Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

What is your position in your family order?

37 replies

Restinggoddess · 13/06/2023 22:04

What is your position in the family ?- oldest child, middle child, only child etc

Do you think this has influenced your life?

Do you think it matters?

OP posts:
BatshitCrazyWoman · 14/06/2023 13:32

I'm an only. I'm pretty self-disciplined and resourceful. I'm also decisive and independent - very used to doing things on my own, and I enjoy my own company. Don't know if that's an 'only' trait.

Everyone in the generations above me has died, so I'm pretty much 'on my own' - would be nice to have siblings, and like a PP I find the sibling relationship between my adult children fascinating.

Bluebells1970 · 14/06/2023 13:35

Eldest. Younger sibling is the golden child and still completely dependent on our Mum even though nearly 50. It's quite sad really.

I'm grateful for it. It's taught me to be independent, and all of my energy goes into my own family of DH and DC/Grandkids. Took me a long time to feel like this though.

Londontomadrid · 14/06/2023 13:42

Youngest. Definitely felt I fit into the youngest sibling stereotype. I got away with a lot and was allowed to do things my elder siblings weren't able to growing up, going out with friends and staying out late etc. also I wasn't really taught basic life skills, like cooking! In some ways, I felt I was spoiled growing up, my parents did pander to my requests etc. I didn't do well at school because I sometimes just didn't turn up, which I didn't even really get in trouble for at home. Despite being predicted great grades, I didn't achieve them. However, now we are much older, I earn much more than my siblings in a professional job that I've gotten into through a bit of luck and lots of hard work.

roarfeckingroarr · 14/06/2023 13:44

DoesItHaveKosovo · 13/06/2023 22:25

I’m an only, with a good relationship with parents. I have a low bullshit tolerance but also hate any sort of conflict.

Me too!!

SnapPop · 14/06/2023 13:46

I'm the younger one of two. I am definitely more chilled out than my older brother. I think in most ways it's easier to be the younger one - I see the same with my own DC too.

caringcarer · 14/06/2023 13:58

Forth daughter of five daughters. I think Dad wanted a boy but he was happy I wanted to go to cricket matches with him. I was his favourite all though his life, probably because my sister's were all girly girls and I was a bit of a Tomboy. Mum just loved having 5 DD's.

Restinggoddess · 14/06/2023 16:07

Thank you for all these - it’s fascinating

Older brother is definitely more serious and was always the ‘more grown up’. DP confide in him mostly

Younger brother got away with murder - possibly the thinking is that by the time DP’s had had the trials and tribulations of child one and two nothing surprised them anymore and so were more chilled as parents. It used to really piss me off how he reached milestones at an earlier age than me ( first alcoholic drink at home etc) and he had a later ‘curfew’ than I did

We are all the sum total of our experiences to date - family position included, it’s very interesting.

OP posts:
CharlotteStreetW1 · 14/06/2023 18:28

Mymouthisonfire · 14/06/2023 07:33

Definitely.....DH and I are both the youngest of a big family.

We're incapable of making quick decisions because we were brought up having people think for us, talk over us and push us out of the way (our oldest siblings still do it even in their 40s!)

That's interesting. DH and I are both the youngest in our families and I recognise these traits in DH. Fortunately for him, I have very bossy traits and am happy to organise stuff.

I know he can do it, he's just happy to be led.

jadey1991 · 14/06/2023 18:33

I am the eldest of 4.

We all have jobs. Mine is higher in pay.

Sometimes I wish I had an older sibling to speak with and look up to but that's not the case. I am the one they all look up to. We are all very close

Soproudoflionesses · 14/06/2023 18:38

There are books about this op - fascinating subject. I am the younger of 2 but my sister was quite ill as a child so she has leanrt to be looked after whereas l am much more self sufficient. Lots of people say they would think l was older although obvs l look much younger lol!

Celticdawn5 · 14/06/2023 18:42

I was the youngest of 3 siblings for 12 years until my youngest brother came along when my mother was 40 . big age gap…my mother totally obsessed with him and still is at age 90 so I always think that’s when my childhood ended….she wasn’t interested in me at all.
I think a huge bearing which I didn’t realise until much later in life .

As the least favoured child ironically am reluctantly the one doing the caring for my mother.

MisschiefMaker · 14/06/2023 20:41

I think birth order has had a big impact on me. I'm the youngest of 2 and never had a say in anything we did as a family. My DF died young so I think perhaps my older DB's role in the family was elevated so he was half older sibling and half "the man of the house". He had loads of small responsibilities that I never had. Just things like mowing the lawn, doing the navigating while my DM drove the car, asking strangers for directions if we were lost, writing our family annual Christmas letter, etc. I was basically invisible to my DM. I never had to do anything, but I was also never allowed to do anything either. Small things like what to watch on TV would be entirely my mum & brothers decision. I couldn't choose my own food in a restaurant when I was young (my DB wanted to choose for me so e.g. I couldn't have a burger at McDonald's I'd always have to have nuggets, or I'd have to have pasta at an Italian because he didn't want me to have pizza). I also wasn't allowed to choose my own clothes until I was old enough to buy them myself.
I think these things add up over time so I grew to instinctively deprioritise my own feelings. I wasn't really allowed my own opinions (otherwise I would be screamed at and ridiculed) and much of the time I was blanked / ignored if I spoke to DM. Even non-offensive statements like asking my DM how her day had gone would be blanked so I ended up being a very quiet person who didn't talk much. When our pet cat died nobody even told me as I was such an unimportant family member, I found out from a neighbour weeks later (I was sent to boarding school so not at home when it happened). And when I was 15 my DM moved out for a few months because she was fighting too much with DB and again didn't bother to tell me until several days or even weeks (i don't even know) after she'd left and that was only because I had wanted her to pick me up from boarding school so she needed to tell me to get a taxi. She never explained what had happened or bothered to even let me know where she was staying for the time she was away.

I am not sure really whether it was worse for me or my DB. My lack of autonomy and consistently being blanked and ignored resulted in crippling self esteem problems as a teenager. Nearly all my good friends are only children which I don't think is a coincidence as I'm unable to make any decisions or push my preferences on others so I end up being friends with people that don't compromise. I didn't go through a teenage rebellion, instead I turned my feelings inward by self harming and with hindsight had very disordered eating. I still sometimes get very angry as I am prone to feeling powerless which can become anger.

DB went very off the rails as a teenager, I think he was unable to cope with the excessive scrutiny from my DM as she poured everything into him. He was a school bully and got expelled from multiple schools. He has a very odd personality and I've wondered if he's a little bit psychopathic as he never feels guilty and just puts himself first no matter what. He is the polar opposite of me in terms of being extremely outgoing.

Nowadays, none of us are very close and we don't really talk much at all. I grey rocked my DM but she didn't really notice, or if she did she didn't say anything.

This is an interesting topic. I've been thinking about it recently as my passiveness I think is interfering with my ability to be a good parent. I am just rubbish at setting boundaries. I've changed a lot and am so much better than I used to be but these characters traits are so ingrained they never really go away.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page