Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

I'm developing strong feelings for my friend-with-benefits and keep having thoughts about being in a serious relationship with him

14 replies

ChocGateau · 27/03/2026 01:21

I'd like to ask for the perspective of MN regarding a situation I currently find myself in. I've been in a casual, friends-with-benefits relationship with a younger man for just shy of a year. I'm 53 and he is 33. When I embarked on this, I thought it was going to just be a casual thing, without any real possibility of it developing into a serious relationship. I was previously in an unhappy relationship with XH, who I divorced from at 49. This younger man who I'm currently involved with, who I think is wonderful, became a part of my life at a time when I was at a bit of low ebb in terms of confidence and overall happiness. I met him on an app. I had no experience of casual relationships before getting involved with him - I've only ever had long-term, traditional relationships. I have been meeting up with him once a week on average since May last year. We started out meeting in hotels, but we have since been going to each other's houses and frequently sleeping overnight together. The only thing I can say about the sex, without it being too steamy for MN, is that he is magnificent in the bedroom. He is very passionate, and he has shown me every time I've been with him that my pleasure is a very high priority for him. He makes the earth move for me whenever we are in bed together. It was never like that with XH or any men I was intimate with when I was younger. He is also very affectionate and appreciative of me before, during and after we DTD.

For me, it's become more than "just sex" and I've been developing strong feelings for him. Aside from the sex being great, he has been lovely to me outside of that. An example of this is that I'm currently in the early stages of menopause. He knows what it is and he hasn't been put off by this at all. I have had hot flashes a couple of times when we've been together, and he's fanned the back of my neck until it passes. He has also fixed a few things for me around the house for free that would have been a hassle for me to sort myself. He's a lovely kisser as well. I have told a close friend about him and what's been going on between us, and she will jokingly ask me things like "How are things with the toyboy?" 😄. I have never seen him as a toyboy though. In all honesty, I would love to be in an actual, traditional relationship with him. I think about him a lot even when we aren't together. He has said he thinks about me a lot too. He has variously described me as confident, classy and gorgeous, when we have been together and in texts. I am very flattered by his compliments. We text each other a lot during the week. I really look forward to seeing him and feel energised and excited whenever I'm with him.

Aside from the sex, we get along really well in general. Is this limerence or could it be more than that? Am I foolish to think this could ever be more than a casual thing? I'm a bit torn between continuing as we are and trying to suppress my feelings, or telling him and seeing if he feels the same way and would be open to having a serious, committed relationship.

OP posts:
CookingFatCat · 27/03/2026 01:34

Was it a regular dating app, did you discuss the premise of being a FWB, hence the hotels?

RavenFinch · 27/03/2026 02:04

You will have to ask him.

One thing in his mind wanting to keep things casual might be if he wants to have future children (even if he has any from previous relationships) at 33 he might see his long term plans as marrying / re-marrying and creating a new family with children.

However, this is an assumption on my part based on age guesswork only ...... the only person who can clarify this for you is him.

Riapia · 27/03/2026 02:47

If you are looking for marriage having a FWB isn’t the best way to start.

Farewelltothatid · 27/03/2026 03:21

I think you have to have a certain mentality to have FWB relationships and it sounds like sex without feelings isn't a set up that suits you.
Continuing this arrangement and trying to " supress" your feeliings for this young guy doesn't sound like the recipe for pleasure and happiness.
On the other hand I would assume that if you declare your feelings there is every likelihood he will end your arrangement because, being realistic, for a 20 year age gap to work in a committed relationship it would take a lot of dedication and love.

I'm sorry but it sounds like a no win situation to me Personally i'd just end the arrangement now before you end up getting really hurt.

Jk987 · 27/03/2026 04:22

Does he see other women?
Does he want kids at any time in the future?
Does he have his own home and independence?
Does he see himself in an age gap relationship or is there a chance he will want someone his own age long term?
I’d want to know this before considering more than FWB.

user1492757084 · 27/03/2026 04:40

Be honest with yourself.
If, in your mind, he has developed into something more than a friend who offers benefits then you need to stop the contact
.
You are no longer sticking to the arrangement.

You risk being hurt and also risk him feeling very bad at the thought of causing you heart ache if he doesn't want more commitment.

It is totally fair that a 33 year old will want something different soon. A FWB would celebrate that for them and say goodbye..

Parkrunnerlpl · 27/03/2026 04:46

It's the bonding hormones running amuck. Women can be much more affected by this than men. You are on a path to getting hurt and are reading a lot into what he's doing for you.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 27/03/2026 04:52

He’s 33. He’s too young in my opinion.

