Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

and yet another MIL thread... my mum is becoming MIL parody to my SIL. it really upsets me! what if anything can i do??

8 replies

wisheveryonecouldjustgeton · 09/12/2008 10:10

sorry this is going to be long - i'd really appreciate peoples' thoughts on this cause i'm obsessing about it

my parents first DGC was born a year ago to my brother. i had their second DGC three months later. before becoming a grandma, my mum was always the most non-judgemental, tactful fair person. lately this has changed and it really upsets me. it so out of character.

the way she is with me is dif to the way she is with my SIL.

my mum and i are struggling to negotiate our relationship now i ama mum. its difficult, but we doing ok. i feel like my mum will never be as involved in our lives as she wants to be - but short of her moving in and becoming a full time nanny, there's nothing i can do to remedy that . i find it upsetting that everytime we speak on the phone i have to say no to her coming up to stay all the time. before dd came along, we got together every other month or so. now its about every three weeks. aside from that the other thing i find frustrating is that she now treats me like a child again - before i was a professional woman with a great career and we had a great relationship. now she babies me and treats me like a bit of an idiot. we have come to blows a couple of times,but cause she's my mum, i can knock it on the head. like i say, we doing ok. tho i have been surprised by how different she seems to how she was before dd came along. its def been tough.

pheeewwww.... so thats me. now for my SIL. i always wondered about people who slagged off their MIL, and always reckoned there were prob two sides of the story. now i can see how it all happens. my mum is clearly v nervous around my SIL and says stupid stuff - its like every MIL parody. it really upsets me cause its so unlike her. i also worry that it is only going to get worse.i hate seeing my family being unhappy.

ever since my brother got together with SIL, my parents have been held at arms length and it got a lot worse after their dd was born. initally my mum was the model of fairness and refusal to judge that she's always been, but thats changed as the months have passed. i know she says silly stuff cause she's nervous, and when i have talked to her about it she says she worries about "being interesting enough" .

BUT recently - she quizzed my SIL on whether she had got round to sending thank you cards to relatives who'd send their dd birthday presents (SIL is always v prompt with cards) and most of all.

my mum recently said to SIL that i was "so tired from being pregnant that i was even considering feeding dd with food from jars." this last comment as you can imagine really uspet me. i only talk to dh and my mum (cause shes a foodie) about feeding dd. i love cooking for her but would never judge how anyone fed their kids, ever. if you asked anyone who knew me how i fed dd they would not really know except that whenever we're out i always seem to give her avacado. i certainly never said to my my mum that comment re jars so why would she say it??

if i was going to be totally honest, i would say that the thing that i fear the most is having my "perfect mum" vision shattered. she's so different to how she was before DGCs came along.

sorry this is long and boring. i just really want someone to chat to about this

OP posts:
Uriel · 09/12/2008 10:14

I wonder if you could get her that 'good grandmother' book that's out. I forget the title of it but I think it's supposed to be pretty good.

wisheveryonecouldjustgeton · 09/12/2008 10:19

this one? anyone read it?

OP posts:
KewcumbersRoastingOnAnOpenFire · 09/12/2008 10:23

My mother went a bit nuts whenDS came home. They seem to revert to being mothers and have no experience of being a grandmother. It takes a littel while for them to find their "grandmother" shaped role but if she is inherently asensible woman she probably will. Can you talk to your SIL about it - does she find it a problem?

Uriel · 09/12/2008 10:28

That's the one, wish, thanks.

Agree with Kew - chatting to SIL might help.

AbricotsSecs · 09/12/2008 10:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

wisheveryonecouldjustgeton · 09/12/2008 10:30

my mum and SIL have never been bezzy mates. i know she will have found these comments upsetting, she mentioned the food one to my DH. i find my SIL difficult, tbh, and cant help but think that it is not one way and that if she made any kind of effort with my mum then my mum would relax a lot more and the silly comments would stop. BUT i make a huge effort with my mum and she has started saying stupid stuff to me so that slightly undermines my argument. i dont know, i could list things bro and SIL have done to upset family but that would be fruitless and and its larlgy just me motivated by defending my mum so not objective

OP posts:
doodleduck · 11/12/2008 09:09

Was really interested in your email. Am only 24 weeks preg with 1st child and already I've sensed some changes from MIL. MIL already has 3 grands from her own daughter's side. So far our relationship has been polite. I make a point of never getting involved in any arguments or anything like that. We live 2 1/2 hours away from them whereas SIL lives down the road. So when she sees SIL's kids it's little at a time and she actually gets to help out with childcare etc... which is nice for her. We're not besties and TBH she makes me quite uncomfortable as she can be quite pushy about things like visiting etc ... However, I always try to find sth to talk about on neutral territory. Now I realise that neutral territory isn't going to exist anymore!!

When we announced I was pregnant she immediately said she wanted to come to hospital the next day to see the baby. The next things were quizzing me on my diet and comments on how small my bump was. Am v. small and my bump is also small. At 24 weeks some people at work still hadn't quite realised I was preggers.
Since then it's been weekly/twice weekly phonecalls to hubby to enquire about the state of my bump. At the weekend we met up with in laws and again all MIL wanted to look at was my bump. When they'd got home I was rewarded by a phonecall to say that 'they were very pleased to see the bump was growing'. During the party, she suddenly sat next to me and she was obviously very nervous about asking enquired about when I would be starting maternity leave and said she might come on the train with a friend of hers who's got family near us to see us for a day (week day). Now I would be on leave but not hubby which means that if she comes down she'll be expecting him to take a day off (?) or does she want to see me on my own (?). Not entirely sure of the thought processs there. I had to remind her that her son works and that it might not be a good idea for her to come during the week. I couldn't face a day on my own with her. She also keeps mentioning how SIL invited her to the 20-week scan for one of the grandkids (she conveniently doesn't mention the other 2 where she wasn't invited) as if to suggest we're excluding her. There have been loads of other loaded comments.

SIL was there when we were having this conversation and I made it clear to MIL that she needed to arrange the visits with her son not me. I felt SO awkward but I thought I had to do it. Relationship with SIL is much better and I love her kids so am hoping that SIL is able to talk to MIL to get her to see some sense.

I have no family in the UK and it's my first -- I'm v. aware that I haven't got a clue but take the stance that I'll learn as I go along. So far my biggest source of stress has been MIL. Hubby is likely to go and visit on his own until baby arrives because of how it makes me feel.

Sorry long story - but yes talk to your SIL to see how she feels. Might also be worth talking to your own mother (does she do humour?) -- she might realise that she's being silly but not want to admit it!

ElizabethCM · 11/12/2008 10:17

i guess all mothers whose children marry become, to some extent, the dreaded MIL! my own mother says that it is very difficult not to interfere because, for so long, interfering has been her job! for so many years it was her duty to teach us, ,give us instruction, lie awake worrying about us , and generally be involved in every part of our lives. then "overnight" because child gets married/ gives birth/ has great job that is no longer allowed. and mother must now stand back. according to my mum (who, btw, NEVER interferes) it is the most "difficult part of being a mother so far".

i'm not excusing mil behaviour (see my MIL thread from earlier!) but i guess i can understand it more now after thinking about that aspect. cannot imagine NOT being around when own dd has a child... will probably be MIL from hell and have mumsnet pages dedicated to my horrorfying behaviour

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread