Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Is it time that my ex came home or not?

6 replies

Cerealontoast · 04/02/2024 20:33

Separated from my husband and father of my kids 18 months ago. We weren't getting along at all- lots of resentment, quiet contempt, irritation and complacency towards each other. I asked him to leave and he moved into a rental owned by his brother- he pays minimal rent as his brother has already paid the mortgage of the property. Mainly just bills.

For us to fully divorce, we would need to sell the family home which I am still living in and divide the equity to buy two smaller properties. We've been holding back on this due to the current mortgage rates etc. But it is the plan.

Then 4 months ago, I began going through quite a testing time (I don't want to go into detail) and my ex has basically been my biggest support. He's been happy to do the huge lion's share of everything to help me. I have one parent living abroad, the other is an alcoholic and I'm an only child so he just showed up and has been doing since,completely off his own back. The tension that was between us when we were together has dispersed and he has been kind and friendly and incredibly helpful. We enjoy each others company again for sure.

He returned to his rental today after spending a few days with us as it has been my time with the children and I haven't wanted to miss out on them, but also needed help with things at home, so he's been here. I'm sad that he's gone. It's been nice. He cooks, he cleans, he is great with the childrens routines and needs, he walks our labrador. He does a lot more for me than most married men do.

I know that he wants to come home (he has said so) and a big part of me wants him home too. But the problem is, he won't talk about anything. Communication is zero. Always has been. He refuses to discuss anything relationship-wise. This will never change. But I need some assurances for him to come home that things can be different. At the moment, we do not have an intimate romantic relationship as the children are around and we don't want to confuse them. Sometimes he hugs and kisses me briefly at night when they're in bed and once tried to have sex with me but I was on my period. He sleeps in the spare room when he's here though so not to confuse the children.

But, I'm not sure how we test whether we can have a loving, intimate relationship given that we have no childcare available to us. His parents have dementia, mine are not able and things are complicated with his brothers and I (I don't like them) and they would not support us by offering childcare for us to date.

I'm also not sure he values a romantic relationship the same way I do and would be just content to come home and live under the same roof again. Things are easier practically when he's here and we have got along very well since around October. He's my favourite person again, like he was before it all went wrong. But I would like to be in a loving, adult, sexual relationship too.

I've begged for him to attend relationship counselling with me to see if we have a chance but he says he doesn't believe in counselling so it's a massive no. It's like he's biding his time and waiting for me to have him back when there is still uncertainty for me. What if he comes back and begins behaving the way he did before he left? Although he seems to be much different now and seems to have realised something... I don't know. I also worry about the impact of his brothers who don't like me and have caused issues between us in the past..he would never see them in a negative light though and is more likely to blame me for future issues based on past experiences.

What do I do?

OP posts:
whendidisaythat · 04/02/2024 22:43

This is a really hard situation, but I think you know he will behave the same. It doesn't sound like he's reflected on his behaviour, discussed it with you or dealt with any of the personal issues contributing to the behaviour on his side. I don't see how in that situation anything could be different for him in the medium and long term.

Quitelikeit · 04/02/2024 22:48

Why can’t he come into your bed once the children are sleeping?

Surely you need to find a local babysitter too? There’s plenty around

Pashazade · 04/02/2024 23:04

He either goes to counselling with you or you stay separated and enjoy the amicable Co parenting, but perhaps put in slightly firmer boundaries over stopping the night. If he isn't talking he's not going to suddenly change, do you really want to go through all the heartache again and confusing the children.

Opentooffers · 05/02/2024 00:22

All he's proving is how good he is when you are apart. So keep him apart and he will behave better for longer.
However, I'm still bemused about the situation where he 'tried to have sex with you' - how? Was there foreplay build-up, or did he just launch himself? Surely it should be a 'we could of had sex' situation, but I was on my period? I've got odd situational scenarios playing in my brain of the moment rain stopped play.
Did it dial back to nothing on the basis of timing, or have you been generally more touchy feely etc since?

urbanbuddha · 05/02/2024 00:31

He either goes to counselling with you or you stay separated and enjoy the amicable

I agree. You need to be able to communicate for a relationship to work and atm that’s not happening. Calmly and non-judgmentally explain to him that you think counselling would help develop a stronger, more satisfying relationship and give him time to think about it. Ask him to really consider it. If he says ‘no’ you could consider it for yourself but I don’t think that’s so useful.

AgentJohnson · 05/02/2024 05:47

The second this man moves back in he will revert to type, do not put your kids through him returning and then having to get rid of him again. He isn’t the man you want him to be, his behaviour now isn’t a stepping stone to better.

Your H sounds emotionally stunted and will never really be the grown up you want him to be. This is as good as he gets, the second his feet get back under the table again, all the old shit will resurface.

Enjoy his behaviour but don’t mistake it for being a gateway to an understanding partner.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page