He might want children one day.

I think you’re being a bit of a silly sausage,

Of course he flatters you, he’s sleeping with you!

what you’re describing seems very fwb and nothing more.

Have you discussed sleeping with other people?

Mumdiva99 · 27/03/2026 04:56

I think you just have a conversation.
"X, I've really enjoyed our time together. But I am now ready to meet someone and fall im love. I know that isn't going to be you, so we need to stop so I have space in my life for a partner."
You keep the power.
You allow him to protest if he wants.
You give him space to walk away with no guilt - which was the original arrangement.
You keep your dignity.

It may be very hard for you. So have strategies for not calling and not begging and not going back. (Rope in a trusted friend to support you).
Otherwise you end up getting very hurt.

Remember the good - he's shown you how great sex can be.
He's reminded you that you are a sexual catch. You are attractive and desirable.

ChocGateau · 28/03/2026 20:49

I appreciate your advice MN. Unfortunately I would have to agree with a PP that I have been a bit silly. I seem to have a knack for choosing the wrong men. I wasted nearly 11 years with XH. I have now fallen for a much younger man whilst knowing that, realistically, there is almost no chance of us having a long-term, serious relationship. If I was 10-15 years younger then I could see us being together, but life doesn't work that way.

He has said he hasn't slept with any women or dated any since we started our arrangement/dalliance. He is independent and has his own home. He hasn't mentioned wanting children but it wouldn't surprise me if he wants them at some point - probably within the next few years. I obviously can't provide them. That in itself makes a relationship a non-starter. Even if he says he doesn't want kids, there is nothing to stop him changing his mind within a few years. That would just lead to worse heartbreak further down the line.

OP posts:
DefiantRabbit9 · 28/03/2026 21:15

My husband is 10 years my junior. We started off as just friends, not even friends with benefits. He bared his soul to me and said he wanted to be my boyfriend and was terrified I would run for the hills. We've been married 5 years and are expecting our first child. That never would've happened if he hadn't taken a risk and asked me for commitment.

Ask him, tell him your feelings. Prepare yourself for the answer you don't want to hear but you never know he might surprise you.

Patagonia21 · 28/03/2026 21:35

Has he ever suggested going out together, to a restaurant or day trip? Otherwise it may be that the current arrangement suits him. Do you talk about what you would each like in the future in general?

RavenFinch · 28/03/2026 21:37

ChocGateau · 28/03/2026 20:49

I appreciate your advice MN. Unfortunately I would have to agree with a PP that I have been a bit silly. I seem to have a knack for choosing the wrong men. I wasted nearly 11 years with XH. I have now fallen for a much younger man whilst knowing that, realistically, there is almost no chance of us having a long-term, serious relationship. If I was 10-15 years younger then I could see us being together, but life doesn't work that way.

He has said he hasn't slept with any women or dated any since we started our arrangement/dalliance. He is independent and has his own home. He hasn't mentioned wanting children but it wouldn't surprise me if he wants them at some point - probably within the next few years. I obviously can't provide them. That in itself makes a relationship a non-starter. Even if he says he doesn't want kids, there is nothing to stop him changing his mind within a few years. That would just lead to worse heartbreak further down the line.

Ask him @ChocGateau - ask him if he wants kids or ...... blah blah blah.

Have those conversations with him - you're already in a sort of relationship (casual) with him - you get to see him - you have the opportunity to ask him.

Also whilst 20 year gap relationships are rare, there is one celebrity example I can think of:

● Michael Ball (singer) was 27 when he met 47 year old Kathy McGowan

They have now been together more than 35 years - not married, but long term partners.

Michael Ball has said that when he committed to being with Kathy he knew he wouldn't be having children of his own - but then he could put all his time and effort into pursuing his showbiz career.

However ..... their relationship didn't start as casual FWB arrangement.

It's not the perfect example.

Another thing to consider / ask your young lover about is dates ...... dates where you do something other than just go to bed together. Ask him if he would like to see XYZ film or theatre show with you / go for a meal and drinks etc ...... is there scope within what he wants to turn your casual arrangement into proper dating ?

^ I think that might be the convo to have with him rather than putting everything on the table straight away.

FatCatPyjamas · 28/03/2026 22:14

Suppressing your feelings in order to carry on enjoying him is going to hurt you a lot in the long-term. Just be honest with him (and yourself) and be prepared to walk away.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page