Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

In an argument how does you dp/dh speak to you compared to how your Dad spoke to your mum?

16 replies

DrNortherner · 12/05/2008 14:02

My Dad has never said fuck off/piss off etc to my mother. If he did it would be grounds for divorce. You just don't speak to her like that

When dh and I argue, we throw obscenaties around, me more than him sometimes but I would never be offended.

How about you, are you offended? Would you scream HOW VERY DARE YOU if he swore at you?

(the fuck off thread got me thinking about this)

OP posts:
nickytwotimes · 12/05/2008 14:03

Oh no, we don't swear at each other. I don't like that, personally. however, we do swear a lot in general conversation!

posieflump · 12/05/2008 14:05

oh me and dh swear at each other and are really nasty sometimes
my parents never argued like that. It was all silent looks and sulks on my Mum's side - my dad was just very pedantic in an argument but never raised his voice

GooseyLoosey · 12/05/2008 14:07

My father never used obscenities with my mother either, although I remember her doing it (but very, very rarely and she would never have said anything like "fuck").

I never swear at dh but dh does swear at me sometimes and I hate it. I have asked him not to but he just does not get why I find it so offensive. As he sees it, he swears in everyday speech, so why not in an argument? TBH I don't really have an answer, I just have an almost visceral reaction to "fuck off" being said to me and can only conclude that it stems from the way it would have been regarded when I was a child.

TattooedGrrrl · 12/05/2008 14:09

we rarely argue, although we have the occassional bicker. we might mutter a swear word under our breath as we leave the room during a bickering session, but that's it. We've never called each other names either.

and it wouldn't make any difference if my father swore during an arguement- he swears so much generally you woudn't notice the difference!

cardy · 12/05/2008 14:15

Dh and I do swear at each other if very very angry...I've been know to trow things too . We don't generally swear in everyday conversation though....well not strong swearing.

My mum would on occasion swear at my dad but dad always kept calm and didn't rise to it.

I think it's the Italain blood in me and my mum that make us somewhat 'emotional'!!

ohdearohdear · 12/05/2008 14:15

I can never remember either using th ef word and i can't imagine dh's parents would either. dh never uses swear word in normal conversation - just when very angry. Like you Goosey, I hate it, but it still happens from tiem to time

RosaLuxembourg · 12/05/2008 14:18

I NEARLY told my DH to fuck off last night, but managed to rein it in. In my defence I was VERY SORELY PROVOKED. We don't argue much anyway. My parents never argued at all, my Dad would just sulk (sometimes for days) if he was pissed off about something. Swearing would have been far preferable.

donbean · 12/05/2008 14:25

dad was violent and agressive to my mother.

my dh is a gentle soul who would never ever raise his hand.
we dont really argue, been together for 14 years and have had maybe 3 disagreements in all these years.
we dont swear either.
do you know, we are just too laid back to be bothered!

millie865 · 12/05/2008 16:27

My parents swore a bit ('bloody' rather than fuck)but never at each other. DH and I are the same - we will swear quite a lot but never at each other. For example yesterday in a row I said fucking hell (a few times!) but I would never say fuck off. The same with DH. I never use cunt as a term of abuse. Ever.

serenity · 12/05/2008 16:38

My Mum and Dad used to have horrible, vicious arguments that made my stomach churn, with lots of shouting and swearing on my Dads side.

Me and Dh don't really argue, we might disagree and I'll get stroppy and sulk in the kitchen but we don't actually argue (Dh is far too laidback!) We (Ok, I) swear a fair amount - lots of buggers and bollocks - but DH has never sworn at me, and I can only think of 1 occasion (in 21 years!) that I've told him to Fuck off, and meant it.

AbbeyA · 12/05/2008 16:52

My parents never swore at each other or me.I argue with DH but we would never swear at each other. I am the same with the DCs, I would say if I don't like their behaviour but I would never attack the person. I wouldn't allow anyone to swear at me and certainly not someone who loves me! It would be grounds for divorce.

DefinitelyNotMARINAWheeler · 12/05/2008 17:10

My parents had colourful arguments that never got insulting or sweary. Quite loud though, and a vacuum cleaner was sent skidding down a flight of stairs with intent although this was denied later.
My dad is a good arguer. They debate things a lot...and then he usually gives in gracefully. He's a saint really, because he never holds a grudge and has been a fantastic husband, father and grandpa.
Dh is an amateur in comparison, but again, we rarely fight, rather argue about politics etc. No swearing here either. Not at each other anyway!

tigana · 12/05/2008 17:13

I take after my mum in that I have a snappy, bitchy temper, swear at dh then the pasive-aggression of my dad kicks in and I storm off in a sulk ( and cringe at sounding like a fishwife earlier)
My dad was too passive aggressive to ever actually argue with my mum.

Bink · 12/05/2008 17:20

You can only see these things from the inside I think. I think my pa is an absolute dear - if I've ever had a disagreement with him he has always started by saying he sees my point of view [that "validation" thing you're supposed to do - I think he does it by instinct though, not because he's been told he should] before he tries to discuss further. But I think his very gentle reasonableness has on occasion been speechlessly annoying to my mother.

Anyway, because of Dad & what he's like I was once totally shocked when (ages & ages ago) dh cast some kind of aspersion at me which, it turned out, he didn't even accurately think was true - he said, later on, & when we were friends again, that he'd been "casting about for something mean to say" (again).

So I'm afraid dh doesn't get accorded the credit & gravitas in argument that he might otherwise have had.

Sanctuary · 12/05/2008 17:21

I swear at dh in a temper he never swears at me.I am the fishwife I hurl the abuse.If I told him to F**k off he would`nt get upset but niether would I if he said it to me.
He is just sarcastic and never raises his voice so it sounds like its me starting an argument.Or blowing for no good reason

I take after my dad with my temper except he never swore to my mum.

tigana · 12/05/2008 17:24

Yep, dh's laid back attitude while i am fuming and ranting just drives me further into fishwifedom.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page