Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Should I give her another chance after cheating

38 replies

p12241342 · 25/05/2021 13:06

Hello

We do I start.

I have been with my partner for the past 20 years and most of the time things have been good. We have 2 lovely children and own our home, we are not rich, but we are not poor, everything is good (or was so I believed).

Over the past couple of months my partner has been distant, on here phone all the time and silly, but true, walking the dog for 2 hours at a time every evening. It felt like something was wrong and after asking her many times she tried to say it was me and I was looking into things too much. But I could see she was getting distant, not only in the day to day stuff, but in the bedroom too.

I spoke to her at the weekend after she had a bottle of wine thinking she would open up to me. To start it was a very close case and she was adamant she hadn’t got someone else. I asked three times and she said there was no one else. I asked her then to swear on our family (which is wrong I know) but I know she would do that unless it was true. Then she said yes there was someone else and she had slept with him also. What’s worse is that the man in question is our sons friends dad, who recently split up from his wife because his wife cheated on him (ironic).

My whole world come tumbling down around me in that short space of time. We continued to talk and more and more come to light. She originally said she had feelings for him and has told him that she loves him. She also said she had only slept with him once and that we 3 weeks ago. I’m 41 and she is 40 and I have found out that she is meeting a guy slightly younger in a car in a local car park (this is not where she slept with him by the way, or at least that what she’s telling me. Not that it matters) This was all happening when I thought she was out walking the dog. She would meet him nightly and then come home to me and our kids like nothing had happened. She says she felt guilty, but obviously not enough to put a stop to it. I asked how long it’s been going on and she said 8 weeks or so. I asked did she love him and has she told him and she said yes.

After speaking to her for many hours its sounded like she was telling me that we were splitting up. I threatened to tell my children what she had done, I know that’s wrong, but I did actually tell our 18 year old daughter. She was discussed with my partner and said she wanted nothing to do with her. Shortly after this my partner said to me that she didn’t want us to split and wanted us to work things out. She seems really sincere, she is full of guilt, so apologetic and full of remorse. After speaking with my partner she says she understands she has made a massive mistake and has done wrong.

The thing I can’t get over is that she slept with the guy early on. She said she felt guilty about sleeping with him, but she carried on meeting him in a car park when taking the dog and let her feelings grow. If it was a mistake why not put a stop to it. Instead she carried on meeting him nightly for another 6 weeks.

If she felt that guilty she would have stopped straight after she slept with him. But instead she carried on seeing him night after night. I even said to her, if you hadn’t have told me you would have been meeting him this week also. I feel she told me because I pushed her into a corner not wanting to come clean.

She is saying she made a mistake and wants us to try again. For us as well as the kids. She seems truly sorry and genuine and I do after all this believe that she does mean what she says. She sent the guy a text saying that she wanted to give things another go with me and that they shouldn’t contact any more. He text back saying “Ok if that’s what you really want”. They had this pact that she admitted, he wouldn’t text her unless she text him first. That way the coast was clear and I or the kids wouldn’t be around. She has been honest about all this even though she knows it will hurt me deeply. She deleted her accounts on Instagram, Snapchat etc which was what she use to text him on. She also blocked him on Whatsapp. But on Monday he then tried calling her when she was at work knowing I wouldn’t be around. Once again my partner was honest and told me this. She also said she didn’t answer because she wanted us to work and promised she wouldn’t. She didn’t have to tell me.

We have been talking overnight and she has told me that she loves me and what she feels for me and what she feels for him is different. She loves and wants me. Not him. It’s going to take a long time to get over my hurt, but I thought I need to try and get over this as I don’t want to lose her as I love her with all my heart. It’s hard, but I need to try. I said to her tonight that may be, she needs to send him one last text and tell him it’s over and to stop contacting her as he has been trying to make contact. She said no leave it, he knows and she doesn’t need to tell him again. This morning she felt so loving and was texting and asking if I was ok. Then all of a sudden out the blue she said, should she text him one last time to once again say its over and to stop contact. That’s sent me back to the start. Why is she thinking about him or his feelings. She didn’t think I dissevered an explanation when she was sleeping behind my back and meeting him each night. Why is she thinking that she should be contacting him one last time. I’m just glad she is being honest with me and not just doing it anyway. She said she doesn’t want it to be arkward if she bumps in to him.

Is that the real reason or is she pinning for him and because she hasn’t spoken to him in a number of days she really wants to make contact. My mind is all over the place and just don’t know what’s real any more.

I’m hurt, im sad and I’m missing the person I love more than anything else in the world. I just don’t know what to do.

Am I doing the right thing? Should I be giving her a second chance ( I really want to as I love her ) but am I stupid for doing so. Even though she says she has feelings for him, but doesn’t want to be with him she wants me, is that true? Or by her wanting to make contact, is that a sign that she can’t leave him alone?

She did say one thing that made sense which was “if she really wanted him and wanted to leave wouldn’t now be the perfect time to do it because of all the mess we are going through now.

She said she doesn’t want us to split she will do whatever she needs to do to gain my trust again and she understand it will take time. She could leave right now but she wants to stay. Am I being silly letting her stay and thinking I am the one she wants because I want to believe it so much or should after all the above, should I be cutting ties once and for all. By the way I know people stay for the sake of the children, but I want to save what we have for me and my partner as well as our children.

