Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

The best boyfriend ever - and I dumped him. Please tell me your ‘One the got away’ stories!

29 replies

BenignKipper · 28/08/2025 02:21

I am struggling to get over a relationship that I ended. I am not sorry I ended it - but I am really not coping with how very attractive and all of the things he is.

Short story shorter: we really liked each other but the relationship moved at breakneck speed and he had no boundaries so was constantly discussing us with other people. He is an extremely anxious person and I found myself becoming more and more anxious - like the anxiety was catching - and eventually I just felt so frazzled I called time.

But I miss him and follow him online. He is so good looking, high achieving, kind - just great. He is also properly accomplished, and … you get the picture. He is objectively my ‘best’ ever boyfriend. So fucking eligible he will be snapped up - in fact I assume he is already in something new. Sighs.

OP posts:
GlowWorm13 · 28/08/2025 09:31

I met my OTGA when we were both 21 at work. He started at this job a few days after I did and sat opposite me and he had this beautiful huge white smile which made me happy every time I saw him. It was a terrible job so we kind of bonded over how awful it was, laughed about the same things, had a lot in common with each other…we just clicked immediately. There was an unspoken attraction between us, and everyone knew we liked each other but it was never verbalised by either of us because we were both in relationships (his was long distance). Anyway, I was being abused by BF at that time and although I didn’t tell anyone what was going on, this guy kind of sensed something nasty was going on with me and he was so kind and supportive, a real rock at a difficult time and never took advantage of my vulnerability. He just built me up and made me feel good about myself and made me realise I deserved better than my BF. This guy had his own issues as his brother was suffering from schizophrenia and it took a huge toll on this guy, so I gave him support and a place to unload his fears as he didn’t feel he could speak to anyone else. His relationship with his girlfriend was increasingly difficult because of the distance and so they argued a lot, plus she was white and he felt he had to keep her hidden from his strict Indian parents (although this turned out not to be the case at all) which caused huge tension between them.

Anyway, I won’t go into all the details because it’s far too long, but when I was single he was in a relationship, and when he was single I was in a relationship. I had my issues and he had his issues, and as a result our paths never really aligned and for a while we didn’t see or speak to each other. During that time I finally dumped my abusive ex and I met my now dh and was utterly smitten with him. The guy contacted me to catch up after a break of about 4 months not seeing or speaking to each other, and we met at a local pub. I went there just to catch up and to say goodbye as I was moving to another area, where as unbeknownst to me, he had wanted to confess that he was in love with me, and wanted us to finally give it a go as he’d been single for a few months and he knew I’d got rid of my ex. Anyway, we met, we had a lovely catch up and then I said my goodbyes to him and we promised to stay in touch. I later found out that once he saw how happy and content I was with my new man (dh) after all the years of abuse my ex had put me through, he decided to let me go and chose not to ruin my happiness by telling me he loved me and causing me turmoil.

Anyway, we’re now both mid 40s and we’re still in regular contact (both my dh and his partner know
we’re in contact and have no issues with this). He has a long term partner and two children, and I’m with my dh and have two children. We still get on like a house on fire, can talk about anything, and I can honestly say he one of the loveliest, kindest people I know. He’s not changed at all over the years. He’s someone who will always have my back and I’ll always have his. I don’t have any regrets about letting him get away, and I believe he feels the same way, but I do sometimes wonder what life would have been like if he’d told me that day at the pub that he loved me, although I suspect I would still have chosen my dh.

TotalMaelstrom · 28/08/2025 09:31

Your ex sounds awful. Don’t be re-seduced by an online presence which by definition doesn’t show his gossip, over-sharing and omnipresent anxiety.

I mean, I could spin someone I dumped in my student days as ‘the one that got away’ in that he was a very nice, attractive guy, who, just after he graduated, patented some product in his field (engineering) that made him millions by the time he was 30, but the fact is, I was right to dump him. It takes a whole lot more than nice, good-looking and rich to interest me, and I was bored.

tetleyhead · 28/08/2025 09:52

mrssunshinexxx · 28/08/2025 06:53

Why do some women set their bars so low. He sounds shite.

This made me laugh out loud.

Delightfully to the point.

YetanotherNC25 · 28/08/2025 13:47

Agree with PP’s that he was not good for you. It’s normal to think about an ex but you really have to stop following him online. You’re only making it worse for yourself by wondering ‘What if’ when that’s not healthy. Cut him loose and find someone who treats you well.

My OTGA was someone who for 80% of the time was fabulous and a lovely person who I believed was my soulmate. But for 20% of the time he was bloody awful to me, disinterested, ghosted, awful communicator and would never acknowledge when his behaviour was hurtful. He just didn’t want to be with me. I left and thankfully he’s not on socials so there’s nowhere to see reminders.

Everything happens for a reason and good looking doesn’t mean good at relationships. Look for someone with shared values who communicates and behaves well. That’s what will sustain a relationship long term.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread