama - good choice for a quiet child??

63 replies

MyBonnyLiesOverTheOcean2020 · 17/03/2021 16:57

My daughter is trying to decide whether she should take GCSE drama or not. She's very quiet and loves performing at home but struggles to convey the performance element in front of others. She thinks doing GCSE drama will help her confidence. I've heard that they work in groups and I wonder if she'll just get drowned out by the many others who are more confident. Any feedback from anyone with some experience of the course would be great. Thanks.

OP posts:
LIZS · 17/03/2021 17:07

How much does she enjoy the subject? A substantial amount of the course is written and theoretical.

emilylovesfun · 17/03/2021 17:11

@MyBonnyLiesOverTheOcean2020

My daughter is trying to decide whether she should take GCSE drama or not. She's very quiet and loves performing at home but struggles to convey the performance element in front of others. She thinks doing GCSE drama will help her confidence. I've heard that they work in groups and I wonder if she'll just get drowned out by the many others who are more confident. Any feedback from anyone with some experience of the course would be great. Thanks.
Not the best choice unfortunately my daughter is like your child with performing and she got bullied for it. ☹️
sessell · 17/03/2021 17:12

Drama transformed my extremely shy daughter. But she started earlier and did a few summer courses first. She did drama GCSE and a level too and loved them.

HypnoRuler · 17/03/2021 17:13

Id recommend a real GCSE instead; Statistics, History, IT, etc.

Yes, I favour STEM over arts anyday.

Ilovelove · 17/03/2021 17:14

So GCSE drama is so much better than Key Stage 3 drama because everyone who is in the class has chosen it.

It is a lot of group work and performance to the class most lessons.

Depending on the exam board, usually about 60% is practical and 40% is written work.

There are options to do one of the practical sections as a technical skill (lighting, sound, costume design) but they tend to be the exception and so pupils that do that, have to really manage their workload with guidance only.
You need to be able to learn lines. Inherent in it is 'fear and risk' - you have to get on stage and you don't know what might happen - and you have to do it anyway.

For me, I was a quiet young person, and I loved the subject, how my teachers taught it and the class I was in. I can truthfully tell you that drama was where I found my voice.

I went on to be a school drama teacher for 17 years and GCSE drama remains my favourite thing to teach - there is so much scope for creativity and trying different theatre styles.

BUT there are some spectacularly bad drama teachers out there (it seems to be either you have an amazing drama department or a crap one and not much in the middle). So I would have a look at the past results, how long has the drama teacher been there (you don't want a high turnover in a department) , what are the quality of the school productions.

Kanaloa · 17/03/2021 17:17

If she struggles to perform I think drama would cause her a lot of stress. My daughter is a bit younger but performs with her dance school - she absolutely loves performing but is still nervous and anxious the night before a performance. That type of stress in a shy child might make the course really stressful for her.

Like pp’s idea of trying a summer course before jumping in, because at least then she’d be able to quit if it really didn’t suit. Of course that may not be practical at the moment.

mumonthehill · 17/03/2021 17:17

My ds has also just chosen drama. He has been encouraged as he has enjoyed the elements of English that have got him debating and writing stories. He never, ever wanted to perform before he got to secondary school but had slowly started to take to drama. All those that I know that have taken it have really enjoyed it and this course allows for set design, lighting and make up to be elements if performing is not your full interest. He is looking forward to doing something different as a choice.

Newgirls · 17/03/2021 17:18

She could still get a good grade if academic as a lot is written work.

Has she done school plays etc with the people who would be in her class? If so she knows them and what they would be like?

MoiraNotRuby · 17/03/2021 17:20

@HypnoRuler

Id recommend a real GCSE instead; Statistics, History, IT, etc.

Yes, I favour STEM over arts anyday.

How rude! Drama is a real subject.

You know, it is possible to do a mixture of GCSEs. My daughter is set for a science career AND a GCSE in Drama. STEAM beats STEM these days, creativity is massively important.

Newgirls · 17/03/2021 17:21

My dd is shy but very good at drama and did find some of the bigger characters frustrating but the teacher handled it well and she got a good grade. Also learned some great skills and confidence and has performed since.

HellonHeels · 17/03/2021 17:21

@HypnoRuler

Id recommend a real GCSE instead; Statistics, History, IT, etc.

Yes, I favour STEM over arts anyday.

History is not a STEM subject.

The good thing about GCSEs is that it's possible to do a range of subjects - the STEM subjects and the arts and humanties.

HypnoRuler · 17/03/2021 17:28

@HellonHeels

True. The 2nd para/ line was a generalisation, not meant to be linked to the examples.

Lets be honest though, some qualifications are worth less for the majority of people: GCSE Art, Drama, French (unless you are going to work internationally).

Same with some degrees: Gender studies, fashion, etc

LynetteScavo · 17/03/2021 17:29

@HypnoRuler

Id recommend a real GCSE instead; Statistics, History, IT, etc.

Yes, I favour STEM over arts anyday.

Haha - last time I checked Drama is a real GCSE, acting is a real job, and having the skills leaned during Drama GCSE are great life skills.

Do you also think English Literature isn't a real GCSE?

I won't ask what you think of art or product design Grin

clary · 17/03/2021 17:29

@HypnoRuler

Id recommend a real GCSE instead; Statistics, History, IT, etc.

Yes, I favour STEM over arts anyday.

Drama is a real GCSE actually.

This post is especially funny as IT GCSE hasn't existed for a few years now.

WelcomeMarch · 17/03/2021 17:33

I was a shy child (selectively mute, indeed, as a small child) but found acting out scripted lines a pleasant change from real, unpredictable interactions with people.

macaronirabbit · 17/03/2021 17:33

Is history more useful than art or french though?
Surely its subjective?

Newgirls · 17/03/2021 17:35

I have actively recruited people with drama skills as they can communicate. Needed even in stem would you believe 🙄

LIZS · 17/03/2021 17:36

Best to pick what she can do well in though, drama can be a difficult subject to get top grades in.

clary · 17/03/2021 17:37

Wow at your next post! Art GCSE is pretty useful if you want to pursue a career in design or many other creative options.

French is considered valuable as a rule even by those who science so called softer subjects!

Op, as long as your dd is doing the core subjects (she will be) then GCSE drama (or art, or PE, or textiles, or French, or German, or sociology, or music!) will be fine in terms of her future career prospects, honest.

In terms of her shyness, dd dud drama GCSE and loved it the best, tho this was partly to do with her lovely group and teacher, which of course you cannot control.

She used to act a lot and sing on stage, but in fact she had (and still has) massive social anxiety. She says that when she is on stage it's different. I don't know how that compares to your DD's shyness, may not be similar at all but I just offer it up.

Andi2020 · 17/03/2021 17:38

It is very hard.
My dd has been doing drama since age 9 out off school not shy loves performing but found GCSE drama difficult got a b in GCSE.
And the person who said it not a real subject that is an insult to people who do this as a teacher or actress.

clary · 17/03/2021 17:40

even by those who favour so called softer subjects that was a crazy auto correct.

My last post was directed mainly at @HypnoRuler btw

skeggycaggy · 17/03/2021 17:40

Given the curriculum is so boring, I think using the 2/3 choices you have to do something you love is a pretty good idea to try to lighten things up a bit.

I honestly believe GCSEs are pretty irrelevant pretty quickly. Do you really think you get jobs based on having IT GCSE instead of Drama GCSE? I don’t even put my GCSEs on job applications these days, just highlight that I have Maths & English Confused

mumonthehill · 17/03/2021 17:43

My ds will be doing biology, chemistry, physics, maths, geography, history , rs, English lit and Lang, welsh so I actually think drama is a great addition to that list and see it has a very valuable gcse.

PositiveNegative · 17/03/2021 17:44

She should do it if she enjoys it, thinks it would be a nice change from desk-based subjects, and is comfortable with it being a bit of a challenge.

I'm sure she's doing other courses as well.

I did a LOT of GCSEs and really enjoyed art as it was workshop-based with music on and such a relief from other subjects!

MissYouStarlightExpress · 17/03/2021 18:06

Ds is doing drama and computer science as his options. He wanted to do something he sees as fun, there is a lot of written work but he enjoys that part too.

He's relatively quiet but he has a great drama class who are all really keen and his teachers are fantastic.