Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Wracked with guilt over leaving

22 replies

Pegs11 · 22/08/2022 09:16

Left my DH a month ago. I had a good reason but I just feel so, so guilty.

The guilt is the worst bit of this for me. I keep reminding myself I left because I had to, I couldn’t cope with his controlling, antisocial and humiliating behaviour anymore, it was like death by a thousand cuts for me and I would have ended up a husk. But reminding myself of that doesn’t help. I just know he’s in so much pain and torment and that he doesn’t understand what’s happened. Everything as far as he was concerned was going so great, he felt happier and more secure than he’d ever felt… and then I just suddenly up and left him. There’s only so much I can tell him at the moment too, for self protection reasons.

I can’t stop thinking about how this must feel for him. It’s really fogging up my thoughts, I should be focusing on myself but I’m struggling with the guilt.

Can anyone relate? Does anyone have any words of advice or methods for dealing with these thoughts and feelings?

OP posts:
Hanstarlucky · 22/08/2022 15:57

It’s natural to feel like this- you are empathetic and kind. Not everyone would feel the same. You are currently putting his feelings before your own. You have left because quite rightly you deserve better.

Hanstarlucky · 22/08/2022 15:59

Hanstarlucky · 22/08/2022 15:57

It’s natural to feel like this- you are empathetic and kind. Not everyone would feel the same. You are currently putting his feelings before your own. You have left because quite rightly you deserve better.

was he aware of how he was making you feel in the relationship?

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 22/08/2022 16:01

OP, you have done the right thing by prioritising yourself.

You sound like a very kind, sensitive and empathetic person - so now is the time to be kind to yourself.

You tried, it didn't work, so please let it go. x

Hanstarlucky · 22/08/2022 16:02

I still feel guilt and sadness towards my ex who was one hell of a horrible person, have faith that it’s good qualities to possess that you are empathetic but also have boundaries and you have ended it for reasonable reasons

when I felt like this I made a list of all the behaviours they displayed which made me feel like shit and all the times they hurt me without a care in the world and I read it often

AttilaTheMeerkat · 22/08/2022 16:12

Its not your fault he is supposedly in so much pain and torment; that is you ascribing those words to him perhaps as a way of explaining why he did the things he did to you. He abused you and targeted you deliberately because he saw something within you like your empathetic qualities that he could exploit.

You were never at all qualified to help him and besides which he did not want your help or support. You were not put on Earth to rescue and or save such abusive men from themselves; being a rescuer or saviour in a relationship never works.

What did you learn about relationships when you were growing up?. What sort of an example did your parents show you?.

Who taught you that you had to be some sort of rehab centre for such a man?. You do not. I am glad you got away from him and you need to stay away from him going forward too. Do you think he feels any guilt for how you were treated by him; no and there's no real remorse from him either. Love your own self for a change and use therapy to undo any emotional trauma bonds you have. I would also read about codependency and see how much of this relates to your behaviour.

anotherpotoftea · 22/08/2022 16:33

That guilt you’re feeling? It doesn’t sound like it’s actually yours at all.

When your partner is controlling and fails to take responsibility for their behaviour, you can end up with that falling onto you instead.

The fact you feel it does not mean it is rightfully yours. It’s a burden you’ve been left with.

Endlesslaundry123 · 22/08/2022 16:37

My words of advice are that he's a grown man. He is responsible for managing his own feelings. It is not your responsibility to make him happy or keep him happy or not hurt him. Just as you took responsibility for yourself by leaving an abusive marriage, rather than endlessly waiting for him to change/someone to rescue you, he must also take responsibility for his own life and happiness.

I understand it is hard, especially when someone has had a difficult life and you don't want to cause them any pain, but you are NOT responsible for his happiness. He's an adult.

Watchkeys · 22/08/2022 17:17

I think it's important to have a look at why you feel this way. Did you have to put your feelings aside for the sake of someone else during your childhood?

We're not born with the need to help others even when it feels terrible for ourselves, but lots of us end up feeling that way; usually we learn it when we're small, and we have an example set to us that adult relationships work in this way. What was your parents' relationship like with each other? What was your relationship like with them? Did they put each other first, equally, and respect each other's feelings? Did they listen to and respect your feelings?

The crux of your guilt will be in there somewhere.

You've done the right thing by leaving, and your guilt will teach you a valuable lesson, unless you ignore/surpress it.

Pegs11 · 22/08/2022 22:24

@Watchkeys yeah, there was a lot of stuff like that in my childhood. I’ve always felt that somehow I’m responsible for others. I still struggle to understand the difference between taking responsibility for your actions and how they can negatively impact someone else vs. not being responsible for others’ feelings.

I know I did the right thing listening to my gut and leaving, I’m just not sure I did the right thing leaving in the manner I did. And not sure I’m doing the right thing in the way I’m handling things now. I’m doing my best though, and maybe that’s all I can expect from myself.

OP posts:
Pegs11 · 22/08/2022 22:39

@anotherpotoftea you’re right. I think I’m feeling so guilty because I’m viewing him as being like a puppy that suddenly gets kicked when they thought they were being a good puppy and were really
happy. Like, he doesn’t understand why this is happening to him. In particular why it’s happening to him now. It’s not like we’d just had a series of massive fights or something. We were getting on better than ever, everything was finally going so, SO well for us (on paper, at least). We’d literally just had this big talk about how great everything was and how far we’d come and he told me he felt so happy and secure with me. And the next day I just up and left, vaguely citing communication problems and lack of trust and anxiety and not giving a full explanation. And I’ve barely communicated with him since. I have my reasons, and they are good reasons, and I am doing it this way to try and keep myself safe. At the same time I know it’s really hurt him and I feel so bad for doing that.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 22/08/2022 22:42

We’d literally just had this big talk about how great everything was and how far we’d come and he told me he felt so happy and secure with me. And the next day I just up and left, vaguely citing communication problems and lack of trust and anxiety and not giving a full explanation.

Why did you lie? Why didn't you tell him then that you weren't happy?

Pegs11 · 22/08/2022 22:43

@AttilaTheMeerkat I don’t think he feels guilty. I don’t think he is capable of feeling guilt, because he doesn’t really have much empathy. I, on the other hand, don’t seem to be able to help it. It’s probably partly what got me into this mess in the first place.

OP posts:
Pegs11 · 22/08/2022 22:52

@Hanstarlucky Yes… I am trying to take the lessons from this, about the importance of staying true to myself, having boundaries, not forgetting who I am. I keep reminding myself that although I was victimised, I am not a victim. I know I am partly responsible for the circumstances I ended up in, but that he was abusive nonetheless and I had to leave.

OP posts:
Pegs11 · 22/08/2022 23:03

@Aquamarine1029 I think I was massively in denial. I thought I was happy… then after we had this final conversation, I started feeling weird and unsettled and I couldn’t put my finger on why… and suddenly something ‘clicked’, and the scales fell away from my eyes. I realised I was viewing happiness through a very narrow lens, that I had become conditioned to not expect very much for myself. This realisation literally hit me like a bomb out of nowhere. It completely floored me. I was not expecting it at all. But there it was. I had to leave.

OP posts:
PiecesofFive · 22/08/2022 23:49

Were you together long?

Aquamarine1029 · 22/08/2022 23:53

I'm glad you got away, op. Do yourself a favour and drop the stupid guilt. It's a pointless waste of emotional energy. You are not responsible for your ex and how he feels.

TheSunnySide · 22/08/2022 23:56

I had terrible guilt when I left my alcoholic partner many years ago. I went to counselling and in around the third session the counsellor told me that given I was the one who chose to leave I had no business fretting and worrying about how he was feeling, the deed was done, I had good reasons and what he was feeling or doing was none of my business anymore. It worked. I stopped beating myself up, stopped the counselling and moved on.

Pegs11 · 23/08/2022 00:27

@Aquamarine1029 I’m gonna try. It’s much easier when I have no contact with him (and can just focus on myself) but I have to sometimes. I had to have an email exchange with him a few days ago because he (understandably) needed to know what was happening with the house and was asking whether he was supposed to leave and go rent by himself or what, and could I give him something more to go on as I had been totally uncommunicative. So, out of a sense of duty rather than really wanting to do it, I emailed back with some clear information and let him know where I stand on things, without going into the nitty gritty at all and trying to keep it unemotional while still being kind and considerate of his predicament. He emailed back and it was an emotional one from him, of course. So the guilt has got worse again after that. Even though he says blatantly manipulative things to tug on my heartstrings, and even though his tactics are more obvious to me than ever, it still tugs. I am just wired that way, dammit. It takes a huge effort on my part to detach myself emotionally and I fail often.

And I am forever questioning myself and whether my thoughts and perceptions of him are just really warped … if maybe I’m not giving him enough credit for the good things about him, if I’m failing to recognise that he has made progress and things are actually better and I’m just hung up on past stuff that I ought to just get over, if maybe I’ve been abusive to him too, or maybe I’m just too sensitive, or if I’m pathetic for not standing up to him, or if I just can’t accept his love and so am finding excuses to push him away, or if just all of this is my fault somehow… but then again, maybe all of that is the result of the years of insidious gaslighting. Honestly, I don’t know my own mind anymore, don’t know where the truth lies, don’t know how much of this I am responsible for … and how much it even matters. The fact is I wasn’t like this before we met. I’m not the person I was. I’m confused and anxious and I feel small and voiceless. So whoever is to blame and to what degree, it wasn’t a healthy place to be.

OP posts:
T1Dmama · 23/08/2022 00:36

This worries me… you’ve stated he’s controlling and was damaging to you.. the face he’s now making you feel guilty and manipulating you in this way is further narcissistic behaviour…
The best thing you can do is not tell him where you are and change your number.
You have to be happy, life is too short.
I f he starts hassling you please consider a restraining order. Controlling/possessive/jealous men are dangerous

Pegs11 · 23/08/2022 11:25

@T1Dmama I have heard it recommended many times that when people leave a narcissistic relationship they should cut all contact, change their phone number etc. But I don’t think that I’d be doing myself any favours doing that at this point in time. I want to minimise contact, for sure, because it is emotionally difficult for me to talk to him about the relationship and I end up feeling guilty and my resolve is challenged... But there is still a process of separation to go through and I still need to have contact with him in this regard, in relation to things like making decisions about the house sale (which is currently under way), getting access to the house so I can sort out my belongings, sharing custody of the dog, and also, soon, a couples counselling session, which I have agreed to try... even if it only serves to help us break up in a calm, amicable way.

He is manipulative and can be petulant, needy and self-centred, but he’s not a malicious/dangerous narc like some I’ve seen/heard about. My friend’s ex, for example, would physically push her around, threatened to destroy her career, he would put her down, insult and belittle her ceaselessly, would not let her sleep, would only buy her birthday and Christmas presents of sexy things he wanted her to wear for him, he hacked into her computer and put spyware on it, wrote letters to her (male) friends’ girlfriends saying she was having an affair with them... And when she finally left him, he stole almost all her friends and used them as flying monkeys. He actually ended up in prison (for something unrelated (embezzlement from the council)). He was pure evil.

My husband doesn’t even come close to that. These days, he is thoughtful and supportive and cheerful most of the time, the problem is that in the past he has hardly ever there for me emotionally when I’ve needed him, and he still has a tendency to make everything about him, hardly ever takes responsibility for problems in the relationship, will gaslight me, be dramatic about/exaggerate things, demand adulation and respond to even the slightest tiny criticism as though I’ve dropped an H-bomb, so I am walking on eggshells all the time and not voicing my needs. Still toxic, still exhausting, still a good reason to leave… but he’s not at the level of my friend’s ex.

It remains to be seen of course whether he could turn nasty… I don’t think he will, I think he might be difficult and put obstacles in the way, but I don’t think he would do the kind of evil stuff my friend’s ex did. But I’m being cautious nonetheless. At the moment he is being reasonably respectful of my need for space and time, a little pushy and manipulative at times, like, making it obvious that he’s suffering and trying to get my attention… but he’s not up in my face all the time or making threats or draining the bank account or anything of that nature.

The way I see it is, I want to extricate myself as gently as possible, not burn any bridges right now, explore whether there is any hope for us, if only so we can know we did absolutely everything to try and make it work, and so not always be wondering ‘what if’. And if we can’t make it work (which I suspect will be the case as I don’t think people really change), to see if we can split as amicably as possible without there being any horrific fights over money, custody of the dog etc.

I’m having to be the manipulative one now, which doesn’t come naturally to me, and is another thing making me feel guilty… but I feel it’s necessary at this point in time.

I may be wishful thinking… perhaps it would be better if I just get called him out on his abusive behaviour and let him react to it, perhaps that would actually push things in the right direction for me and bring more clarity to the situation. But I don’t think I’m ready to risk the bridge being irreparably burnt, not at the point where I feel I still need him “on side”.

OP posts:
T1Dmama · 23/08/2022 12:19

Pegs11 · 23/08/2022 11:25

@T1Dmama I have heard it recommended many times that when people leave a narcissistic relationship they should cut all contact, change their phone number etc. But I don’t think that I’d be doing myself any favours doing that at this point in time. I want to minimise contact, for sure, because it is emotionally difficult for me to talk to him about the relationship and I end up feeling guilty and my resolve is challenged... But there is still a process of separation to go through and I still need to have contact with him in this regard, in relation to things like making decisions about the house sale (which is currently under way), getting access to the house so I can sort out my belongings, sharing custody of the dog, and also, soon, a couples counselling session, which I have agreed to try... even if it only serves to help us break up in a calm, amicable way.

He is manipulative and can be petulant, needy and self-centred, but he’s not a malicious/dangerous narc like some I’ve seen/heard about. My friend’s ex, for example, would physically push her around, threatened to destroy her career, he would put her down, insult and belittle her ceaselessly, would not let her sleep, would only buy her birthday and Christmas presents of sexy things he wanted her to wear for him, he hacked into her computer and put spyware on it, wrote letters to her (male) friends’ girlfriends saying she was having an affair with them... And when she finally left him, he stole almost all her friends and used them as flying monkeys. He actually ended up in prison (for something unrelated (embezzlement from the council)). He was pure evil.

My husband doesn’t even come close to that. These days, he is thoughtful and supportive and cheerful most of the time, the problem is that in the past he has hardly ever there for me emotionally when I’ve needed him, and he still has a tendency to make everything about him, hardly ever takes responsibility for problems in the relationship, will gaslight me, be dramatic about/exaggerate things, demand adulation and respond to even the slightest tiny criticism as though I’ve dropped an H-bomb, so I am walking on eggshells all the time and not voicing my needs. Still toxic, still exhausting, still a good reason to leave… but he’s not at the level of my friend’s ex.

It remains to be seen of course whether he could turn nasty… I don’t think he will, I think he might be difficult and put obstacles in the way, but I don’t think he would do the kind of evil stuff my friend’s ex did. But I’m being cautious nonetheless. At the moment he is being reasonably respectful of my need for space and time, a little pushy and manipulative at times, like, making it obvious that he’s suffering and trying to get my attention… but he’s not up in my face all the time or making threats or draining the bank account or anything of that nature.

The way I see it is, I want to extricate myself as gently as possible, not burn any bridges right now, explore whether there is any hope for us, if only so we can know we did absolutely everything to try and make it work, and so not always be wondering ‘what if’. And if we can’t make it work (which I suspect will be the case as I don’t think people really change), to see if we can split as amicably as possible without there being any horrific fights over money, custody of the dog etc.

I’m having to be the manipulative one now, which doesn’t come naturally to me, and is another thing making me feel guilty… but I feel it’s necessary at this point in time.

I may be wishful thinking… perhaps it would be better if I just get called him out on his abusive behaviour and let him react to it, perhaps that would actually push things in the right direction for me and bring more clarity to the situation. But I don’t think I’m ready to risk the bridge being irreparably burnt, not at the point where I feel I still need him “on side”.

Ah yes I see. I had to stay as friendly as I could to my ex, he bought me out of the house but dragged his heels till I had to threaten him, that if I lost the house I was buying the house he was keeping would need to revalued as house prices had risen…. He then transferred the money very quickly..
maybe the way forward is to keep the emails/contact a little business like? Don’t respond to the emotional guilt he’s thrusting on you… easier said than done I know!!
my friends narcissistic ex sends her an email to say when he will next see the girls, and instead of it simply saying ‘I’ll collect girls Sunday at 10am and drop back at 6pm… the email is about 3 pages long, lectures her on crap she already knows and does.. puts her down and generally causes her upset and ruins her week….
My ex thankfully has no hold over me now as we have no shared assets (pets dogs etc) so once we split financially I was free to walk away and move on… and the abusive texts did eventually stop 2 years later! (I had changed my number several times but he always got hold of it!)
I wish you so much luck with your separation and hope he doesn’t make things difficult for you…. I hope the dog doesn’t become his way of manipulating you and hurting you. You seem to have your head screwed on, more than I did going through this in my 20’s.

Pegs11 · 23/08/2022 19:37

@T1Dmama Thank you. We are currently halfway through our house sale (that was already under way before I left) and I just can’t wait until that’s all done and dusted as it will be one less thing to juggle.

However I am not looking forward to the day I have to go and do my bit to clear the house, I think I will be very emotional. Saying goodbye to the home I knew… it’s going to be a difficult process of letting go. We were going to sell anyway, but of course I’d envisaged essentially moving the ‘home’ to another location, but now ‘home’ no longer exists for me, and I will desperately miss the old life even if it wasn’t perfect. I will especially miss my beloved cats, who I can’t take with me (DH will take them) and all the little routines I loved… it may sound silly but I’m even grieving for the tiniest things, like how no matter which room I was in, I’d always know which cat had just come in by the unique sound they’d make coming through the cat flap. And how all the pets would want to come with us when we went and sat in the garden, and we’d all sit there together. And how there would always be a lovely fresh coffee waiting for me when I woke up because my DH knows I need my coffee in the mornings. Just little things that delighted me, but which now make me so sad when I remember them. I miss those things so badly! Sometimes so much it makes me want to go back, and try to work things out, if only so that I can still have those things and not have to give them up.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page