Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Husbands injury - advice

32 replies

LanaL · 06/09/2023 09:22

Hi
ive posted this here as it is about a relationship as it concerns my husband and this thread seems quite active . This is more for advice with the NHS

My husband had an accident with significant injuries ( there’s a complaint and possible negligence but that’s a long story ) so I’m trying to shorten it here .

He had a broken hip , broken shoulder and all ribs broken on one side . He was discharged, we believe unsafely , after surgery to repair his hip and shoulder ( advised to hop in and out of a large step to our home , told it was safe he could go out etc . No assessment , no one assessed our home or saw the step but we told them repeatedly and our concerns . Bear in mind using a crutch - both sides of his upper body are broken ) . The day after he came home he fell on the step and further damaged his hip and shoulder , damaging the pins put in and both breaks are actively deteriorating. The fall was 2 weeks ago. Before the fall he was healing well .

we went to a hospital appointment a few days after the second discharge to be told that his shoulder needs surgery asap ( still not had a date , we were told 1-2 weeks it’s been 2 weeks . ) With surgery he will have 80% function in his arm , leaving it will lead to complete loss of function as it’s deteriorating day by day. The original hospital told us he may need surgery - a nurse mentioned it in passing as he was being discharged- the new hospital knew nothing until we mentioned it then said it was an emergency. Had we not told them it would have been left.

Anyway , back to the main point. The new hospital told us at the appointment that his hip cannot be repaired by surgery , it’s actively deteriorating. This was all new information and unexpected . We had been led to believe his care was being transferred as the new hospital had a better surgical reconstruction team. The scan that day showed more damage than the scan a week before that he had just after his fall . They said they have two options . 1- a hip replacement if it continues to deteriorate- he would recover from a hip replacement within a few weeks , slowed down by his other injuries, but he would pretty much completely recover , be able to go back to his job ( a physical job but high paid and it’s his career he’s worked hard to move up and it’s all he has ever done - he’s 36 ) . No long term effects that would affect him day to day .
Option 2 - leave it to heal , if it stops deteriorating. But with this , he would need a replacement in 10 - 15 years anyway , but in the meantime he will have one leg significantly shorter than the other and have a permanent limp , need special built up shoes and have walking sticks permanently too. He won’t be able to do his job and his mobility will be affected in all areas of his life . This isn’t a “maybe” this is it , this is 100% what is going to happen without the replacement, the damage is already there and only replacing the hip will fix it.

My husband is 36, very active , we have children he plays football with them, he takes them swimming , he loves his job , he is the main income earner . This will kill him . His whole life affected , he will slip in to depression I know he will . This may not sound like a big thing either but he’s a very image conscious person - the amount of difference in the length of his legs means he can’t have discrete buildup inside his normal shoes it will be a specialist medical boot / shoe . The replacement would take all of this away and mean he can live a normal life , it would affect his ability for maybe extreme sports ( that’s fine ! ) but day to day he wouldn’t be affected and he would be able to do his job . As a side note the financial aspect will really affect us , as it stands I am not at work right now due to his care ( I have a post grad level career , newly qualified, but I work agency so no work = no pay ) and he was very newly self employed ( 6 weeks prior to accident ) so no income coming in - we have applied for universal credit but the income loss is about 70% . We have no savings . He asked the doctor if he could opt for the replacement- in an emotionally charged moment he said “ if I have to live like that I’ll end up killing myself “ - the response to all this was “ that’s not justification for a replacement” . The doctors reasoning was that there is no going back after a replacement and at his age they want to do what they can to save his hip - even though he had just said that they can’t , but he spoke as if him having permanent disabilities was the best option as “ most people cope ok “ but he has also just said that he categorically will not be able to do his job and that the sticks , limp , length difference is guaranteed and permanent- nothing they can do .

What can we do ? Can we push for the replacement ? Surely at 36 years old the replacement is the best option ?! He will have to have one in 10-15 years anyway but by then the prime of his life has passed . They also said that at some point the pins may start to protrude out of his hip and then if that got ‘too bad ‘ he might need a replacement. He worked hard to get where he is , I recently qualified in my field and agency work was temporary - I was going to go into a permanent salaried role once my son started college this year . My son is autistic and we don’t know what the future holds - I studied for my career so at this point , with my husband also recently making good progression , that we could begin to put things in place for his future … to save for a house so that we have some security for him and something to leave him so he doesn’t end up in the care of social services when he’s an adult if he’s not able to live independently and our time comes . This is impossible if he can’t continue to work . In 10-15 years my husbands prime part of his life is passed .

I don’t understand why they would leave him like that when there is an option. It’s not like we’re just saying we want it with no valid reason or to just make it a bit easier to recover - the entire course of our lives will change without it but most importantly my husband will have to live with permanent disabilities without it and I really worry how that will affect him and how he will cope .

OP posts:
WetBandits · 08/09/2023 10:25

Is there any chance of compensation to cover a private hip replacement if the accident was caused by negligence?

AbbeyGailsParty · 08/09/2023 11:34

You know hip replacements will need replacing over the years but your DH earning potential, his most active years too are here and now. Also technology moves on, by the time he needs another replacement they might be hugely improved, have a longer life expectancy. I’d go for the hip replacement now so at least one part of his body will be healed and active again. ( also walking in pain, uneven kegs puts strain on other joints and could DP more damage over time)
I hope you have a good lawyer. Feel free to PM me if you need a personal recommendation.

LanaL · 19/09/2023 17:40

I just wanted to update here. We had another appointment today regarding my husbands hip , this time a different doctor who assured us that he can have the hip replacement if he wants! He has said he like like to monitor it for 6 -12 weeks as there’s a chance the length difference may be 1cm which would mean an insert inside his she but wouldn’t leave him with permanent issues and he would be able to go back to work / play with the children etc pretty much live a normal life but if not then he will replace his hip. He was a lovely doctor who pretty much guaranteed that he would not leave him in a situation where he can’t live a normal life without mobility issues . It’s such a relief . Thank you all for your replies xx

OP posts:
Ginsmything · 19/09/2023 19:21

I haven’t read the whole thread but my DH had a hip replacement at 40 due to a birth defect and surgery as a child. He had a severe limp before the replacement but recovered really well and now doesn’t limp at all. That was 23 years ago so the 15 yr life span is not necessarily true. Hope it goes ahead soon and he gets a full recovery

LanaL · 19/09/2023 22:42

Thank you for sharing that , it’s nice to hear positive stories !
The doctor did actually say to us today that it’s certainly longer than 15 years that they last now xx

OP posts:
Babytwodue · 21/09/2023 09:54

What wonderful news @LanaL second opinions are definitely needed in situations like this.
everything crossed for a full and speedy recovery x

Popskipiekin · 22/09/2023 06:44

Wow well done for persevering, that’s such great news! I’m so glad you found someone who would listen to you and provide the answers you were looking for.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page