Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Advice please - relationship, divorce and ‘the one that got away’

21 replies

OnePinkRobin · 29/12/2024 20:34

Hello,

I need some advice. A bit of context: I (35F) met a guy (35M) when I was 17 and due to my own insecurities and generally not feeling good enough for him, I pushed him away. In my head I think I was pushing him away before he left me. I always regretted it. But was too embarrassed and was convinced he hated me so I didn't reach out. I thought, this is my bed I need to lie in it. I always hoped that he was happy. Always wished him love. He moved on, he got married and had children. Again, although I was sad at what could've been between us I was happy for him.

After years of focusing on my career at the expense of my personal life and a few failed relationships later I'd almost come to the conclusion that I was going to be alone for the rest of my life, but again I'd sacrificed meeting and building anything with anyone for my career, so this was my bed so I had to lie in it. Again.

Fast forward almost 19 years and this guy literally slid into my dm's. I thought hmm, what is this about. He is happily married and never thought I even crossed his mind. Turns out I'd never left his mind. We had both been thinking about each other all these years. Both in love with each other but had resigned ourselves to the fact that we were each others 'the one that got away'. I was skeptical as to why he was reaching out now. He told me that his marriage had been very controlling and he had recently separated so thought he'd reach out to see how I was as he was now allowed social media and to speak to other females. His family always knew my name as I was brought up from time to time. Because of this, his ex wife knew my name and we only found out when we reconnected that she had changed my name in his phone to a very derogatory term and blocked my number. Another way of trying to control him in my opinion.

We then spoke every day - it was like no time had passed. We arranged to meet a few months down the line. I wanted to be sure he was emotionally ready and not on the rebound. This meeting then sparked the start of a relationship. After entering into the relationship with trepidation and caution, I let my guard down and thought why am I so hesitant, don't push him away again. So decided I was in.

Fast forward a few months of meeting on average every 4/5 weeks (we do not live near each other) and his divorce getting more messy, he starts to pull away. We'd discussed in the past how he shuts down and doesn't talk. He acknowledged that he should open up and talk to me. He told me I should push myself into his head if I felt the need to. So that coupled with not wanting to repeat the pattern of walking away again - I did not want to walk away just because things had got hard. I was in for the good and the bad. After another couple of months of him retreating further. Communication becoming very sporadic on his part. I asked how best to support him but didn’t received a direct answer. So I did what I thought was best. I kept contact as I didn't want him to think, oh she's left again, she doesn't care. Plus him previously telling me to essentially not give up. I would message just to check on him every week or so. Trying to give him space but not drop him completely. After he then stopped responding to these messages, I messaged saying that I didn't want to walk away because things got hard. That I believe in us and I don't want to give up but that I needed to clarify as to where I stood. He responded saying that he needed to sort the 'mess out'. The divorce. I acknowledged the message but left it there. I didn’t want to put pressure by asking how things were so I didn't ask any questions or anything. A few days after this I wake up to discover that I have been blocked.

I don't know how to deal with this. I am trying to tell myself his behaviour is not a reflection of how he feels about me. But a reaction to the stress of his divorce. Or maybe she is threatening access to the kids. This happened with his parents and he’s petrified that history will repeat itself and she will take the kids away if she gets wind that he is seeing someone. But being blocked feels personal. It's like a knife in my heart. We had spoken about life. About spending it with each other. About having children. About me moving to be closer to him at some point in the new year.

I always felt that an implosion was going to come. He seemed too ‘fine’ and so I would check in and ask whether he needed space or was ready for something with me. He said no he didn’t need space and wanted us to work. So I always tried to never apply pressure, the only thing I asked was that he be honest with me. Be transparent. Despite me trying to be communicative, I always felt like he would disappear. Shatter like glass. That every time I saw him would be my last. So I treated him like glass. Pushed my feelings to the side.

What's mad is that, deep down. Deep in my gut I feel like things will all work out. Like we will live a happy life together. It's not an image I am forcing. It's a feeling. Like it’s the natural order of things.

So I guess my question is/are; have I not been understanding enough? Have I done something to push him away? Maybe I should’ve backed off ages ago but that felt like running away again. In hindsight I should’ve said, reach out when the divorce is through but he said he was ready. So I don’t know. Is it personal? And am I delusional to feel like things will work out once he's got out of his own head and a clearer path sorted? I might be stupid to feel this way given, when I look objectively he hasn't necessarily treated me with the respect I deserve. But is it delusional or is there something in a gut feeling?

If you've made it to the end of this, thank you. Essentially any advice would be appreciated as currently I am heartbroken. Heartbroken and confused.

OP posts:
OneWittySquid · 29/12/2024 20:40

It sounds like he was wanting an affair and was found out.

Mrswhatsit40 · 29/12/2024 20:43

First answer nails it. He’s married and wanted a fling, he’s pulled back when it’s become too messy.

OnePinkRobin · 29/12/2024 20:45

Objectively, I would probably agree but she had mentally broken him and controlled his every move. I don’t believe he had the mental capacity to hide one. Plus certain things that had been planned as a family had been cancelled. Shared childcare and I had met some of his friends. I just don’t believe that he never left her and just wanted an affair. I felt I was too close to his life for an affair to be practical. I understand your view point but my gut says that isn’t the case.

