Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Leave for happiness or stay for custody

8 replies

EveSquire91 · 15/04/2026 23:32

I should probably be a little more confident in my own gut instinct by now as I’ve been here before but I really need some advice 😔 I am sat here in turmoil over what to do about my relationship of 5 years.

A very long story short I had one 8 year relationship that ended after we had a child together. We had the house, intentions of being together forever etc. once we had our baby he changed. He was never there for us, neglectful, mean, selfish beyond words. I eventually left with nothing but our clothes and a bed for us. He kept it all.

it took a lot for me to trust again but I eventually found a partner that seemed to be all the things I didn’t have from my ex. A help around the house, supportive, kind. I didn’t plan of having another baby but he hadn’t had his own and honestly my eldest is my biggest blessing so it wasn’t hard to have another with “the right person”. The promises it would be a completely different experience were made. Well it wasn’t. Not quite anyway. He shows up il give him that but since having our child he is angry, short tempered and miserable. I’ve rode it out for a long time, she is 3 in September. But my life has become miserable. The moments of fun are almost always ruined. He constantly picks at and puts down my eldest, doesn’t do anything with the kids. All he wants to do is work (we are both self employed). I work 3 days a week and pay for the nursery bill to do so but am responsible for 85% of the bills. Thank the lord I developed a skill that pays. If he has to have the kids it almost always results in a meltdown from him, whining or tears. I am constantly jumping in to save this man from the chaos he creates. Once he’s kicked off he will have a cry about it. It’s utterly exhausting. Here is the kicker…he is saying if we break up he will be having my youngest 50/50. It breaks my heart that I will potentially have to not see her for 50% of the week. I do not trust he is emotionally stable to have her. He doesn’t have his own place (I rent our house and it’s fully in my name) or anywhere safe for her to stay. He used to live with his mum who bless her is a darling but her house is full with stuff and she has dogs that are not toilet trained so it’s just not possible for her to stay there.

It Took me years to leave my first partner because I constantly held on to the small things he did do. Even now I doubt it was that bad. It’s like I cannot trust my own constant pain and unhappiness because I see tiny bits of good. My current partner does help with chores, he does show up for the kids events etc. But surely my peace is worth more than that?

I feel as if I can’t win and I would rather suffer than have my daughter suffer. Any advice of thoughts are really needed. I am sorry if this isn’t well written. My brain is fried from constantly being put in fight or flight. Rel

OP posts:
Blimms · 16/04/2026 01:01

This part “He constantly picks at and puts down my eldest” is an absolute dealbreaker. He is emotionally abusive to your child.

Oreoqueen87 · 16/04/2026 01:31

i feel for you OP, this is a horrible situation.

I chose not to leave and regret it. It will get worse and become unsustainable. My reason for not leaving is I have a child with additional needs and it’s easier to get agreement on their medical need this way. Otherwise I would be gone.

He sounds as if he won’t actually be up for looking after her and will probably just have her for the day here and there when reality hits. You might have to get through a tough but first though while he does it to punish you.

If you can access therapy to help you through this please do so.

PaperMachePanda · 16/04/2026 01:37

The moment he started picking on your eldest was the moment you should've kicked him out.

As it's only your name on the tenancy it's easy enough to boot him out. If he won't leave on his own accord then go down to your local police station and ask them to help remove him from your home (you should do this anyway).

So what if he wants 50/50. He might not get it and he'll probably lose interest anyway.

WWomble · 16/04/2026 01:47

My Mum left my Dad when I was a toddler (a long time ago). He’s a good man but tricky to live with. It was the best thing she could have done.

Could you play a longer game - set yourself up to go it alone but in the meantime keep a diary of how much he is hands on with your daughter, in the hope of fighting 50/50?

Endofyear · 16/04/2026 06:06

OP, your eldest daughter is being constantly picked on by him? This should be enough for you to kick him out! Lots of men say they want 50/50 (mainly so that they don't have to pay child support) but in reality he's unlikely to - he would have to work less and pay for nursery during his half of the time. He would have to have a secure base for her to live, not at his mother's which sounds unsafe. If I were you, I'd tell him to leave, your oldest child shouldn't have to live with someone who behaves like he does.

Mumlaplomb · 16/04/2026 07:21

Kick him out OP he is using the threat of 50/50 to keep you with him. You absolutely have a duty to protect your eldest child from his bullying.

Imbusytodaysorry · 16/04/2026 07:54

EveSquire91 · 15/04/2026 23:32

I should probably be a little more confident in my own gut instinct by now as I’ve been here before but I really need some advice 😔 I am sat here in turmoil over what to do about my relationship of 5 years.

A very long story short I had one 8 year relationship that ended after we had a child together. We had the house, intentions of being together forever etc. once we had our baby he changed. He was never there for us, neglectful, mean, selfish beyond words. I eventually left with nothing but our clothes and a bed for us. He kept it all.

it took a lot for me to trust again but I eventually found a partner that seemed to be all the things I didn’t have from my ex. A help around the house, supportive, kind. I didn’t plan of having another baby but he hadn’t had his own and honestly my eldest is my biggest blessing so it wasn’t hard to have another with “the right person”. The promises it would be a completely different experience were made. Well it wasn’t. Not quite anyway. He shows up il give him that but since having our child he is angry, short tempered and miserable. I’ve rode it out for a long time, she is 3 in September. But my life has become miserable. The moments of fun are almost always ruined. He constantly picks at and puts down my eldest, doesn’t do anything with the kids. All he wants to do is work (we are both self employed). I work 3 days a week and pay for the nursery bill to do so but am responsible for 85% of the bills. Thank the lord I developed a skill that pays. If he has to have the kids it almost always results in a meltdown from him, whining or tears. I am constantly jumping in to save this man from the chaos he creates. Once he’s kicked off he will have a cry about it. It’s utterly exhausting. Here is the kicker…he is saying if we break up he will be having my youngest 50/50. It breaks my heart that I will potentially have to not see her for 50% of the week. I do not trust he is emotionally stable to have her. He doesn’t have his own place (I rent our house and it’s fully in my name) or anywhere safe for her to stay. He used to live with his mum who bless her is a darling but her house is full with stuff and she has dogs that are not toilet trained so it’s just not possible for her to stay there.

It Took me years to leave my first partner because I constantly held on to the small things he did do. Even now I doubt it was that bad. It’s like I cannot trust my own constant pain and unhappiness because I see tiny bits of good. My current partner does help with chores, he does show up for the kids events etc. But surely my peace is worth more than that?

I feel as if I can’t win and I would rather suffer than have my daughter suffer. Any advice of thoughts are really needed. I am sorry if this isn’t well written. My brain is fried from constantly being put in fight or flight. Rel

@EveSquire91 speak to a solicitor for reassurance . I would refuse 50/50 and make him forget through the courts if he wants it.
On the reasoning of his anger and his mum messy house (if he moves there )
Sounds like he would get bored and it’s a threat .
Once you have spoken to a solicitor I’d put him out. He is using you and nasty .

mindutopia · 16/04/2026 09:20

He kicks off has a tantrum and cries when he has to look after his own child on occasion now with you there to step in and help!

Trust me, this man will not be parenting 50/50 when he properly has to do it on his own. You don’t need to worry about that.

He sounds awful and needs to go in the bin. Your children will be so grateful for a peaceful happy home.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page