Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

What's more important in life...

32 replies

importantinlife · 03/11/2004 19:50

...having children or having a fantastic relationship?
I've been pondering this question because my friend and I seem to totally disagree on this - this may partly be due to the fact that I already have children and she doesn't.
She has had an on/off relationship with a very difficult man for ten years now. About a year ago they split up and she had an affair with another guy, who was totally different to her ex in that he worshipped the ground she was walking on, wanted to commit to her etc... but she let him go and is now trying to sort things out with her ex again, while getting nowhere fast. She's 32 and I'm worried that she'll spend so much time doing this that she might miss out on having children, which would be devastating for her. But she says that he is the love of her life and that that is the most important thing.
I, on the other hand, have been with dh for 10 years now. We are happy, but not ecstatically so - we don't really have the same interests, just the same values and goals in life - the children are everything to us, and that's our main common ground. (I changed my name, by the way, as I wouldn't want dh to read this.) I know that he is faithful, dependable and a good provider. Some people might feel that what I have is not enough, that you should keep looking for your soulmate. But I feel that I'd rather have this relationship and have children and the life I have than hold out for something else while possibly ending up childless.
I know it's a very personal choice, but I was just wondering if there were people out there who feel like me?

OP posts:
welshmum · 04/11/2004 12:33

Oh JDM that is a really, really difficult one, I feel for you and I don't think I could possibly offer any advice at all. Only you could possibly know what's best for you and your family. I'm thinking of you and I hope you reach a decision that brings you happiness - of one sort or another!

johnnydeppsmistress · 04/11/2004 12:36

Thanks welshmum, that's really sweet! I am still pondering over it and have been for the past year..... it's very very tough as we also own and run our own business, so could be messy. Time will tell!

WigandRobe · 04/11/2004 19:27

Message deleted

fio2 · 04/11/2004 19:33

oh god we are both scorpios and we row...not that i beleive in horiscopes

aloha · 04/11/2004 20:18

I certainly don't think any long-term relationship can ever be constant excitement, sexual passion and butterflies. If that's what you (I mean that in the general sense - not referring to anyone) want, then in IMO you will never have a happy long-term relationship. There are very, very good biochemical reasons why the beginning of a relationship feels different to long-term love. And children do change everything too, at least while they are young.

hatter · 04/11/2004 20:39

very interesting thread. My dh too is in theory the perfect man (good father, good fun, intelligent, generous etc - he's also tall, dark and handsome ) but I do feel we lack a certain spark. On the other hand when we got together I can remember consciously thinking - this is not the "prefect" man but he's the one I want. I always felt that acknowledging the relationship's shortcomings boded well for the long-term future. Dreams about perfection have a nasty habit of coming crashing down.

kama · 24/01/2005 21:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

New posts on this thread. Refresh page