Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Is it time to accept my marriage is over despite him being a great dad?

44 replies

mumoftwosurrey · 19/10/2026 14:07

I’m not really sure what I’m hoping to get from posting this, but I think I need some outside perspectives because I feel completely lost.
DH and I have been together for 9 years, married for 5, and have two children under 4.
Firstly, I want to say that he is a genuinely wonderful dad. He absolutely adores our children, and I would choose him to be their father over and over again. That’s what makes this all so difficult.
But as a marriage, I feel like there is absolutely nothing left.
If I’m being completely honest with myself, I think I’ve had doubts for a very long time. When he proposed, rather than feeling overwhelmingly excited, I remember feeling a slight sense of dread. But he felt like a solid, dependable choice. Someone I could build a life and family with, and I thought that was enough.
Since having the children, things have deteriorated massively. I’ve struggled with exhaustion, both physically and mentally, and he is completely emotionally detached. Whenever I mention that I’m feeling unwell or exhausted, he rolls his eyes or acts as though I’m being dramatic. There is absolutely no emotional support.
I’ve recently been diagnosed with ADHD, which he thinks is a load of rubbish. The other day I came down with a sickness bug, and his immediate reaction was to swear under his breath because it was clearly an inconvenience to him. I just feel like I can’t be vulnerable around him because I’m met with irritation rather than kindness.
We’ve also had a huge amount of financial and emotional strain. He’s been made redundant three times in four years, which has been incredibly stressful. He also has a very problematic relationship with alcohol. He binge drinks and eats junk food, then spends the following days in a foul mood. He’s started getting into the habit of going to the pub for a drink before nursery pickup and sometimes taking our daughter to the pub after collecting her. I find the whole pattern increasingly difficult to deal with, particularly when it affects his mood and our family life.
We sleep in separate rooms and have done for some time. There is virtually no affection, and when there is, it generally feels like it’s because he wants sex. I’ve become so detached that I don’t think I feel any romantic attraction towards him anymore.
The other night we had a very frank conversation and both admitted that we feel completely over the relationship. We talked about how there’s simply nothing left in the tank and how neither of us feels particularly happy.
But since that conversation, he’s suddenly started making an effort to cuddle me, touch me and be affectionate. I know that probably sounds like exactly what I’ve been asking for, but the awful truth is that it’s giving me the ick. I don’t want him touching me. I feel terrible saying that because I know he’s probably trying, but I think I’ve spent so long feeling emotionally unsupported and disconnected that something in me has just switched off.
I genuinely don’t know whether this is something we could come back from, or whether I’ve simply reached the point where I’m done.
The biggest thing keeping me here is the children. They adore their dad, he adores them, and the thought of breaking up their family absolutely devastates me. I also feel terribly guilty because there is no huge dramatic event that’s caused this. It’s just years of feeling lonely, unsupported and increasingly unhappy.
I don’t hate him. I don’t even particularly dislike him. I just don’t think I’m in love with him anymore, and I’m not sure I ever felt the way I should have.
I feel like I’m going through the motions of being married because it’s what we’re supposed to do, rather than because I actually want to be with him.
Has anyone been in a similar position, particularly with very young children? Did you manage to rebuild things, or did you eventually accept that the marriage was over?
And how do you reconcile leaving someone who is a genuinely good father but no longer feels like a partner?
I feel horribly selfish even contemplating it, but I’m only 35 and the thought of spending the rest of my life in a marriage without affection, emotional connection or love feels incredibly sad.

OP posts:
Jk987 · 19/10/2026 17:02

I knew when I read the title that he would
not be an amazing Dad and I was right. So
if you feel guilty about that you don’t need to. A good Dad makes sure the mother of his children is treated well full stop.

Co parenting might work out better. I do understand it’s really hard with children to think of though.

LizzieSiddal · 19/10/2026 17:12

@mumoftwosurrey

It’s great you’ve written it all down and posted here, can you honestly read back what you’ve said and have any doubt that you need to separate?

The bottom line is he is NOT a nice person, don’t waste your life with him and don’t let your dc grow up thinking his behaviour is acceptable. He is NOT a good dad because good dads are not unkind to their wives when they are ill and they do not think it’s ok to drive a car whilst drunk.

BarbaraUsher · 19/10/2026 17:47

Why has be been made redundant so often? I know that job market can be tough, but this does seem a little bit unusual with everything else you’ve explained

mumoftwosurrey · 19/10/2026 17:55

He worked in small startups in a niche industry. It was unfortunate

OP posts:
cartagenagina · 19/10/2026 17:58

It’s over. I can’t imagine how you think he’s a great father. He can’t even collect his kids up sober. 🙄

TFImBackIn · 19/10/2026 18:19

There is no way on this earth that I would let him have them unsupervised. As for 50:50, I'd fight in court over that. I hope that nursery staff report him for picking her up drunk.

BeenThereBackThen · 19/10/2026 18:34

Honestly, you will feel more supported by 4 walls around you after you leave him than this.
No emotional warmth, no connection, worrying about his drinking (and driving), worrying whether he will keep the next job - that’s no way to live your next 40+ years. Kids will grow up and leave and you will have him all to yourself, how does that make you feel? I feel dread on your behalf.

EverybodyLTB · 19/10/2026 19:10

Seek legal advice, even if that’s just googling to begin with. Financially he’d be expected to contribute, you wouldn’t be left destitute and could possibly be eligible for Universal Credit if you have a shortfall. His wage now will probably take you over the threshold, but separated you’d probably be entitled to something by the sounds of it. He’s awful, literally awful. He will pretend he wants 50:50, they all do, it’s a script.

Inthemiddleofthenightagain · 19/10/2026 19:48

My point is different to the others, I have no children for example. But when I was married (which I shouldn't have been!), I didn't fancy him anymore, he was lazy, unaffectionate etc etc. I said I wanted us to split. Later he then started to be affectionate, doing things around the house (he'd never done anything), all this gave me the real ick, and I felt angry, I didn't actually want him to be better, I just needed it to be over.
Wondering if this might be a small part of it?

Zanatdy · 19/10/2026 20:21

Whenever I read posts on here that say they are great fathers, they really are not. Drinking before pick up and taking a young child to the pub is not a good father. You will probably be entitled to UC to help, though may not be able to afford to own your own home, but don’t stay for financial reasons. I rented for many years after splitting when kids were young but now own my own home again.

IDontCareWhatMyUsernameIs · 19/10/2026 20:52

I separated from my ‘good dad’ husband 18 months ago; he also likes a drink. Doesn’t get drunk but drinks more than I think is healthy or right when you have children.

Now my teenage son phones me from his house asking for money because his dad won’t give him a fiver but takes himself to the pub three nights a week when the kids are at his.

These men…you can’t change them.

OMGDidYouSayThat · 19/10/2026 21:05

I’m in no fit state to give you advice about whether you should stay and give it a go or leave as i’m in a similar position where i’m staying for my kids, all i will say is don’t let finances be the reason why you stay, because you’re married with dependants you won’t leave with nothing. Good luck. Big hugs 🤗

mumoftwosurrey · 19/10/2026 21:18

So we spoke tonight and he just can’t understand why having ‘only a pint’ before picking up our daughter is problematic. Thank you for all the advice and support today 🤍

OP posts:
Poppedforgum · 19/10/2026 21:19

mumoftwosurrey · 19/10/2026 21:18

So we spoke tonight and he just can’t understand why having ‘only a pint’ before picking up our daughter is problematic. Thank you for all the advice and support today 🤍

Edited

And taking your daughter to the pub afterward. No words

IDontCareWhatMyUsernameIs · 19/10/2026 22:12

mumoftwosurrey · 19/10/2026 21:18

So we spoke tonight and he just can’t understand why having ‘only a pint’ before picking up our daughter is problematic. Thank you for all the advice and support today 🤍

Edited

Well, he’s not entirely stupid so he knows it’s not right or normal. So he’s a lying alcoholic.

monymonymony · 19/10/2026 23:03

You mentioned you don't know where you'd be financially if not for him, you can check what you'd be entitled to in terms of Universal Credit online. But to be honest I'd give it a couple more years and leave when your children are in school. He's an alcoholic and sounds horrid but the practicalities of moving out with 2 children under 4 are just as horrendous. I also don't think he sounds like a particularly good dad, maybe only if you compare his treatment of his children to his treatment of you. I'm surprised no one from that pub has called social services yet. Given the dead bedroom aspect of your relationship I have a feeling if you stay for one more year he'll probably leave you which will make everything a lot easier.

Mancity08 · 20/10/2026 00:13

It’s not just the after work drinking though is it ?
over the years he has been unemotionally committed to you, rolling his eyes when you say something. Tutting when you mention you don’t feel well etc etc .
who would not be attracted and attached dh/dp treated you like that.
He’s mentally worn you down over the years I wonder your not interested.

35 your so young, put all your effort into getting out off this sham relationship.
Hes being nice now (for how long ??) because he’s realised how you’ve been feeling and had a panic moment

StarCourt · 20/10/2026 00:58

Which part of him is a wonderful dad??

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread