Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

I need an honest opinion about MIL... Long but please, I need your opinions

36 replies

Chandra · 02/11/2004 20:36

Well, as many as you are aware, I have some issues with MIL, since we decided to marry she started acting as if I was not good enough for his DS. She is horrible sometimes but she always disimulate the ofense in the way of saying: "Oh but I love you very much, but how do you expect people to be nice to you if you don't hide you come from latinamerica"- or "I don't know how do you do it but when DS was dating X he always dressed very well, but then X cared about those things" or "I don't care what you think but you don't have my permision to...have a dog, name my grandchild with that name, move to another country or seeing the relatives I don't like". The problem is so deep that the main reason we don't go back to Spain is that we are sure our marriage won't survive so much pressure. Since DS was born this has been a war, she finds extremely difficult to respect our decisions and as a result DH and I relationship gets affected. I used to blame DH for not stoping her but since DS was born DH has tried very hard and we only get treats saying that she is going to do whatever she wants.

A few months ago, she demanded to see DS (he was 14m at the time), we have not planned to visit her for several reasons but the main obstacle was that my visa was expired and it took months to renew it and as a result I couldn't go out of the country, but she threw a tantrum and requested DH to leave me here and take DS to her. I was so shocked at that request that DH didn't even comment on that.

At the moment I'm very stressed as I have to submit my dissertation in 2 weeks, we had planned to go this weekend (DH had a business trip to Spain and we have said DS and I would go with him), unfortunately I will be risking failing the dissertation if I go now, so we have spend the week thinking how to tell her to avoid a further drama, so we decided just to postpone the trip for two weeks. DH told her about it today and hell broke loose, she is fuming and DH (who atm is in Austria) rang me an hour ago to tell me that after his meeting in Spain he will come back to pick up DS and take him back to Spain to his grandmother. I really don't know if I'm over reacting, but both DH and I don't trust her to take care of DS, I understand she is his grandmother but why do we always have to do the things her way? why is it to bad to wait 2 weeks?, she has said that she had to cancel something to be home this weekend and had lost some money, and the only thing I'm tempted to do is to send her a check for the amount and cancel the trip at the end of the month.

I really need a reality check, I don't think is right of me to let DS go alone when he barely knows her, I really don't trust DH to take proper care of DS (He is a great Dad but sometimes he gets concentrated in other things and don't pay attention, sometimes he forgets to feed him, other times DS has had some little accidents while DH is distracted), my MIL has a pond, a swimming pool and toxic substances at home (some pigments she uses to mix her oil paintings are very poisonous), and she is far more uncareful than DH. Would you risk a biiiiiggg fight with DH to avoid taking DS (without me) to stay with MIL? Or would you just let him go and pray nothing bad happens?

OP posts:
Caligula · 03/11/2004 09:57

Go Secur, go!

Quite right. Glad we've stiffened your resolve, Chandra!

secur · 03/11/2004 09:59

Message withdrawn

MarsLady · 03/11/2004 10:01

Chandra, it took 10 years to sort us out. If I had stuck to my resolve at the beginning and DH had remembered who he wanted to wake up next to for the next 20 years then it would have been sorted sooner. No need for excuses. Set the boundaries and tell her NO! Talk with DH and decide the way you want your family life to be. As someone said earlier (sorry sleep deprived don't remember)she sees your DS on YOUR terms. With you every step of the way. Stay strong. Short term pain, long term gain. Believe me there is a lot more happiness in our house now. Kisses

MarmaladeSun · 03/11/2004 12:01

Chandra...call her bluff. If she wants to see the little one so badly, be as nice as pie (through gritted teeth I know) and invite her over. Offer to do the booking for her, and to pay for her ticket! (But only if you're in the position to do so in the unlikely event that she accepts!). Then if (and when) she makes her excuses you have the perfect weapon. It's much easier for her to travel on her own than for you and DH and DS to traipse over there with all the paraphernalia that accompanies a small child.

XenaWP · 03/11/2004 12:31

My sixpence ha'penny would be that you need to deal with her yourself, like the bully she is.
You do need your dh to be backing you - that's vital & she needs to know that, but her problem is with you. I don't think you should fib about an illness (unless you really can't face her) as it's not going to help long term. You & dh should discuss how you both feel about your immediate family and how you want it to be, then you let her know this. Be as open as possible and as honest then let her like it or lump it.
Not sure I'm being cleear here - not a lot of sleep at the mo', but above all, good luck. I've a 'semi-Latin' MIL (northern French) so have had a little of this.

Grommit · 03/11/2004 12:40

Chandra - you are not overreacting. She is a bully. She needs to realise it is your life, your husband and your child. She has no right to dictate. Suggest you discuss with your dh and ensure he will support you and you must stick to your guns. When she next insults you must tell her you are hurt and offended. Let her keep going the way she is and she will ruin your life! Good luck

GRMUM · 03/11/2004 12:57

As I said before you and dh have to be united but any decisions have to be seen to come from him. If you do all the talking etc she'll just use it as ammunition against you. I know I've said this already but I really believe its the only way to go. Is your dh an only child? If not is she like this with other daughter-in-laws?

shalom · 03/11/2004 20:26

if she expects her son to do what she says then she should expect your son to do as you say. You are both mothers She controls her son you control your son. DONT LET HIM GO. If she can't resect you how can she respect your son-no matter how young he is!!!

Chandra · 04/11/2004 02:22

Wow!, haven't realised there were so many extra messages. Thanks . As an update, I have talked to DH today and DS it's not going on this trip, additionally, lovely DH is offered to return after the meeting to help me with DS while I work in the dissertation. (his mother is going to kill me, DH was suposed to spend the weekend at her place ).

Shalom, I perfectly understand what you say, but what can I expect of a woman who, when I mentioned about us being given our children to take care for a time as if they were borrowed, answered "My children are mine and I decide what they should do"? Actually I refused to see her during the 9m of pregnancy because she told me about DS "that child is not only yours, it belongs to us as well(the inlaws)" Though I don't think my DS belongs to me (he belongs to himself) I felt like the woman at Rosemary's Baby.

It's a horrible situation, in the past I used to blame DH for it, but I have seen him trying so hard but the wretched woman it's just impossible. I would preffer to stop contact all together for a time but I think DH would suffer from such situation as well... so I don't know what to do! I supose I will need to improvise when the time for a big discussion comes, but I will keep your comments in my mind. She always say she is not rude, it's me who is too sensible (told after she said that one of my best friends deserved to be annoyed by people because she had darker skin (just slightly darker than mine )GRRRRRRR!!!!

OP posts:
Chandra · 04/11/2004 02:24

sensitive, not sensible (though it would be nice to hear her say I'm sensible as well). Cows will fly past my window before that happens

OP posts:
MarmaladeSun · 04/11/2004 10:24

Aaarrgghhh....how annoying this woman seems to be. I too believe that our children are only on loan to us, and certainly don't 'belong' to anyone. I get really cross with my Mum, as if my ex hubby is having the children for a few days, and is taking them to see his Mum, my Mum sulks and says things like 'I have more rights to those children than she does' or something similar. Actually, er, no...no-one has any rights to them IMO. Well done to you for standing your ground

New posts on this thread. Refresh page