Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

MIL/SIL, DH or me problem

7 replies

KnackeredButHere · 25/09/2025 10:37

DH and I have been together 5 years, married for 3. I have two older DC and we have one DC together.

Because I am divorced and had two children, MIL heavily disapproved from the outset and was not subtle with it. DH put me first throughout the first few years and tried to just move forward being honest and firm with MIL. I was actually empathetic towards MIL because she adores her DS, is East Asian where this is culturally not the norm and only wanted the best for him. His dad died when he was 12 and he has one sister. Their style seems to be that MIL, SIL, DH and youngest DD are family. I am his wife and of lower value, two older DC are lowest value. This is was not my DH’s attitude initially and he tried really hard to make things different

Over the last couple of years, MIL has accepted the relationship but continues to be jealous (she seems to want DH to have a more husband than son-like relationship with her) and make up some odd lies about me or spin stories so I am doing very unreasonable things, mainly to SIL. Like that I am pressuring her to move to my city and take care of my child. They have an interesting family dynamic with lots of lies and secrets between the three of them.

Previously, DH wanted to maintain a good relationship with them both but was totally transparent with me about what was going on. He prioritised me but we also made an effort to prioritise his family despite what was going on. An example, I feel so uncomfortable when his mum comes to stay and by 24 hours I’m bouncing off the walls with anxiety and trying to bend over backwards to avoid an argument - so I set a boundary of a one night stay at a time. MIL adores DH and youngest DD and I wouldn’t like to ruin that for them but I’m a person too. At this point I ensure older DC are with their dad during visits so are not impacted.

Recently, I feel like things have shifted. DH has said he feels that maybe he has created some of the problems by being so honest on all fronts and maybe he should have kept more to himself. In terms of MIL visits he most recently was trying to arrange her to come asap and for two nights, I don’t know whether he was getting pressure from her or just feeling some son guilt. He said he feels so guilty that it is a long drive (2 hours) for just one night and seemed to want to arrange her to come asap even though it was a bad time for us. I slept on it and offered two nights but two weeks later when it was a better time. He did not say thank you or acknowledge my boundary being breached. He did after I pointed this out.

Yesterday, he told me he had offered to give his sister money because she has run out and said it was because she was impulsive and had spent all of hers, and that she had given him money in the past. I was quite cross that he had meaningfully offered out large sums old our shared finances without talking to me and said that I’m not sure it’s the sort of reason I agree with. It turns out, the money was for a different reason due to her relationship status but his sister had asked him not to tell anyone.

If I meaningfully offered out family resources, I would tell him. If something was going on between him and my parents, I would prioritise him. If something was going on for my family, I would talk to him about it. I appreciate that every relationship is different and we are all entitled to our privacy but this is the type of relationship we had before. Although, I do respect his sister’s privacy as well so that’s a tricky one.

This seems to be going from a place I didn’t enjoy but felt like we were a team to something entirely different.

Do I have a DH problem, a SIL/MIL problem or am I the problem?

OP posts:
KnackeredButHere · 25/09/2025 11:21

TLDR
Married 3 years, blended family. MIL disapproved from the start due to cultural reasons and my being divorced with kids. DH used to fully support me and be transparent, but lately he’s been prioritising MIL/SIL’s needs over our boundaries and shared decisions—like extending MIL visits and offering SIL money without discussing it. I feel like we’re no longer a team, and I’m unsure if the real issue is DH changing, MIL/SIL dynamics, or if I’m overreacting.

OP posts:
Purplecatshopaholic · 25/09/2025 11:34

I defo don’t think you are the problem. Sounds like you are trying hard to compromise and make this work, and yet his family make up lies about you. I’d have gone NC with them right there. This is a DH problem. Really his family aren’t your problem - go LC if NC is too much, and he can see them, take your child for visits etc. You need to speak seriously with your DH about visits etc (I wouldn’t have them in my house, but you might be more accommodating), and the dynamic in general, if he feels under pressure and why it might explain things more. Like in earlier days, he needs to put you first.

KnackeredButHere · 25/09/2025 11:42

Thank you. Does me going LC/NC and him continuing a relationship drive the wedge even bigger between us though? Then there’s a whole relationship and world going on with them that he presumably will feel like he can’t share with me. Can I trust him to protect DD from the dynamic or will she be encouraged to keep secrets from me as well?

OP posts:
Purplecatshopaholic · 25/09/2025 12:03

KnackeredButHere · 25/09/2025 11:42

Thank you. Does me going LC/NC and him continuing a relationship drive the wedge even bigger between us though? Then there’s a whole relationship and world going on with them that he presumably will feel like he can’t share with me. Can I trust him to protect DD from the dynamic or will she be encouraged to keep secrets from me as well?

Couldn’t it just be the case you don’t tend to engage, or visit, you just stay in the background, without any need for nastiness, lying or hiding things, and he has a relationship with them but you don’t really? I think you need to discuss this with your DH.

FuzzyWolf · 25/09/2025 12:08

I wonder whether he feels that by telling you so many negative things about his family and their views that it has caused an unnecessarily big wedge between you and them with him in the middle. What you see as transparency some might see as stirring or causing issues that weren’t there. Maybe he now regrets being so open with you because it means your boundaries are impacting his relationship with his mother and sister.

UpDownAllAround1 · 25/09/2025 12:59

What a mess to marry into. Secrecy, lies and traditions. You and DH need to agree further boundaries and now he is stopping communicating about finance issues

StartleBright · 25/09/2025 13:18

This is tricky. You have to grab the bull by the horns and be very proactive and up front. Yes his sister deserves privacy, but by bringing family finances into play, she automatically brings you into play and her privacy no longer counts. No lies, no pretending you don’t know x and y. Clear the air. Be direct with them ‘SIL it wasn’t respectful of you to ask for family money without me being involved, imagine you were in my place’, ‘MIL I know you don’t like me, I respect our relationship, but these nonsense stories about me need to stop (examples)’.
Bullies thrive on silence, secrecy and no one standing up to them. Try it a couple of times and I assure you they will behave. The situation may also go nuclear, but then you will be left in no doubt as to who has been behaving badly.
Your hubby knows what is right, but he has years of being trained to follow the dysfunctional dynamic - don’t allow it to threaten your home. He needs to know that it’s you and him vs the dysfunction, and that you will not put up with being treated badly for a bit of dysfunctional ‘peace’. Good luck!! You sound like you have your head around the situation quite well and just need a bit of a handhold. (Also what a rubbish MIL if she can’t welcome your other children!!)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page