Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Husband after 5 years still hold grudge over his aunt, was he overreacting?

33 replies

stayathomewife · 09/08/2024 20:48

Before I go on, I need to say this as it might be cultural difference, I am Chinese, in the China culture is a very close-knit family (No, you don't just cut off a family member), and respect elders, not just your mom dad, grandparents, but also your aunts and uncles too as they are siblings of your parents.

The Chinese me I'm the type that like to maintenance peace, and you can call me doormat but I never dare cut out a family member, and I avoid confrontation.
Him, my husband (whom not Chinese), he has zero problem with cut off a family member, and he will start war if he has to, and he has zero problem with confrontation.

Together 14 years, married 12 years. Our child died of brain disease 5 years ago, my child died when he was 1.5 years old, brain disease run in my side of the family and I'm the baby's mother.
This is not on my husband, it on me. Even if we try for another child there always a 50/50 chance the next baby could inherit brain disease from me again.
Both me and my husband still grief our child's death.

My husband is fine with not having children as he said he married me because he loves me and wants to grow old together with me, not because he wants to carry on his genes or carry on the family name.

------

So you see during holidays we have family get together with all his family members, his aunt (his paternal aunt), his aunt commented that use his income and his U.S. citizenship, he has a University Master degrees and income of 6-figures.
His aunts said use his money and U.S citizenship go to China, Vietnam, Philippines, Russia, etc.. to find a younger woman (beside be a better match for him than me) but also can give him children to carry on the family name, because he is the ONLY son.

He was mad, right there in front of the whole family get together dinner table,
yep. in front of his whole family sitting there.
He SLAM his FIST down the holiday family gettogether table and yelled "ENOUGH", and point to his aunt and address his aunt as "this woman", that do not ever call him for any family gettogether anymore if has "this woman" (his aunt) in it.
......
Told his aunt to apologize to me his wife, and do not ever speak a word to me again, and do not come anywhere near me. Hold my hand, said to his mom he call her later, walk straight out and SLAM the door on his way out.

My jaw drop, I was speechless. ALL that just because his aunt on the holiday family gettogether table said the da-mn truth that he has other options out there, other options alot better than me, and another woman can give him healthy children without brain disease.

He told me he not want his aunt to instill things like this in my head, and he does not want her anywhere near me. He also does not want to have anything to do with is aunt or want to be around a woman like her.
And that it is his aunt, his family, let him deal with it "his" ways. And No, I do not have a choice but listen to him. And that I need to understand he protecting me here.

It been 5 years, he keep his words, he never went to any family gettogether that has his aunt in it. He completely cut her off, just over that.
And does not want me to talk to his aunt, reason is because he does not want her to instill bullock things like that in my head.

He still hold grudge against her 5 years later. I get it it his aunt, let him deal with his family. But was he overreacting with his aunt?

OP posts:
Mischance · 11/08/2024 12:21

Three cheers for your wonderful supportive husband! He is a keeper.
Your aunt was way way out of order and he was right to tell her so.
Stop worrying and just get on and enjoy your lovely man!!

WallaceinAnderland · 11/08/2024 12:36

He was protective of you. He loves you and shows it with his actions as well as his words. I'm sorry for your loss, that must be very hard to bear but please don't blame yourself. You can have a full, happy, loving life with your husband because he's a good guy and he's choosing you every day.

MitskiMoo · 11/08/2024 12:37

I like your husband.

Zanatdy · 11/08/2024 12:40

My god, what his auntie said in front of you, a grieving mother, is unforgivable. Good on him. I do wish you both all the best

pikkumyy77 · 11/08/2024 12:44

seriesoffortunateevents · 10/08/2024 11:24

I’m on the fence, your aunt was rude and it is right he took issue but he can do so in an eloquent way, make his point and leave, not act like some oaf. Past that I’d also not see her again, so I agree his actions and point,but think he could have handled it in a much more eloquent way. I am not a fan of men, or women, who lose control

But this kind of busybody, the kind of person who would publicly disrespect the OP and urge her nephew to discard her can’t be stopped from harming OP by courteous words or a calm rejoinder. Since she has so much love for her own opinion and so much contempt for OP she will not stop offending.The DH’s strong response was necessary to terminate the attack on OP.

pizzaHeart · 11/08/2024 12:54

Look at this from a different angle : his aunt showed complete ignorance of his grief, disrespect towards his choices, she implied that his only value was to continue family name and his happiness didn’t matter. She did at a family gathering, in front of other relatives young and old. What loving aunt does that? What kind of family is it?
Your DH reacted correctly, this aunt has no shame to behave like this. She is not a child she is grown up women. The response she’s got was proportional to what she’s done.
of course it’s worth investigating other options e.g genetic testing or adoption but it’s not the purpose of this thread, To answer your question- your DH is right, he is not holding the grudge, he is treating his aunt absolutely fairly.

Arconialiving · 11/08/2024 13:22

Zanatdy · 11/08/2024 12:40

My god, what his auntie said in front of you, a grieving mother, is unforgivable. Good on him. I do wish you both all the best

This! Well done to your DH Op. He's definitely a keeper!

betterangels · 11/08/2024 13:26

You found one of the good ones. Get some counselling so you don't end up pushing him away. He did the right thing here.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page