Active discussions

Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Scotsnet

Welcome to Scotsnet - discuss all aspects of life in Scotland, including relocating, schools and local areas.

Original poster

Q Mannivan “rape is a spectrum”

52 replies

Helpmaboa · 08/08/2026 18:09

Has anyone else seen this? I didn’t believe it could be true, even for the Greens, so searched for it, and lo and behold it seems to be an actual interview

A video interview from YouTube last year

There are also comments about “different modes of consent”

Surely this is now too much? If it’s true

https://x.com/joelandland/status/2086060973807255786?s=46&t=9nUj9BEk_qVJghGVBCwIRQ

Allan Joe Land (@JoelandLand) on X

@DownWithTheSNP https://t.co/cIdCisoTW8 The full podcast. Clip is from around 25:30mins

https://x.com/joelandland/status/2086060973807255786?s=46&t=9nUj9BEk_qVJghGVBCwIRQ

OP posts:
Original poster
Helpmaboa · 18/08/2026 21:04

NullaEffugium · 18/08/2026 19:40

I’ve asked for a transcript, @OtterlyAstounding couldn’t find one either but did transcribe some of it for me. So there isn’t a version to read for those of us who can’t really watch/listen.

However, the main gist of the issues are there, if you’d care to discuss them. I’ve reread your posts and there is a lot of judgement without explanation as to your thought process or views.

dangerous to witter shite in an effort to sound deep and intellectual about subjects that are in fact very clear cut. These are the kind of vague comments you have made.

talking pure shite and giving the impression that there is a sliding scale of rape and indeed consent. - except we learned that the rape as a spectrum comment was said with the disclaimer this doesn’t mean a sliding scale of less to most bad. And there hasn’t been anything indicating a sliding scale of consent only that consent is affected by situations and circumstances- which again is true.

I really enjoyed talking with other posters who have taken the time to consider the topic in some depth and give reasoned replies. Thank for for starting the thread OP. It’s too bad you don’t seem to want to have an intellectual discussion or consider perhaps the issue is not as clear cut when you look beyond the surface.

Show quote history

I’ll discuss it with you when you know what was said

OP posts:
NullaEffugium · 19/08/2026 13:51

Helpmaboa · 18/08/2026 21:04

I’ll discuss it with you when you know what was said

Show quote history

You mean everything that was said because I do know some of what was said. What about the other posters who do know everything that was said, you’ve not engaged in discussion with them either. Why is that?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page