Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Why'd he break it off after seeing each other for a month?

16 replies

Tcbay52 · 12/03/2026 10:55

Hey all, I want your help figuring this thing out. I was seeing a guy regularly for a month. We went on about nine or ten dates (or more like hangouts). We hung out quite often, at his place or driving in his car together. His ex had cheated on him and he had forgiven her, but they eventually broke up. He played the guitar, I sang, and we were planning to perform on the street together. There was almost no physical intimacy between us for eight dates, only during two of the last meetings at his place. He said he had previously been seeing a girl from Tinder for a month or so and realized it wasn’t right — that there was no “vibe” and also that she lied about not smoking while she did smoke. He saw it as a lie in the very beginning of the relationship and that was one of the reasons he broke it off with her. He said she got pissed.

He said he liked me, that I was pretty, and that he wanted to kiss me. I didn’t kiss him at that time. I initially saw him as a friend and wasn't that attracted to him but later on I became really into him. I wasn't initiating any physical contact though. He asked what this was leading to. He said he was unsure whether I was looking for friendship or more. He said “decide,” and “at worst our paths will part and I’ll stop trying in this way" (like grabbing my hand, cuddling, etc). He would offer me alcohol. He told me to think it over after confessing that he found me attractive. He said he "didn't know how to act" after his confession. Later, during one of our dates, we kissed passionately (he initiated it). I also stroked his hair and there was some intimacy between us. We hugged too but didn’t have sëx. After that, he started rescheduling plans. In general, he would cancel quite a lot, either because of being sick or working on his game that he's creating, training etc. I often complained to him about my ex too much and even cried once. I know I shouldn't have done that and now I regret it. During the last date he didn’t kiss me, only hugged for hello and goodbye. He pulled back and didn't text me all day until the evening.

Yesterday evening he messaged me and offered to drive over to bring me my hat I had left at his place. He wanted to talk. He said he didn’t feel the vibe with me, that I was pretty, that we both liked music, that I was talented but “you see we’re not texting each other.” He also said “a girl who goes to the gym and works out a lot is probably more my type" (I didn't really go to the gym). He said we will both focus on finding someone for us. At the end, he said, “no hard feelings?” and hugged me. He didn’t even consider friendship. On his dating profile he claimed he was looking for something long or short-term. What happened here? I kinda want to text him for closure but I'm scared I'll make a fool of myself. Should I do it? Why say all that dumb sh.t and then pull this trash? I just wish at this point I could become gay, srsly. I hate men.

OP posts:
MyFunSloth · 12/03/2026 11:01

It sounds like both of you were quite stand-offish with each other for quite a long period. When a relationship really feels right, it’s not hard - you feel naturally drawn to each other and small annoyances don’t feel like big ones.

This sounds like one to chalk up to experience. Try not to carry hate in your heart for him - it just seems you weren’t compatible. Isn’t it best to walk away with a smile?

worldshottestmom · 12/03/2026 11:12

Honestly, i would just move on. He sounded a bit one foot in one foot out after trying to rush the progression of the relationship, which he possibly felt rejected by when you didn't reciprocate at first. All of this would make me a little suspicious in the sense that things should just flow naturally and shouldn't be rushed / forced.

Also making the comment that he wants to date someone who is always in the gym would put me right off and is a little insulting. Maybe he's met someone in the gym, who knows. Either way he isn't interested anymore, accept it and move on. Don't give him the satisfaction of the "but why not me" conversation.

moderate · 12/03/2026 11:21

How old are you? To me it sounds like you're just not that into him and he's picked up on this.

Owly11 · 12/03/2026 11:21

Sounds like he was just looking for sex and didn't want to invest any more time or energy and it sounds like you were perhaps ambivalent or hard to read. A relationship relies on both parties sending signals to each other and it sounds like you either sent him mixed signals or no signals at all.

mondaytosunday · 12/03/2026 11:22

Whoa the gym comment is left field - I actually had someone say that to me (not the gym but being more into sport). And of course his next girlfriend- who he eventually married - was not into sport at all!
He just wasn’t that in to you, and you didn’t seem that in to him frankly. You weren’t ‘dating’ for a month, you were friends then he asked if you might be interested in more and your not entirely encouraging response probably out the kibosh on it.

WorstPaceScenario · 12/03/2026 11:22

After a month, simply changing your mind or just 'not feeling it' is sufficient. You're only barely getting to know one another at that point, learning about one another's personalities and values. It's the very time in a potential relationship that you're likely to learn something about the person that puts you off.

Everlil · 12/03/2026 11:26

‘He would offer me alcohol’?! Was it rubbing alcohol?! What a weird way to say that he offered you a drink (not sure what it adds to the story anyway).

Maybe it was all the hair touching that put him off?

dairydebris · 12/03/2026 11:26

He broke it off because he wasn't feeling the vibe. He told you. For a while you weren't feeling the vibe either. Perhaps he picked uo on that, perhaps not. Meh. You have closure, he wasn't feeling the vibe. Move on.

TomatoSandwiches · 12/03/2026 11:26

You both sound like really awkward people, can you just not accept you didn't like him as much as he didn't like you...
although the gym comment was dickish nothing to need closure over at all.

OrlandointheWilderness · 12/03/2026 11:27

Well he may have thought you weren’t really interested tbh - almost no intimacy in 8 dates isn’t a brilliant sign! Plus you didn’t find him attractive, didn’t want to kiss him after he told you that’s what he wanted and repeatedly complained about your ex and cried about him!
the comment about the gym is a dick comment but he’s probably trying to make up for feeling a bit rejected.
why would he say about friendship? No one is on tinder looking for mates. You meet, see if you are compatible and move on if not.
What sort of closure are you after?! Exactly what IS closure!? (Hate to say it - but are you American!?)
He said stuff like he thought you were attractive because that’s what he thought at the time, he has now spent enough time with you to think that maybe you aren’t compatible for a relationship. It’s a pretty normal scenario, no one is at fault here. I’m not quite seeing why you are thinking he’s done something so wrong? It’s a brief interaction - don’t overthink it. Move on.

Assistledoggo · 12/03/2026 11:30

He wasn’t feeling it and he broke it off.

that is literally all these is to it.

FlowerFairyDaisy · 12/03/2026 11:31

He just feel there was enough chemistry between you, wasn't attracted enough to continue dating. It happens.

If you are at the point of hating men then stop bothering with them. There are a trillion other fulfilling ways you could be spending your time and efforts.

TwistedWonder · 12/03/2026 11:33

From your OP it seems you’re very young and possibly not on the UK.

Regardless it’s 4 weeks of your life - don’t give it any more headspace and move on.

bunnypenny · 12/03/2026 11:58

He correctly determined you weren’t interested in him.

Catza · 12/03/2026 13:12

What happened was that you are both very young and it's the time of your life when dating is supposed to be fun. Can't see any fun happening here for either of you so move on to the next one.

INeedAnotherName · 12/03/2026 13:20

How old are you both? I'm getting vibes of 19 and 16.

It's normal to realise you aren't right for each other after a month. Well done him for not stringing you along.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread