Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Am I wrong to leave over years of distance and poor communication?

17 replies

Aussiemum87 · 05/05/2026 09:49

I’m 38 and partner is 42. We have 3 kids , 20, 9 and 3. We haven’t been together for the whole 20 years but have come together and broken up a handful of times.
I think to put it simply, we just don’t get along. He’s a seemingly good Dad, and good partner most of the time but there’s things that put distance between us , mostly on my side. He’s very happy to just ignore things as long as I don’t express a problem.

There isn’t a particular thing that comes between us but more a pattern of things.
A few of the things that bother me are things like:

Has never once sang me happy birthday on my birthday. My mum and dad and sisters generally have a small gathering for me (well we all do it for each others birthdays) and not once in 20 years has my partner sang happy birthday with everyone else. He sits in silence.

He isn’t big on holidays but for example this past Christmas, he unwrapped his presents from me which I actually thought he would love and he just opens them, doesn’t say a word, doesn’t smile , just puts them down beside him. It’s been like that for years with holidays and birthdays.

We each have our own dogs, but his dog is a large Rottweiler who I don’t feel confident walking on my own. My dog is small so she gets walked a lot and taken out of the house frequently. His dog never ever leaves the yard. He doesn’t feed the dog, doesn’t play with the dog. Nothing. I interact with the dog a lot because I do like him , he’s lovely , just very big and heavy. So I’m happy to look after him but it’s so irritating that it’s fallen on me. And if I try to bring it up , he gets defensive and I get the silent treatment for a week.
I do also ask him if he wants to go for a walk at least once a week , we could take the dogs and go to the park with the kids but it’s always no. Always.

One recent incident, he left for work, slammed his car door, and accelerated his car really forcefully out of the drive way. I thought he’s obviously annoyed about something but I’ll leave him to cool down for an hour or so then call to see if he’s ok. I call and he says ‘nothing I’m fine.’ He proceeds to be icey and quiet for the next week. We then go to our couples therapy session (which I’d initiated a few months earlier) and I brought up the incident and he said yea I was annoyed because you through out my old tax return and I saw it in the bin. The lack of communication really gets to me.

another recent incident was where I had something on , on the coming weekend so I asked him if he had anything on too, if he could sort out his Mum to watch the kids. He says back to me ‘don’t worry, I never plan anything on the weekends, because you’re never around anyway.’ I try and invite him to things and I have done for 20 years but after about 19 of those years of him saying no, and just wanting to watch TV, I stopped and I just do things without him. I generally include the kids in my weekend activities too which is the most annoying part of his reply.

None of those things alone are terrible. But it’s the pattern and things like this have been happening for years and years. I thought counselling would help but it seems to have only made him more withdrawn. For years he’s been telling me I’m bad at communicating but I think he was projecting. I do communicate, but as soon as I do , he withdraws and I get silent treatment.

I can’t cope with the miserableness anymore. I don’t know what to do because it’s not one awful thing that’s happened, and I would feel guilty leaving because of small things.
Has anyone experienced a similar partner and found a good solution?

OP posts:
EstrellaPolar · 05/05/2026 09:53

None of those things alone are terrible.

I disagree, I think each and every one of those things are terrible in a partner, individually. Not sure why you don’t think they are.

We have read all about his unpleasant attributes. What are the good ones? Why are you with him?

KidsDoBetter · 05/05/2026 09:56

He sounds grim and lacking in joy. I’d leave. The happy birthday singing is one that wouldn’t bother me. Sounds generally though that he really dislikes you.

EstrellaPolar · 05/05/2026 09:58

For years he’s been telling me I’m bad at communicating but I think he was projecting. I do communicate, but as soon as I do , he withdraws and I get silent treatment.

You’ve hit the nail on the head here. You try to communicate, but he has no interest in it. He doesn’t seem that interested in you/his family either, sorry. How is he with the kids? Is he approachable, do they have good relationships with him? (Good doesn’t mean not awful, good means they can go to him for emotional conversations such as boyfriend/girlfriend for your older one, exam stress, job or life outlook worries, friendships, etc…).

You are allowed to leave because of small things. It sounds as if the small things have all been snowballing and become this massive weight that sits on your shoulders, is ever-present in your living room and makes walking about freely in your own home, difficult. The giant ball is made up of “small” things, but it’s become so big, it’s now in everybody’s way. It’s okay to kick the giant ball out, otherwise you soon won’t have any space to walk around it.

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 05/05/2026 09:58

OP the only thing you have done wrong is to stay with this lump for as long as you have. Get his bags packed and get him out the door.

vincettenoir · 05/05/2026 09:58

I think you’re already doing what you can to increase communication: initiating counselling; asking him about his feelings; inviting him for walks. But unfortunately you can’t make this work on your own.

mrscoreytaylor · 05/05/2026 09:58

God life is too short to be putting up with this joyless man, set yourself free op, you’ll feel much better for it.

AnticsNShenanigans · 05/05/2026 10:00

He sounds awful. Miserable, ungrateful, lazy, passive aggressive. Not a partner or friend or supporter to you in any way.

I’d be gone in a flash. Let him sit in all weekend watching telly and neglecting his dog, with nobody to blame for his miserable life but himself!

Purplewarrior · 05/05/2026 10:05

He sounds awful.

Aussiemum87 · 05/05/2026 10:19

EstrellaPolar · 05/05/2026 09:53

None of those things alone are terrible.

I disagree, I think each and every one of those things are terrible in a partner, individually. Not sure why you don’t think they are.

We have read all about his unpleasant attributes. What are the good ones? Why are you with him?

When things are good, he’s very pleasant. But in doing my own therapy ive realised that’s because I’m keeping my mouth closed about what bothers me.
But like next week for example , I’m going away for 5 days alone to do a workshop on a hobby I am interested in. He doesn’t have any issue with that, doesn’t cause a fuss about the kids staying home with him. And I guess that’s more than a lot of fathers would do. He doesn’t whinge about the cost of it or anything. So there is good parts, it’s not all bad.

OP posts:
FettchYeSandbagges · 05/05/2026 10:21

You are not wrong to consider ending the relationship with this horrible man. He is vile and how you've put up with him for so long, I don't know.

Being so full of misery is absolutely a good enough reason for you to split, and please do also consider your dc, who are growing up in this environment thinking behaviour like his is normal, and who may go on to replicate it in their own relationships in future.

Aussiemum87 · 05/05/2026 10:25

FettchYeSandbagges · 05/05/2026 10:21

You are not wrong to consider ending the relationship with this horrible man. He is vile and how you've put up with him for so long, I don't know.

Being so full of misery is absolutely a good enough reason for you to split, and please do also consider your dc, who are growing up in this environment thinking behaviour like his is normal, and who may go on to replicate it in their own relationships in future.

Our eldest son moved out because , and I quote ‘it’s always so miserable in this house, he’s always angry about something.’

But in saying that, all 3 kids will happily seek comfort in him and the elder two will share things with him, like things that happen at school or work so I guess the relationship between him and kids if like his and mine - either up or down. No grey area.

OP posts:
Noshadelamp · 05/05/2026 10:34

He is emotionally abusive.
Silent treatment, anger for no apparent reason, blaming you for his faults, refusing to engage etc

He's withholding love, affection and basic human courtesy.
Not even acknowledging your gifts to him is manipulative.
It's all designed to destabilise and "keep you on your toes", running in circles to please him.

It is life sapping and you deserve more. He's not going to change.

Narcissists don't like other people celebrating birthdays, the attention isn't on them and they can't bear it.

Noshadelamp · 05/05/2026 10:36

But in saying that, all 3 kids will happily seek comfort in him @Aussiemum87

Or they've learnt in order to keep him sweet they need to pander to him.
You're doing it too, not arguing or bringing up things you want to discuss to avoid more emotional abuse.
It's classic self protection living with an abuser.

SnowFrogJelly · 05/05/2026 10:39

LTB

Ihaveneedofwaternear · 05/05/2026 10:57

Aussiemum87 · 05/05/2026 10:19

When things are good, he’s very pleasant. But in doing my own therapy ive realised that’s because I’m keeping my mouth closed about what bothers me.
But like next week for example , I’m going away for 5 days alone to do a workshop on a hobby I am interested in. He doesn’t have any issue with that, doesn’t cause a fuss about the kids staying home with him. And I guess that’s more than a lot of fathers would do. He doesn’t whinge about the cost of it or anything. So there is good parts, it’s not all bad.

Him not kicking up a fuss about you going away for your hobby, parenting his own children, or how much things cost from the presumably shared pot of family money are not "good parts" or "more that what a lot of fathers would do". They are absolute basics in a respectful relationship.

It sounds like your personal therapy is helping you reflect on your standards around relationships. He sounds joyless and nasty, OP. I hope you can create a happy, enjoyable life for yourself.

moderate · 05/05/2026 12:10

Your course is clear IMO: keep going to individual therapy until it helps you realise that you need to leave him, and then leave him.

BuckChuckets · 05/05/2026 12:53

@Aussiemum87
Our eldest son moved out because , and I quote ‘it’s always so miserable in this house, he’s always angry about something.’

The moment this happened I would have taken steps to make sure he didn't break my younger children in the way he's broken my eldest. That's so sad 😢

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread