Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Is there any point.

34 replies

justgivein · 28/12/2021 13:22

In getting married anymore. Seen so many threads about abusive husbands.

OP posts:
justgivein · 01/01/2022 07:50

I'm not going to string this thread out anymore I've been lucky with the people taking part.Any kiddies reading just don't get married too early ..give it at least five years,you know it makes sense.

OP posts:
nbsorted · 01/01/2022 10:27

I am not sure what you mean, introduce children into the mix? Abusive people are abusive to their children as well as their partner. I am not sure how what I said could help you sort your father out?

In relation to emotional intimacy, some children are not show love and support in healthy ways by their parents. They are more likely to choose abusive partners, because they are not aware of what healthy looks like. People who have experienced healthy relationships as children are more likely to choose healthy relationships as adults. They are also more likely to see the signs of unhealthy relationships quickly and get out quickly (well before marriage). Sorry, my post wasn't very clear.

I don't think it is to do with time though. There are various things you can do before you commit, rather than waiting. Eg getting to know their family and friends and colleagues means you get insight into how they manage relationships over time, how they deal with conflict, how they treat people, their values, their integrity, loyalty, kindness etc.

nbsorted · 01/01/2022 10:45

Sorry, I have re read your posts this morning and can see that you were just pondering marriage in a sort of philosophical NYE way! You can ignore my posts, as they were more about why I think some people do relationships better than others rather than pondering the future of marraige. Doh! My fault for not reading all your posts more carefully.

justgivein · 02/01/2022 05:04

@nbsorted

I am not sure what you mean, introduce children into the mix? Abusive people are abusive to their children as well as their partner. I am not sure how what I said could help you sort your father out?

In relation to emotional intimacy, some children are not show love and support in healthy ways by their parents. They are more likely to choose abusive partners, because they are not aware of what healthy looks like. People who have experienced healthy relationships as children are more likely to choose healthy relationships as adults. They are also more likely to see the signs of unhealthy relationships quickly and get out quickly (well before marriage). Sorry, my post wasn't very clear.

I don't think it is to do with time though. There are various things you can do before you commit, rather than waiting. Eg getting to know their family and friends and colleagues means you get insight into how they manage relationships over time, how they deal with conflict, how they treat people, their values, their integrity, loyalty, kindness etc.

I sort of meant if children were taught about abuse between partners at school that some of them would start confronting their abusive parents.I was using my father in my own case as he was...have you got all day ...a very complicated man and I don't think it would have helped atall standing up to him during my early teenager years But I'm sure they must include this in school past sixteen..well I hope so because again in my little world if I get out of line my kids will definitely tell us about it. I think it can go the other way with emotional intimacy if you mean men aswell.Like myself seeing all the things my father got up to and the lack of intimacy/support I got because my poor mother was having to deal with so much when I was a teenager and as before my father was just ogre like.I think it helped me get into a relationship with people that were totally not abusive especially my wife.

I'm not into ignoring people ,thanks for your posts.Smile

OP posts:
Graphista · 02/01/2022 07:05

Marriage isn't the cause of abusive relationships!

In terms of finances and legalities you're better off married than cohabiting

There have been a few threads recently to counter the abusive/shitty husband ones people don't tend to post when things are going well - they've no need to

That said ime sadly there are few truly decent and fair men out there.

Even the "good guys" are often lazy!

marriage unlikely to last now.

Divorce rates are increasing not because men are worse than in the past but because women are less trapped financially now! That's a good thing.

What we now need to happen is for men (as a class AND individually) to cop on and start behaving better!

The relationships I know of in real life where the men are the better husbands/partners are interestingly (though not surprisingly I don't think) the ones where the men were single parents with care for at least a period of time and/or were sahp at some point. Seems experiencing things "from the other side" gave them an education!

The rest of the ones that I know that are decent partners/spouses were raised either by no nonsense single mums who were determined their sons wouldn't be like their dads OR like the aforementioned were raised by lone parent fathers or fathers who at least for a time were sahp

@GoodnightGrandma many of us now WOULD class your stbxh as abusive - abuse doesn't have to be physical

I'm the child of an abusive marriage (all kinds of abuse) and I would say the mental abuse is FAR harder to deal with

A forum isn't an accurate cross section of marriages.

I agree to a point - but then approx half of all marriages end in divorce, couples that cohabit are even more likely to separate and then if you add in the ones where the women don't leave (societal pressures, financial entrapment...) then I reckon yes men are generally pretty shit at relationships!

My ex wasn't abusive...until he had an affair then he turned very nasty!

Not a person I recognised or even his own family recognised! His dad is one of the decent men I referenced. His 1st marriage split due to her affairs (plural) he continued to fully be part of his kids lives and bought a house in the next street to be close to them he also continued to pay half the mortgage and child maintenance of a decent amount (way before csa) so my ex hardly followed that example!

He was raised by a single father (his mother had died in the war in a bombing raid)

Ex emptied the joint bank accounts in the days after I booted him out, took the family car literally in the dead of night, took the computer and other valuables when he knew I was out with dd at a medical appointment - leaving me and dd stranded in the sticks with no transport and no money for basics!

but her mother is often saying she didn't really want kids.She had a good career writing articles for a magazine but it was just expected you got married next step is kids without really thinking it through.

Choosing to be child free is becoming easier.

I once worked with a woman of an older generation (I'm 49, if she's still around she's in her 90's now) who confided in me that partly how she knew her husband was the right person for her was he also didn't want dc. But they still told people it was because they COULDN'T to get the parents etc off their backs!

Might be considered disgusting by some not by me as I understood the pressures women were under in those generations.

I'm an unplanned pregnancy myself! Which is difficult to come to terms with considering the marriage that followed the shotgun wedding ended up abusive. While not actually my responsibility it does feel...difficult

I agree what's needed is lots of education! What a healthy relationship looks like, what's abuse and how to withdraw from a relationship that isn't working (for whatever reason) but that also needs to be shored up with better incomes and working conditions for women - especially mothers inc single mothers (we're still way behind on this!)

Education needs to be in schools as too many children aren't getting good examples/education at home

Actually I also think another reason why it SHOULD be taught in schools is so that children can recognise and possibly disclose abuse.

If abuse had been something discussed at school in my day I might have reported the csa as well as the other abuse and been safer than I was. As it was I left home as soon as I could (I was 17) and never went back! I didn't disclose to anyone until I was in my 20's as I didn't truly understand that what I had experienced was actually abuse (it was framed as discipline in terms of the physical and mental abuse and love in terms of the csa)

Also, if you are in a relationship with someone not abusive, it is also about understanding the value of it and the value in making the effort to keep the connection between you. It does require effort even with a great person, making time for them, consciously making the effort.

Absolutely

In hindsight I also married too young - 22 - even though we'd been together almost 4 years. You change so much in your 20's!

justgivein · 02/01/2022 11:46

Also the Dads/partners that stayed after work or finished work early because Mums had evening jobs or were volunteering in the evening there are alot of them aboutSmile.Toddlers to teens I had a good education,but sometimes it was really tough day after day and after a physically/mentally hard day.Not that I'm complaining of course wouldn't do that on hereGrin.

What sort of age are you looking at for kids to disclose abuse between parents?Wouldn't you have to be careful about kids thinking they are the cause of parents splitting .Even on here people argue about what is abuse .It can be a grey area for kids to take on.I wouldn't have a clue if I was a kid because my father went through a long period of depression and male menopause ,also an uncle with late diagnosed Aspergers living in the same house.I know I'll get shot down but just putting it out there.

OP posts:
Graphista · 02/01/2022 16:19

Re age and disclosing abuse.

Teachers and certainly social workers and others have training on discerning what's abuse and what's something else.

I'd rather we as a society err on the side of caution here BUT we would need the resources and infrastructure to back it up.

I definitely wouldn't want the situation I was in where I didn't even KNOW I could tell a teacher to still be the case.

GrandmasCat · 02/01/2022 16:29

The problem is not getting married is overstaying in a situation where things are getting gradually more toxic. Sadly, by the time women realise they should have ran from a bad relationship their confidence is at floor level and have no good incomes so they stay afraid of the financial implications of parting. Honestly, it is more difficult to decide to leave a bad relationship than staying in it.

But I think you have a point, both divorced and married women have struggles, some are similar, some are not, but in general, despite all the difficulties a most of my divorced friends look happier than most of my married friends do.

TheCatsKilledTheGonks · 02/01/2022 16:40

I don't think marriage and abuse are linked. But being married certainly makes it much harder to get out of an unhappy relationship. Getting married was the worst financial decision I ever made and caused an enormous amount of stress in terms of having to go through the divorce process rather than him simply moving out, if we hadn't been married. I'd never do it again and will advise my children to think very carefully about why they want to get married before they decide to do it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page