An hour’s detention or a few days off school as a suspension is in no way a deterrent.
These children who behave violently would be sat laughing at not having to conform to any rules for a few days. And if it’s just a detention given, they smirk or swear at the teacher as they walk out of school anyway because they aren’t bothered. And then when the teacher rings home, the parents give a barrage of abuse down the phone or worse still, come storming into school swearing, calling the teacher all the expletives under the sun and saying the teacher is a liar. You can’t physically hold the children, you can’t punish them, SLT are unavailable so you have to evacuate the entire rest of the class in a violent episode. The learning of all of the other children is ended for the full lesson because they can’t get back on track. Any particular innocent victim is traumatised and becomes fearful of school. I’ve had to remove detentions countless times because OFSTED apparently won’t like the amount of sanctions we have given out, and it looked ‘worse’ in my dept as we gave out more (because we tried to deal with the behaviour) so we as teachers became monitored for our own performance.
This happened to me on more than a handful of occasions, and these weren’t even from especially violent children.
Teachers are there to teach. If a child can’t behave reasonably well (not perfectly, they can’t all get it right all the time), they need specialist help, whether that is being in specialist school, have 1-1 support, behaviour support available at all times and lose the rules regarding consequences such as when the suspension ends, they can’t get another one straight away. I can’t see any of this happening, largely due to money, but it’s so wrong. School should be safe learning environment for everyone and what a travesty that it’s not.
I’ve since left the profession.