I’m sorry I have rambled but any advice would be much appreciated

OP posts:
JesusIsAnyNameFree · 25/05/2021 17:10

I do think you need to try therapy if you're going to have a chance of making it work.

Do consider taking time apart as well. You need some space to figure out what it is that you really want.

Tiger2018 · 25/05/2021 17:27

I really feel for you both. There will be a reason she has chosen this path, whether she's aware of it or not at this stage. When she told you, she threw a bomb into your marriage and there is no going back to what it used to be.

Right now it is all so so fresh. I don't think its wise to make any long term decisions about your relationship if you aren't sure on whether you want to work on it or not.

When it happened with me and my exH, the minute he told me he knew of my affair, in that moment, I knew that I no longer wanted to remain married to him. Something just clicked and I was done. It was nothing to do with the other guy either - the marriage hadn't been working for a very long time. I am not proud of how much I hurt my ex or the decisions I made, but I didn't give my ex any hope of reconciling as that would of been even worse. If I hadn't of been so sure, I would of asked for space for us both to think.

I think thats what may help you (space) - as this is all so raw you need time to reflect on what you want and your wife needs the space to consider what she wants too as it seems like she is swinging from in/out and that isn't fair on you.

Gently said, please do not further involve your children in your relationship. This is between you and your wife. The reason I say this is that my ex did involve our children during the initial dday period and it damaged their relationship with him for a while. I know that you are angry and upset, please reach out to your friends or family for support.

TwinkleStar88 · 25/05/2021 17:29

So you had a healthy sex life and she chose to stop having sex with you in favour of this man. Wow, that’s quite something! I almost feel angry for you.

Sakurami · 25/05/2021 17:46

I wasn't able to forgive an affair or trust him again. I tried though and I'm glad I did.

However, I did not involve my child because it has nothing to do with them.

I feel disgusted that you told your daughter. Do you think it is fair on her (your daughter that is). This is between you and your wife and if you do decide to split up what you tell your children is that you both love them and their relationship with each parent doesn't change etc etc.

2bazookas · 25/05/2021 17:47

I said to her tonight that may be, she needs to send him one last text and tell him it’s over and to stop contacting her as he has been trying to make contact. She said no leave it, he knows and she doesn’t need to tell him again.

Then next morning she suggested contacting him .

Something doesn't quite fit there. I am wondering if what hapened was, she told him you knew and suggested leaving you for him; and he got cold feet and refused. (Not surprising; he's just out of a painful breakup and has discovered free no-strings sex; why tie himself down again? ).

That would explain why very suddenly she loves you again and is very sorry and wants to stay with you.

AusFrosty · 26/05/2021 03:39

Is the other guy single? If yes why would he be having sex in a car ? Doesn’t make sense.

I don’t think you have the whole story.

It sounds like your wife did a 180 soon after you found out - one minute she is half out of the door, the next minute she loves you and it’s all a mistake.

My money is on your wife telling other man she is leaving you and he puts the brakes on - he’s happy to continue having sex in a car but doesn’t want her moving in - perhaps because he is already in a relationship.

Seadad · 26/05/2021 07:53

Yes - sex in car means he's cheating too! They aren't teenagers!

TwinkleStar88 · 26/05/2021 08:50

The OP says the guy has separated from his wife, so he is single. I suspect they’re having sex in his car because he has kids at home and he’s the OP’s sons friends dad.

feeficken · 26/05/2021 10:27

@p12241342 I am sorry your going through this, I know how it feels as I am too living this nightmare with my wife right now. My wife has said many of the things your wife has said and I will be honest its turned out pretty messy as my wife has bounced back and forth between myself and OM and that went on for a year. The last few months she has been living at home (with me) while dating OM apparently looking for somewhere to live.

I will be brutally honest with you in that once your OH has had their head turned it can be VERY hard to turn that around. Please do not do the pick me dance I did that for best part of a year and it has totally destroyed me. Its very early days for you and it may not have settled in yet what she has done so take it very slowly, listen there may have been problems in your relationship that contributed to the lead up to this BUT she made a choice and there where better less hurtful ways to deal with it.

Take it easy and remember that words are easy, watch her actions that should tell you what you need to know if the relationship can be saved or not.

AusFrosty · 26/05/2021 11:25

@TwinkleStar88 - yes maybe - but kids at home that he had no intention of introducing OPs wife to.

TwinkleStar88 · 26/05/2021 11:43

@feeficken - Gosh I can’t believe your wife has the audacity to stay living with you, whilst she sees the other man, just kick her out. She made her bed, she can lie in it. Don’t allow others to treat you as an option.

Phoenix121 · 26/05/2021 11:43

OP, if you want to make it work you should be aware that this will be a new type of relationship - you won't be getting the old one back ever. So many things change your reality after you have been betrayed. There will be unexpected triggers for you which may last a very long time if not forever. Obvious triggers, like her walking the dog, but also tiny, ordinarily insignificant triggers (e.g. driving past a road with the same name as the Other Man - sounds crazy, but anyone who has experienced this will know exactly what I mean).

Your mind will play tricks on you and catch you out when you are least expecting it.

Although you're wavering, it sounds as if you want to make it work. It can be done but only if you and your family understand that you can never go back to the relationship which existed before.

TwinkleStar88 · 26/05/2021 11:44

@AusFrosty - The OP’s son is friends with the other mans son, so her being at his house would have raised suspicions.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page