OP posts:
TY78910 · 29/12/2024 20:46

Either what PPs have suggested or they got back together.

SpringIscomingalso · 29/12/2024 20:47

He was not nice to his wife. He had affair while still married

ClementineChurchill · 29/12/2024 20:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Amaranthasweetandfair · 29/12/2024 21:05

What strikes me about this is how much you've taken as fact when you only have his word for it. As in, he was in love with you for 19 years, his wife is controlling and won't let him speak to other women, etc etc. I'd be questioning it all at this point, as his actions wouldn't indicate that he was being truthful about everything. I don't want to upset you, but that's just my takeaway from what I've read. He's spun you a very good yarn.

Amaranthasweetandfair · 29/12/2024 21:07

He has also put a lot of the responsibility for his own actions on to you - it's for you to get in his head rather than him up to you, for instance. This isn't how a good relationship works at all. If he wanted to be with you he'd be doing everything in his power to be with you, is the bottom line.

ClementineChurchill · 29/12/2024 21:08

lol MN deleted me so let me make it clearer that I’m answering your actual question:

”So I guess my question is … am I delusional to feel like things will work out once he's got out of his own head and a clearer path sorted?”

my answer is: yes, in my opinion you are delusional to feel like that.

perhaps it will help MN not to delete my post this time if I provide context. I think you should walk away from this guy. I don’t think he’s good for you and I don’t think you’re helping each other. I also think that the “one who got away” trope is very powerful when people are living unsatisfactory lives. But it’s more productive to look at why you’re feeling unsatisfied, rather than plunging into the fantasy of what could have been. He has pulled back from you. Take this as a useful cue to consider what it is in your life that you feel is missing. Maybe 2025 is the year you can focus on that instead of being sidetracked by this man who was himself looking for distraction.

GreyAreas · 29/12/2024 21:09

I think it's a strong possibility that he had mentally broken her. Maybe your gut was talking sense at 17.

OneWittySquid · 29/12/2024 21:13

He is going to paint her as an evil controlling person op. He wanted abit of fun on the side. It's got too serious or she's found out and he blocked you. Many friends will turn a blind eye to a man pursing another woman behind his wives back..did you meet his family?

CluelessAsFuck · 29/12/2024 21:14

I was getting "Where rainbows end" vibes and am disappointed for you OP - it sucks 100%.

OnePinkRobin · 29/12/2024 21:16

Yes I did meet his family

OP posts:
Snowballsarelush · 29/12/2024 21:19

Remember he could literally be telling you what you want to hear. You absolutely don't know he is separated or is divorcing. He has gone down the classic manipulative route of 'my ex is crazy and controlling', it's the oldest one in the book. Unless you have spoken to his wife you really don't know what's going on.

I'm sorry to say but it absolutely sounds like he wanted to have an affair with you and he backed out because he changed his mind. He blocked you because he didn't want your messages popping up for his wife to see.

Did you ever go to his house?

I think you know deep down you've been played. He's been cruel and is just another man looking for a fling.

I'd be tempted to check Tinder, etc to see if he has a profile.

RedDeadReflection · 29/12/2024 21:22

Jesus wept OP the guys a tool and you can't even see it. We are not the same people at 35 as at 17.

Topee · 29/12/2024 21:31

I wouldn’t be so keen to assume he was telling you the truth. The whole thing smacks of him still being married.

Dery · 29/12/2024 23:34

“I think you should walk away from this guy. I don’t think he’s good for you and I don’t think you’re helping each other. I also think that the “one who got away” trope is very powerful when people are living unsatisfactory lives. But it’s more productive to look at why you’re feeling unsatisfied, rather than plunging into the fantasy of what could have been. He has pulled back from you. Take this as a useful cue to consider what it is in your life that you feel is missing. Maybe 2025 is the year you can focus on that instead of being sidetracked by this man who was himself looking for distraction.”

Sorry you’ve had this experience, OP, but this with bells on. Remember that this guy will have been telling you what you wanted to hear; that could be a very far cry from the truth.

OnePinkRobin · 29/12/2024 23:37

Thank you everyone. It’s good to hear some other perspectives. I appreciate it.

OP posts:
PinkLady1979 · 29/12/2024 23:44

Just wanted to say that I feel for you. I have been there. Being love bombed or pursued by an old flame is one of the biggest head messes around. It is so potent as they know what buttons to press and the nostalgic romance of it is heady. It is hard not to get swept up in what could be an amazing happy ending. I don’t know whether he was genuine or not or why he has gone cold but look after yourself. X

LavenderFields7 · 29/12/2024 23:45

He’s lost interest, the novelty has worn off, the imaginative idea of what a relationship with you would be like has lost its sparkle. He’s checked out. Cut your losses and move on with someone else who is more available and looking for a serious relationship. He is not it.

EvriSingleTime · 30/12/2024 00:04

He's used you OP and now he's discarded you. I'm so sorry.

Time and distance are your friends. Allow yourself to feel the heartbreak (cry etc) and then block him on all platforms and never, ever engage with him again. It's never going to happen OP.

Two wise MN sayings are:

When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time

and

Never make someone a priority when you're just an option to them.

Grieve for him, take a deep breath, and then move on and never look back. All the best OP.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page