Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

I failed my gf (now ex). Do I have any hope?

19 replies

ILoveYouStill · 01/05/2024 12:48

I (M22) failed my gf (F20) (now ex). What chance of reconciliation do I have?

I am in the UK, she is in India, so all of our contact is done via social media etc.

Firstly, she is has a disorder and trauma that she has informed me about. This trauma involves the people she trusted leaving or treating her badly.

Secondly, we were in a bad situation with her family who had now forbade our talking. This was no wrongdoing on either of our parts. Things just didn’t go to plan.

Due to both of these things, our contact was very limited for a good month. First, we talked just when she could and her family weren’t around. This was next to no calling and very few moments that we could text. Then they found we were still talking and very strictly said to make sure I was blocked. She suggested that we don’t talk for a bit just to be safe.

A few days later, she rings me and we have a nice call and FaceTime. It was amazing to see and hear her again. The following night, she calls me again and we talk a bit. Then she tells me that she might have to go for a little bit soon because some guy she hadn’t heard from in years wanted to FaceTime. I was obviously very upset and felt uncomfortable and disrespected that she wanted to use our very limited time to talk to some random guy. I felt I should have been prioritised, especially given the circumstances. I stated this and said I don’t want her to. She kept saying but it was already planned and stuff and he’s just a friend. I raised my voice a bit because I use every available second I had to talk to her. I prioritised her over anything and anyone. I said “I don’t give a fck who he is.” She responded telling me not to be rude. I said “no, it’s not fair. We barely get to talk at all and you wanna use our time to talk to some fcking pr*ck?” She went silent after this. I immediately apologised and said I didn’t mean to raise my voice. I said I wasn’t meant to do that and I’m sorry. I said I wish I said it more calmly, I just lost control.

This is the first and only time in the 8 months we were together that I had raised my voice with her. It is my biggest regret and I hate myself for it. I had never even really been mad at her before.

She went away for a bit to talk to her mum and called me back after 2 hours. I said I was sorry for before. I had cried while she was gone and had this horrible feeling in my stomach. She has always told me that I was the only true comfort she had, the only person who had truly loved her and been there for her. She always said I was the best thing that ever happened to her. It felt like such a betrayal from me and like I had failed her. She had told me how others always scolded her and shouted at her when she did something without bad intentions.

We talked about what happened and she said it was just unexpected. I explained why I got mad calmly and she said she understood and would’ve just appreciated if I said it like that the first time. I wish I did, it really hurt me. She said to just not do it next time and it’ll be ok. In the tjme she was gone, she said she spoke to the guy for about 10 minutes. I honestly felt a bit disrespected that she still spoke to him after I showed I was clearly uncomfortable with it but I didn’t say anything.

Fast forward 2 days, she is speaking like everything is fine, saying I love you and I need you etc, and has done over those 2 days as well. She comes back after an hour of no messages and then says she hasn’t felt the same for me since I screamed at her. She said it had been hurting her forever since. I was shocked that she called it screaming but I understood that her trauma may have made her view it that way. Either way, I hate that I raised my voice to begin with.

She then said she’d broken up with me and this was goodbye. I pleaded with her to work it out like we always do and we always said we can get through anything together. I was and still am in a really bad place mentally and I needed her. She refused and became ruder, just saying bye to me. She said she is tired of having people around her who scream at her when she does things without bad intentions. That someone she had found comfort in had now done that. She said I was only one who hadn’t done so. She had begged me to stay after many things she did that hurt me and I forgave her. I always stayed. I told her that and she said she never asked me to do that even if she begged. She ended up blocking me on everything.

After this, I felt like I was worthless to her. Like I meant nothing. Everything I did for her just didn’t matter anymore because of this one mess up.

Did I really f*ck everything up? Is it possible that she’ll ever forgive me? I hurt so much and hated myself for raising my voice. I love her more than anything and, I know it sounds silly in 8 months, but I thought she was the one. It feels like my whole future has fallen apart.

I know a lot of people are gonna say there wasn’t much luck of a good future for us. I just wanna know, after what I did, what chance of talking to her again I have.

OP posts:
OrlandointheWilderness · 01/05/2024 12:54

Well yes, you fucked it up. And we are allowed to swear on MN! You lost it over her talking to a friend. You come across as incredibly controlling and a bit of a prick, yes. He trauma hasn't made her not want to be with you, her boundaries have and thank God because that is no way to conduct yourself. She is not your property and she has every right to spend her free time exactly how she chooses, and speak to whoever she wishes.
Have you actually met this woman or is this solely online?

TenderChicken · 01/05/2024 12:56

Honestly she was right to break up with you. You were being controlling and slightly scary. Big red flags for the future.

Sorry, but you need to let go.

ILoveYouStill · 01/05/2024 13:10

She could speak to this guy at literally any time. I was doing everything I could to make sure we had as much time speaking as possible. We had 1 hour that night. I just wanted my efforts to be reciprocated. I wouldn’t prioritise anyone else over her.

OP posts:
ILoveYouStill · 01/05/2024 13:12

There’s been many many occasions where she has done things to me but I was the one who ended up apologising.

OP posts:
BIWI · 01/05/2024 13:14

Sorry but this isn't/wasn't a relationship. You were pen pals really.

You also need to really examine how you behaved in all of this and grow up

RenoDakota · 01/05/2024 13:14

You did to her exactly what other people did to her in the past that led to her trauma. You knew about that and still yelled and swore at her.
She is better off without you.

thanKyouaIMee · 01/05/2024 13:15

It didn't work out, you shouted / screamed, she didn't prioritise you in the moment etc etc.

If there's been many occasions she's done things to you and you're bringing that up now despite your quite long contrite post, I'd leave it. The family also don't approve and it's a huge LDR, what hopes for the future do you honestly have for this relationship?

LardoBurrows · 01/05/2024 13:15

Accept her decision. This relationship sounds like it was doomed from the start. You should focus on meeting someone in the same country as you instead of some hopeless long distance relationship.

Jokl · 01/05/2024 13:15

Using the word ‘obviously’ when referring to how upset and angry you were with her indicates to me that you’re still not comprehending how out of order you were. She was right to dump you, you were acting like a whole party of walking red flags and I hope you are able to do some serious self reflection and approach your next relationship with a better perspective.

CleanShirt · 01/05/2024 13:24

BIWI · 01/05/2024 13:14

Sorry but this isn't/wasn't a relationship. You were pen pals really.

You also need to really examine how you behaved in all of this and grow up

Yep, this.

Uricon2 · 01/05/2024 13:33

Have you ever met her IRL?

Whatever, this whole relationship sounds impossibly melodramatic and very unhealthy. In my opinion, time to put it behind you and in the future be aware that drama and neediness, which there was on both sides here, is not love.

Singleandproud · 01/05/2024 13:38

You weren't in a romantic relationship you were just modern pen pals. There was likely no scope for this to continue due to distance and family opinions. You are controlling and insecure she does not owe you anything, even her time if she doesn't want to.

You need to work on your relationship skills and be aware of and address your own insecurities and meet some one in the same town/ city (or at least continent) to actually have a relationship.

vodkaredbullgirl · 01/05/2024 13:45

You were penpals not in a relationship.

Justcoincidences · 01/05/2024 13:53

You sound like a douche bag. She’s well rid.

Stressyfab · 01/05/2024 14:34

I explained why I got mad calmly

🤢

StrawberryWater · 01/05/2024 14:43

You sound awful.

Even in your two other comments you're minimising your behaviour and trying to turn things around on her with whataboutisms. It's a dick move on top a whole mountain of dick moves.

You're 22 so I think it would be a mistake to write you off completely but you do need therapy and a lot of it.

GreyCarpet · 01/05/2024 18:18

Have you ever actually met her?

Wolfiefan · 01/05/2024 18:28

Agree with PP. You weren’t “with” her. This wasn’t a relationship. And even if it was? You don’t get to dictate who someone else chooses to talk to. Get a grip, grow up and stay single until you can manage a relationship.

LightSpeeds · 01/05/2024 19:39

There are all sorts of problems here (beyond the 'shouting' incident).

You're both young - move on and get over it as best you can.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread