Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Is this just uptight Englishness/ religion or something else?

2 replies

PiffPaffPof · 22/01/2024 11:03

I have been thinking about my relationship with my parents and in laws. They are good parents but I have always struggled with the lack of emotional generosity.

They never really compliment their children face to face. Although they might speak with pride about their children’s and grandchildren’s achievements to friends or random people.

There seems to be something about how directly showing an interest in someone or taking pride in them is spoiling them. Both my parents and in-laws are pretty religious and sometimes I think it’s about not encouraging pride or seeking approval from sources other than God (that’s a big thing in evangelical style Christianity).

It really gets me down. I will tell my Mum something I am proud of and she will never ask any follow up questions or show an interest. She seems to see it as boasting and will always play it down. I see so many people be open and enthusiastic about the people they love and wonder why my family is so different. I try and compliment my children a lot. I am not naturally sentimental (due to my upbringing) but am trying to break the cycle. My husband’s parents were the same but hyper critical on top of that so he had it even worse.

The strange thing is I know that they all boast about their children and grandparents to other people. Somehow I think this is because they can make it about them? In the sense they can brag to the neighbour then they look like the amazing parent and grandparent.

Are other peoples parents stingy with their praise like this? I am trying to tackle how this makes me feel as I know it has made me desperate for approval in the past which isn’t the best way to be.

I love my parents and see them a lot and generally do enjoy their company. Part of me thinks it’s just the way they are because of age/ upbringing and religion. The less generous part of me thinks it’s because they like being the centre of attention and talking about themselves and generally aren’t interested in others.

OP posts:
AllFunAndGamesUntilYoureRunningForTheLastTrain · 22/01/2024 11:50

I was thinking today how differently I praise compared to DM. I was the first (& only) person in the family to get a degree and I don’t recall being told she was proud of me and, although hugged and kissed, never said ‘I love you’.

I constantly tell DC I love them, even though they are young adults. DM has only recently started saying it to me.

I wonder if it’s generational? DGM once commented to DM about her sitting holding my siblings hand, she said she wished she could have done that when DM was younger. She could have! it just wasn’t the ‘done thing’ in her day I suppose.

rainyhouse · 23/01/2024 12:33

My parents are the same op, and I am not English. I was once told by a peer that I had done a very good job only when I left.They said they didn’t want to say it before hand so it would not go to my head.
My mum also said that she never praised my sister in order to make her be more ambitious. It’s sad actually, both my mum and my peer were teachers at the time.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread