Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Advice - is this what I want in a relationship

18 replies

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:17

I could do with a bit of advice regarding my 3 year relationship. I am not too sure if some parts are what I want or if I am over thinking or being influenced by others. We met online and had different up bringing and family values. Background …

we are both mid 40s, both have our own homes, no kids ( he has adult son) and good but busy jobs. I live 250 miles from my family (only 3 of us) and him very close to. I speak to my family weekly and he is from a large family and never sees them much. We both have our own social life which is important to us.

he stays at my house 4/5 nights a week. I never go to his as it’s rural a both our works are close to me. I also live in a big city with lots going on. I have been and I lived with him for 6 months due to my house sell. We didn’t get on well and split up for 5 weeks when i got my keys. It came down to values. He is more traditional and thought I would do most chores as I wasn’t paying rent, despite us agreeing a split before I moved in. I also struggled to adjust to rural life and missed my friends being close. He didn’t include me in his life as it was his life and we ended up as roommates. Previous to this we laughed, went out etc. but hadn’t merged lives.

we have been back together for 7 months. We get on well, go out, but I have never been invited out with his family or friends. I feel hidden. We chatted and he said I don’t like his music and he doesn’t go out with family much. I love him, spend 75% of my week with him and we get on well. He will come out to some things I invite him to with my friends, but not reliable.

My doubts are creeping in. I am not sure if I am overthinking and comparing other lives. My parents did lots together and shared friends, same as my friends and partners. His parents divorced and never remarried and never shared friends. I want to be independent but also want him included. He is happy to do his own thing and can be introverted - he is always on the outside. We sort of got into a habit of organising things with friends and then fitting us in.

we have never spent a Christmas together. Our first Christmas I had a family death. Next Christmas he was working. This Christmas I am having my family and friends round for a party. He says he hates Christmas and would prefer to be us or alone. He is not coming to mine and decided to spend it with his dad and a brother.

We agreed to spend new year together instead and that would be just us. He has now decided he wants to go to a dance event with his friends (I would hate it). I said I would come with him but he says no. I don’t think he is going now. Said he will come at Christmas instead but I know he will be grumpy. I have said it’s not a negotiation as I have no plans at new year now as I was supposed to be out with him.

I feel an option. I feel I don’t have a partner to do family things with and invite out to couple events. My friends think it’s odd he doesn’t want to spend Christmas with me. he says I am his priority he just wouldn’t enjoy some things I do.

basically I am in a relationship but with a partner that picks and chooses partner events for no reason that he probably won’t enjoy it. He will go to similar things with friends, but not me. Just the 2 of us it’s great, it’s the social element I am not too sure i can see a future with.

am I overthinking this? I don’t want to live in each others pockets, but I would also like my parter to want to spend time at social events and not be alone. Is this too different or more compromise needed.

OP posts:
DandySnail · 14/12/2024 15:27

but I have never been invited out with his family or friends. I feel hidden.

in 3 years or since you got back together?

DandySnail · 14/12/2024 15:27

basically I am in a relationship but with a partner that picks and chooses partner events for no reason that he probably won’t enjoy it.

and also one that you know you don’t actually get on with given you had a disastrous 6 mo t of living together and split up

DandySnail · 14/12/2024 15:29

he would rather not got to the NY party than go with you

Op, he sounds embarrassed by you.

which is no life for you

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:33

DandySnail · 14/12/2024 15:27

but I have never been invited out with his family or friends. I feel hidden.

in 3 years or since you got back together?

In 3 years. If we meet them out he introduces me to them. He never asks me to go out. But I feel he never arranged with friends, always the one to asks. His friends don’t invite their partners or are single. It’s only his younger brother who goes out with his girlfriend that he seems to be surrounded by couples

OP posts:
Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:35

@DandySnail i don’t think he is embarrassed by me. If out and we bump into friends he introduces me. People know about me, met his family etc.

OP posts:
DandySnail · 14/12/2024 15:36

either

his friends have asked you’re not there
or
he doesn’t like how you behave in social setting

3 years op.,,, that’s shocking

and actually… this is just the tip of the iceberg burg isn’t it about issue you’ve posted about on this relationship for a long time?

TwistedWonder · 14/12/2024 15:42

You’ve posted about your relationship a few times on here OP and imo that’s not a sign that it’s working for you.

From this and your previous threads, I just don’t see you two as compatible in any way

I honestly think you need to cut your losses and end it rather than waste any more time flogging a dead horse

Tbh I’ve always had a separate social circles to partners so that on its own for me isn’t the issue but it’s just another thing showing this relationship isn’t going anywhere.

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:53

@DandySnail i know I behave well and have manners, not worried about that. I just don’t think he thinks.

OP posts:
Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:55

@TwistedWonder its compatibility I am worried out. Just us together is great. But that’s not life. He doesn’t seem to be bothered about socialising together.

OP posts:
DandySnail · 14/12/2024 16:24

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:53

@DandySnail i know I behave well and have manners, not worried about that. I just don’t think he thinks.

yes but he might not share the same view

DandySnail · 14/12/2024 16:24

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 15:55

@TwistedWonder its compatibility I am worried out. Just us together is great. But that’s not life. He doesn’t seem to be bothered about socialising together.

but when. it was just you “together” for 6 months

you split up

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 16:30

@DandySnail I am not worried about being embarrassing or I wouldn’t have an active social life or in fact my job. It is not this. Knowing how to act in different social situations is something I can do well.

OP posts:
DandySnail · 14/12/2024 16:33

Amazingday · 14/12/2024 16:30

@DandySnail I am not worried about being embarrassing or I wouldn’t have an active social life or in fact my job. It is not this. Knowing how to act in different social situations is something I can do well.

ok op

because in 3 YEARS never once socialised with you either his very close social life

and to even decide not to go to NY party if it means you coming with him…. well it looks like it

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/12/2024 17:48

What about the bits where you lived together that he wanted you to cut off all your friends? Do all the housework and generally be his servant 24/7 whilst he largely ignored you?

He just doesn't want you to be with other people. That's why he's screwed over your New Year. It's why he doesn't like you seeing his family or friends. It's why he's refusing to see you at Christmas and then punishing you in the New Year. He likes you isolated.

Every time you posted, people said this was the start of coercive control and isolation.

unclemtty · 14/12/2024 23:57

I would describe you being in a situationship rather than a relationship.

It's a convenience for him (free board and food and minimal housework, sex and pleasant company ) for him during the week and cuts down on his commute and the cost of the commute.

If you moved somewhere inconvenient for him would he bother to carry on seeing you?

He doesn't integrate you into his life because he's just out into you and doesn't view you as relationship material.

MyAquaBear · 15/12/2024 06:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

unsync · 15/12/2024 07:45

Does he stay with you during the week and then go home for the weekend? If so, is that because its easier/cheaper for him than commuting?

I'm not clear on what positives you are getting from this. How do you think he is enhancing your life by being together? Do you feel cherished and respected?

ChristmasFluff · 15/12/2024 12:37

You've said yourself, you do not have shared values. So even without anything else, this relationship has no legs. It's going nowhere.

So are you happy with exactly how it is now? No, otherwise you wouldn't be posting.

It isn't going to change, so if this isn't what you want, it is time to end it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page