Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Should I tell my adult son about his dad’s abuse when he asks?

33 replies

DressingGownDoor · 28/02/2026 10:17

My eldest doesn’t live at home (very complicated), he is autistic and lives in supported living near his dad, and his dad has been supportive mixed with incredibly unhelpful (unhelpfulness reported by social workers, not my potentially biased opinion), but my son recognises the support his dad has given him over the last year, and so do I.

Background - dad was abusive towards me mainly, the kids also to some extent. I left 10 years ago, ds1 chose not to see dad for a number of years, his younger siblings saw dad supervised at contact centre, then supervised by family members, then unsupervised for a while before some incidents made me stop contact and go back to court which took ages and ended with him being granted unsupervised contact again which went on for a couple more years very infrequently (due to dad not me) with a few more incidents and then younger kids have in the last 2 years decided not to see him as they are now young teens and able to decide for themselves. The last incident before they decided to stop seeing him involved him screaming abuse at me at pick up in front of them.

Theres a lot more but I don’t want to make this too long. In a nutshell DS1 because abusive towards me and younger siblings as he became an older teen and eventually he couldn’t live in the family home safely with us any more which is why he’s in the supported living. He has severe mental health issues.

I have been aware over the years that dad has spoken inappropriately (imo) to all the kids about the circs of the break up, accused me of lying to police, lying in court etc - unfortunately while he was convicted of assaulting a female police officer in custody, there was not enough evidence regarding me.

Ds1 told me last night that dad had told him everything, that he knows everything that happened and that it’s terrible ‘that I’m not letting the younger ones see dad, it’s so awful for dad, that I’ve lied to the younger ones about dad etc. He asked me to tell him my side since he’s an adult now. I had Ds2 beside me at the time so I said I couldn’t speak then.

In general my policy has been never to speak badly of their dad to them. More lately when the younger ones have repeated lies their dad has told them in the past, I’ve corrected them factually without going into detail, but that is all.

What should I do if/when Ds1 asks me again? He is an adult but I dont want to collude in putting him in the middle. I don’t know exactly what his dad has told him, but I don’t want to tell him all the details and frankly, since he values his dads support I don’t want to tell him anything bad about him at all really.
But Ds1 had sent me a message before he called saying I wasn’t his mum anymore, and started the call by saying it would be the last time I spoke to him because dad had told him ‘everything’
I called him back later in the evening and he didn’t mention it at all because he was deep in his special interests at the time so we just spoke about those.
DS1 does speak to his siblings from time to time, and he tends to tell stuff even if he’s been asked not to, so I think it’s likely that anything I did tell him would eventually be heard by them.

What shall I do?

OP posts:
DressingGownDoor · 28/02/2026 11:23

Lightuptheroom · 28/02/2026 11:15

I've been in a similar position. The advice was always to find out what they think they know and work from there. With your son's added needs I'd ask advice from his case worker, as doing things in an age appropriate manner might not look the same in your son's case. My son never did swallow his dad's version of events but also wanted to know the truth particularly when one girlfriend decided to claim he was 'just like his dad' which couldn't be further from the truth. Sometimes they have to 'know' to settle themselves that it wasn't something they did, it's never easy and the biggest thing is to remain as factual as you can, almost like a list rather than any emotion.

That’s very helpful. I’m sorry you’ve been through this too

OP posts:
DressingGownDoor · 28/02/2026 11:23

Iwanttocomebackasmycat · 28/02/2026 11:21

tell it factually, in an age appropriate way. Children these days know a lot about the world, and that things aren’t black or white; good or bad.
Explain that their Dad has a different view ; explain like you did to us how he justifies it and makes it convincing. But why it’s not how you and other people see things.
Explain that as he gets older, he has to be careful with what he believes.

This is helpful thanks

OP posts:
Heyhelga · 28/02/2026 11:23

Got to weigh up what benefit will the child get from knowing the back story. Will it stir up a hornets nest in teenage emotions? Will it rewaken any bad feelings from the ex?

DressingGownDoor · 28/02/2026 11:27

Heyhelga · 28/02/2026 11:23

Got to weigh up what benefit will the child get from knowing the back story. Will it stir up a hornets nest in teenage emotions? Will it rewaken any bad feelings from the ex?

Well yes. I’ve come a long way to no longer being scared of his dad like I used to be, but it’s still there at the back of my mind - if I say xyz what might it make him do.

Also - although his dad is not a good person - he has helped DS1 and I don’t want to sever that support for him in any way. He lives quite far from me now, and I can’t visit him that often for various reasons, and I can’t be there on the spot to help him when he needs it. His support workers are brilliant, but I do think that he currently needs his dad and I don’t want to mess that up

OP posts:
Heyhelga · 01/03/2026 13:02

DressingGownDoor · 28/02/2026 11:27

Well yes. I’ve come a long way to no longer being scared of his dad like I used to be, but it’s still there at the back of my mind - if I say xyz what might it make him do.

Also - although his dad is not a good person - he has helped DS1 and I don’t want to sever that support for him in any way. He lives quite far from me now, and I can’t visit him that often for various reasons, and I can’t be there on the spot to help him when he needs it. His support workers are brilliant, but I do think that he currently needs his dad and I don’t want to mess that up

All in all, I wouldn't rock the boat especially if ds is in a good place at the moment and your ex is being a good Dad. A time will come one day when you can perhaps answer any questions more truthfully in-depth but it might be best to do that when ds is in his 20s out of the hormonal teenage years.

DogAnxiety · 01/03/2026 15:09

Completely disagree, @Heyhelga . By then irrevocable damage may have been done to the op and her son’s relationship. You can give factual information to a young adult and also explain that it’s ok to be involved and see both parents. Some (not all) autistic young people will be very black and white in their thinking. The son could mean it when he says he is washing his hands of his mum. And he needs his mum to be a stable presence on his life.

DogAnxiety · 01/03/2026 15:16

Also, if the OP’s son feels the OP has lied to him in future, that is likely to go down very badly. A lot of autistic people (not all) cannot understand telling white lies or grey lies or whatever, even if the intention was to protect someone.

DressingGownDoor · 01/03/2026 18:11

This thread has been very helpful - I am intending to answer any further questions he may ask factually but minimally and hope for the best. 🤞

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page