Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

He doesn't know I know his secret

41 replies

Haribo321123 · 09/10/2021 18:42

My boyfriend and I were talking on an intimate level for months and months before we started actually having sex and being involved on a relationship level. I'd that makes any sense. Our paths crossed as tricky times in our lives. He was 18 months out of his last relationship and was still sorter scared, grieving, got used to being alone. I had separated from my children's dad. It was like we really wanted eachother but we just couldn't seem to get it going. We still expressed love and feelings. Still talked everyday. Talked about what we wanted. Then he had a massive freak out and got scared. He ran away. I was heartbroken. I couldn't believe it.

Anyway for 4 months we pretty much cut eachother off. I spent all that time trying to understand and I missed him. He popped back in a couple of times but it was like his fears made him run. I gave up. But I kept peeking at his social media. I noticed a women had started love hearting his photos. I was suspicious. Went on her profile. She lives in another town. They had nothing in common. No friends in common. It didn't make sense. But I knew something wasn't right. When he got back in touch in May this year he kept me at a distance and I started to feel hurt and confused. Which resulted in me saying look what do you even want I've had enough. He shut down and said he had strong feelings for me but didn't know what to say. Later that day I saw this lady had liked his latest photo. So I got stressed and messaged her. I asked her if anything was going on between her and him. She said they were just friends but had a thing not long ago. I asked what thing? Explained I had been in his life for the last year but he had ran away. She said she was from tinder. They met a few times. Then he told her he couldn't have a relationship with her. He said he wasn't ready. She told me it was roughly April time they had this fling. She confirmed they had sex. Be never loved her. There was no talk of anything serious. I didn't say anything to him about knowing but told him I was sick of the situation and was done.

In July he turns up at My door. He's been to councilling. He finally opened up. He had been in touch with one of his dad's exes who had also helped him clear alot of baggage regarding his dad who had let him down alot. He admitted he had struggled massively to start with loosing his ex and he was so terrified when feelings came for me he just said to himself, he couldn't do it and ran. He said he wanted to tell me how much he loved me and wanted it to work but he needed time to sort himself and his support meant he now felt ready. He told me he's ready to put in 100% and he wants a relationship.

We have been together since July and everything is going great. But he's never told me about his tinder fling. She's still on his Facebook and they do like eachothers stuff. She's actually got engaged now. So she's moved on. I find it all abit strange that they have kept in touch.

Should I be worried and hurt he's hidden her from me. Or do you think he doesn't need to as we were off and technically it was nothing to do with me. I guess sometimes I'm hurt he has kept her on his Facebook if he wouldn't want me to know. What would you do?

OP posts:
Horriblewoman · 09/10/2021 23:34

@IComeInPeace congratulations on taking an obscure route to being on her side and deciding the man is the worst.

OP this is really odd behaviour. Why on earth would you message a stranger asking her why she liked a man's photo you weren't involved in?

IComeInPeace · 09/10/2021 23:44

wHaaaAT, he strung her along for ages telling her he had feelings for her while simultaneously seeing what's available on tinder.

If you'd be cool girl about that then that's your call.

HeartsAndClubs · 09/10/2021 23:46

Good god he should run a mile. You’re waving bunting here.

Imagine the responses if a woman posted:

“I was talking to a bloke on and off over a few months, but we never actualy had a relationship. Eventually I told him that I had stuff to deal with and I walked away. In the meantime I did date some and ended up meeting a bloke and we slept together. But there was never any relationship there and we were both very clear on that. Anyway, fast forward a few months and I got bac in touch with the other guy. We talked some, and since July we’ve been officially together and things have been great. However i recently discovered that he had stalked my fb while we were apart, and when this other bloke liked some of my pictures etc he had messaged him to ask him if we’d had sex.”

Not one person replying would say that the OP was the one in the wrong. Not one.

BoredZelda · 09/10/2021 23:51

I'd get really turned off by his behavior. It's really shabby.
She stalked him obsessively on FB, messaged a woman on his friend list about their relationship when she wasn’t with him, but you think his behaviour is problematic?

IrishMel · 09/10/2021 23:55

For me I could not be with someone who said they could not have a relationship and then went onto have that fling with another woman or fwb tinder thing. That will always play on your mind. He wasn't too lost to sleep with another woman. I think he will do a disappearing act again. Take your time and have a good think about what you want as he is just saying what you need to hear.

saraclara · 09/10/2021 23:58

@MrsRobbieHart

And you sound obsessive. Messaging a woman who hearted his picture? Hmm he should run.
Yep.
dangerrabbit · 09/10/2021 23:59

Your behaviour with this guy is creepy. If he was posting on this website, I would tell him to run!

Thewiseoneincognito · 10/10/2021 00:01

He needs to run from you! Poor guy is better off without you anywhere near him. You seem deranged OP..

Kuachui · 10/10/2021 00:02

You sound like the ridiculous one.
Firstly for letting him back in so often (doormat)
Secondly for messaging some random woman instead of just moving on
And thirdly for stalking his social media.

He sounds like he isn't ready for anything. Sounds like he's made a lot of excuses

Rummikubfan · 10/10/2021 00:04

Why on earth did you message a woman you had never met or heard of who you later found out slept with your someone you weren’t with and had never been with

Crimeismymiddlename · 10/10/2021 00:06

You messaged a stranger, about a man you were not in a relationship with due to her leaving love hearts on his profile. This is insane, rather than worrying about him keeping a fling he had when you were not in contact a ‘secret’ you should actually be worried about him finding out about this. Also he seems very hard work-is he worth all this bother.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 10/10/2021 00:08

For me I could not be with someone who said they could not have a relationship and then went onto have that fling with another woman or fwb tinder thing.

That would be consistent of them though? If they didn't want a relationship then it makes sense they'd want 'just' a one night stand / fling / FWB.

LoekMa · 10/10/2021 00:20

Sounds healthy

ImInStealthMode · 10/10/2021 09:24

@IComeInPeace

wHaaaAT, he strung her along for ages telling her he had feelings for her while simultaneously seeing what's available on tinder.

If you'd be cool girl about that then that's your call.

But the Tinder fling was during the 4 months that he wasn't in contact with OP. For all he knew she could have moved on in the meantime, or be doing the same?

The man has done nothing wrong here. In fact if it's true that he wanted to hold off from getting into a serious relationship while his still hurt from the last one then he's more admirable than some.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/10/2021 09:32

When did you actually meet him? It sounds like you mutually declared the love off the back of some online chatter over a few months. Then he legged it. Saw this other woman. Sloped back in, more love and now you’re together.

Why did you take him back if you don’t trust him? What makes you think she didn’t immediately tell him you’d contacted her?

And what’s the relationship actually like now you got what you wanted? It honestly doesn’t need to be this complicated. There are other men.

pollypocketlover · 10/10/2021 10:40

This sounds really unhealthy. It's not OK to message a woman you don't know to ask her questions about a man who you are not in a relationship with.

That being said, this guy sounds too much. He's let you down a lot of times and sounds really hard work. This isn't the type of guy I'd want to be in a relationship with. What happens the next time things get 'too much' for him? Is he going to run away again? I'd ditch him and find someone who isn't scared to give you the love and commitment you deserve.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page