Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Controlling him or stubborn me?

30 replies

sandwoman · 29/06/2008 16:22

I have been with my partner for around 2 years. I have 2 children to previous relationship aged 10 and 12.

I was a single parent for a long time before getting with DP so I'm not sure if it's just me being set in my ways or signs of controlling behaviour from him.

The first thing was that I was due to enter a martial arts competition a year or so after we met. He was really against it saying I might get hurt, it was stupid of me to enter and he didn't want me doing it. I told him I had been involved in martial arts for a long time before I knew him and was confident enough to enter and know I wouldnt get too hurt, if at all. I apreciated his opinion but it would have no bearing on the situation, I would be entering. He could choose to either come and support me or stay completely uninvolved in my hobby...I was happy either way. He said I was stubborn and acting unfairly but decided to come to support me anyway.

The second one involved me buying a car, I always wanted a new primera. He didn't like them and tried his hardest to put me off saying they're ugly, hard to drive, badly made...I said I wanted one and would be buying one whether he liked it or not, my money, my choice. He said I needed to learn to compromise but why?? I work for my money, surely I should be able to buy what I want when I want? I wasn't expecting him to drive it.

Now the third one has caused a huge rift between everyone involved. I told him I fancied taking the kids to New York for a week, would he like to come too. He said "Yes, but not yet". I said "when then?" and he said "dunno, not really thought about it" So I told him I was looking to book by the end of the month, did he want to come with us or not... he said he wasn't sure if he could afford it.

Anyway to cut a long story short, he then went out and bought a playstation 3 with a load of games for £400...from that I assumed he had the money all of a sudden ( ) so asked him again, "do you want to go or not? I'm ready to book..." so he said "don't know yet" so I booked for me and the kids and we are due to fly in October. He was furious, said I was selfish, said it was a stupid, dangerous thing to do and he would "not let me go" I reminded him that I was not asking for his permision and WOULD be going. He then went around my family telling them what I'd done and turned them against me, my mum said I was stupid going to NY alone and that "anything could happen" and one family member even said I was putting the kids lives at risk "just to prove a point".

I'm sick to death of the whole thing, surely if I want to go somewhere I should just go? since when do you need permision just because you're in a relationship?

Or have I been single so long that I can't see I'm being overly stubborn and selfish??

OP posts:
Pheebe · 30/06/2008 16:53

It sounds to me liek you BOTH need to start thinking/working together rather than viewing yourselves as cohabiting adults. TBH its probably both him being 'controlling' as in wanting to have some control/input in the relationship and you bein stubborn as in not wanting to give up your independence. Doesn't make either of you wrong.

The martial arts thing - he was in the wrong imo but could it have been his clumsy way of trying to be the protective male

The car - its a big expense, did he see it as a something that should have been a family purchase and therefore a joint decision

The holiday - you asked him if he wanted to come with you and the kids. Could he have heard 'do you want to tag along on our trip'. TBH I wouldn't have wanted to. The going round you family part is totally wrong (again imo) but could have come from his frustration at having no say at all in what should have been a family decision (I accept you gave him opportunities to have his say in when but the way it was presented may have been the problem). Why your family have sided with his pov is beyond me.

It would be easy to dismiss this as simply his controlling behaviour. But if you want your relationship to work I think you need to look beyond that and find a way to work as a couple rather than 'him and his money' and 'me, my kids and my money'. It sounds to me like he is being asked to go along with whatever your decisions are and is reacting by behaving like a child - not right but understandable surely.

Hope that makes sense and helps you moving forward

Anne76 · 01/07/2008 12:19

Sounds totally controlling & unreasonable (bullying even) to me...

New York is a perfectly safe city - they've had a huge crcak-down over the past few years & have increased police visibility on the streets.
Was there a month ago and would have no hesitation in taking much smaller children than yours there quite happily.

There are far more dangerous places here in the UK...!

£400 on games?!?! Am assuming he didn't ok the purchase with you beforehand? So it's ok for him to spend his money as he sees fit, but not for you to do the same?

Doesn't really sound like a recipe for a long-term happy relationship to be honest....
You either need to agree that you both entitled to financial independence, or both of you must discuss expenditure in advance..... or get out of the relationship?

NewlyMarried · 01/07/2008 17:20

Controlling!!

Go to NY, have a great time, the kids will come back and tell EVERYONE what a fab time they had!

Your partner should be supporting you, not trying to control you. Well done for being independent, lots of real men would find that hugely attractive and would be so excited to accompany you to somewhere fantastic like that and not shitting on your ideas. I think you are giving your kids a great example....a mum that does martial arts and takes them to New York, ffs!!!! You go girl!

Hope you have a great time!!

Kimi · 01/07/2008 17:27

He is controlling.

Twelvelegs · 01/07/2008 17:30

You sound like a brilliant mother, super strong and independent.... stay that way.
He is controlling.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page