Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Paper books or electronic copies?

10 replies

mmzz · 13/09/2017 09:17

Does anyone have an opinion about whether its better, worse or just the same to have an e-book on the internet or a traditional text book that you can write on etc when revising for GCSEs or other exams?

The school is offering e-book access, which is cheaper for them obviously, but is it just as good for GCSE revision?

OP posts:
Allthebestnamesareused · 13/09/2017 12:02

If the school is issuing the book in hard copy it will be collected in for the next year group and thus you cannot write on it anyway.

If you want your child to be able to write on it you will need to buy your own hard copy.

Therefore the school is correct to offer the e format and spend the much needed funds they save elsewhere.

Ttbb · 13/09/2017 12:27

I've always preferred hard copy books.

Kazzyhoward · 13/09/2017 12:50

Many "e-books" are nothing more than an on-screen PDF style version of the paper version, and in my opinion, are awful to use. My son complained about using them and I just dismissed him as whinging until I looked at a topic with him and realised how annoying and distracting it was.

In particular, they havn't been designed to be read on a single screen, whereas a text book is designed to have two pages open. For the book, you may have a diagram or photo on the left with description or narrative on the right - exactly how it was designed. Transfer that to a screen and you have to constantly flick forward and back from one screen to another.

That's just one problem. There are many others, such as with a paper version, you can copy a particular page and write on it, annotate it, etc., but you can't usually print a page from an e-book, i.e. no "print" or "copy" nor "save" options leaving you with the only alternative of the printscreen button which then means you have to resize, crop, etc.

At the end of the day, I believe it just makes things harder for the child, and anything that makes things harder isn't good when they need a rocket up their arse to do the work anyway!

I've bought hard copies of several text books which the school have only provided via e-books. My computer literate/savvy son, who spends most of his waking hours attached to his ipad will reach to the bookshelf for his homework rather than click onto the e-books - that says it all!

Kazzyhoward · 13/09/2017 12:51

you cannot write on it anyway

Of course not, if the school want it back, but you can fill it with post-in notes.

TheNotSoGoodWife · 13/09/2017 12:53

Dc1 is studying Eng Lit A level and has her reading list as both kindle (to read when she's out) and paperback (to annotate). It is dearer but it works for her.

mmzz · 13/09/2017 13:10

Thanks for the replies. No, you are right, he couldn't write on the paper book unless I buy it (which i just did). Previously I thought he'd be using post-its and sticky page markers on the school copy.
The school seem to think revising off an e-book is ok, but thinking about it, I don't believe that its just me being old-fashioned when I say its not as good. So, i bought the books a few minutes ago.

OP posts:
TeenTimesTwo · 13/09/2017 13:24

My reason against e-books would be that they would then have electronics switched on which would be more tempting to 'just check' social media etc. I know they need to be online for certain things, but keeping the temptation away is helpful.

mmzz · 13/09/2017 13:27

That's a good point, TeenTimesTwo. DS doesn't even need to check - he gets various notifications flashing on the screen whenever anyone posts anything or when BBC sport has anything to say. So, it will be a constant distraction. It will be far better if he leaves all devices downstairs and works in his bedroom undistracted for an hour.

OP posts:
Bekabeech · 13/09/2017 13:37

Some ebook textbooks are far more than just PDF versions of the paper one. They can have embedded videos, electronic quizzes, and other ways to explain or test the material. So if you're not sure then I'd ask more info and if you can "see before you buy".
Books for English though - much better as a paper copy.

Kazzyhoward · 13/09/2017 13:38

Not to mention, heaven forbid, if the internet was down as you wouldn't be able to access your text books.

A couple of years back, with Storm Desmond, our area lost power for about four days. DS took the initiative and did loads of homework, revision, etc (as he was bereft without his ipad!). That was only possible due to having paper books. Yes, I know that's not a common occurrence but it really highlights over-dependency on our electronic "crutches", which is crazy when not really necessary.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page