Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Naive expectations of inlaws ending in disappointment

43 replies

Watchyowstep · 13/03/2021 09:40

When I moved to DHs home town prior to us having children together, I automatically assumed that my inlaws would look out for me. My Dad isn't around and I was moving 200 miles away from my Mum.

I can see that the problem is my expectations, but I can't help but feel disappointed. They have offered practical help with childcare regularly which has been immensely helpful, but I feel like they have conquered and divided DH and I.

His mother has been blatantly rude to me throughout the time I've lived here, ignores me when I speak, challenges my parenting, has even outwardly insulted me. Whereas DH can't do any wrong, he is the perfect parent and she listens to intently to all he has to say.

When I was poorly and struggling, she would still ask me how DH was, without any regard for how I was. Constantly telling me how "hard" DH worked and how worried she was about him. Although I'd been diagnosed with a chronic condition requiring treatment and was up all hours breastfeeding, which she just brushed under the carpet.

When I told her I was struggling and needed more support from DH, she told me I needed to "get out more" and that DH "deserves a rest."

Unfortunately, this attitude and differential treatment of the 2 of us I think has been influential in dividing us. DH thinks he's entitled to more free time and is disregarding of my needs although he denies this.

I often just feel like the carrier of their grandchildren and not a lot more.

Can anyone relate? Or has anyone had the opposite experience of warmer, more caring inlaws?

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 13/03/2021 20:12

@Watchyowstep

And no I'm not young. I'm 37. I have never come across a family dynamic quite like theirs before I have to admit and I often think DH acts relatively immature because of it. But, I'd assumed (naively) that they just really loved their grown-up kids and thought they might love me too.
I have to say I’m very surprised, You’re knocking on forty and wanting your in laws to act as parent guardians of you and complaining your husband is the immature one because they don’t love you as much. Are you maybe trying ro compete with him in their affections, which has reduced you to this?
WisnaeMe · 13/03/2021 20:18

@Howshouldibehave

I'm well aware I have a DH issue.I've already applied for a divorce

That changes things rather. It could be that your marriage has been obviously failing and your MIL is just looking out for her son.

But, I'd assumed (naively) that they just really loved their grown-up kids and thought they might love me too

I think yes, it’s probably naive to think that in a marriage break up, in laws will not favour their own child.

what a horrid response and very unfair to OP 🌺

WisnaeMe · 13/03/2021 20:20

I have to say I’m very surprised, You’re knocking on forty and wanting your in laws to act as parent guardians of you and complaining your husband is the immature one because they don’t love you as much. Are you maybe trying ro compete with him in their affections, which has reduced you to this?

knocking on 40 !?

this post is horrible

EKGEMS · 13/03/2021 20:20

@Bluntness100 The OP is referring to when she was supposedly happily married not during the divorce process! I suppose you can't get past your habit of blatant bias vs ANY poster on this forum

WisnaeMe · 13/03/2021 20:21

Glad you're Divorcing him OP 🌺

EKGEMS · 13/03/2021 20:22

@WisnaeMe Don't be shocked she's blatantly bitchy and recently got her arse handed to her about a month ago on another post she was so awful towards another OP

Bluntness100 · 13/03/2021 20:28

Sorry I missed they were divorcing.,,

WisnaeMe · 13/03/2021 20:30

I hope you're able to relocate nearer your own family OP, is this a possibility or are there complications 🌺

Watchyowstep · 14/03/2021 07:26

Thanks all.
Don't worry, I've come across @bluntness100 on countless posts before. I know the response before I even read them; always contradictory of the OP; always disparaging; never sympathetic. She appears to be hell bent on attacking OPs. I've complained about her before. She/he must live a very miserable existence.
@WisnaeMe
@EKGEMS

Moving closer to my Mum is an option, but I'm hopeful not to up-route DCs now that they've made friends at school etc. I'm optimistic that leaving him but staying quite local will be enough to set me free from feeling like the poor family member and give me the scope to find support in friendships.

OP posts:
Bluebirdhumming · 14/03/2021 09:46

I'm sorry you're going through this @Watchyowstep. It sounds very difficult and lonely. Do you have a group of friends you can lean on around there?

I also had naive expectations about the relationship between my exFil and his wife when I first got married.
I realised after a few years it was best to be superficially friendly and have no real expectation of a genuine kindness from them whilst exH wasn't in the same room.

Luckily, he stuck up for me.

user1493413286 · 14/03/2021 10:00

I’m sorry your pil are like that, mine are very supportive and they look at things quite fairly and will tell DH to stop working so much to help me and will stick up for me to DH if he’s being unhelpful. More importantly when they can see that both DH and I are knackered they’ll offer help so we can both rest or sleep.

JourneyToThePlacentaOfTheEarth · 14/03/2021 10:14

Sorry to hear this op. I would be really disappointed tbh. My in laws accepted me and my kids completely. Helped with childcare for all the dc whether blood related or not. Sing my praises everywhere they go, enjoy my cooking and gave alot of support generally. They can annoy my dh by having too many opinions but mostly questioning him not me. Your exdh seems to have enjoyed having their support but against you, when you should have been a team. He sounds strange. I hope you find happiness in your new life and reconnect with all your family and supportive friends

whichwayisup · 14/03/2021 13:14

I think it's hard for people who haven't experienced a manipulative mother in law to appreciate just how difficult it is to negotiate.

It definitely needs the husband to recognise the issues and address them. It's really sad that this hasn't happened with your husband. Your mother in law will be over the moon that you are getting divorced.

I think it's even harder when you are from a normal family where, warts and all, you are loving and trying your best to do the right thing.
It really floors you when you catch on to what's happening.

I can't imagine the damage that would have been caused by my mother in law if we had lived 5 minutes up the road.

I feel for you OP, I'm glad you are getting out.

Watchyowstep · 14/03/2021 15:12

Thank you for the support. I don't have many friends here. I also work quite a demanding job in addition to DCs so never had much time for socialising and making new friends when DCs were small, I'm also quite shy.

I genuinely thought they would embrace me and welcome me into their fold. But the more I think about it, DH hasn't helped me make friendships either, always keeping his friendships very separate to me. I only see his friends and wives at a weddings and I seem to sit on my own whilst he stands at the bar drinking with his mates. The wives all seem to be friends already.

DH really hasn't helped me out at all with building friends and support networks. It's like he's kept them all for himself. He's also loved by everyone, they all seem to look out for him as he's also very quiet.

I feel like an idiot.

OP posts:
Stillfunny · 14/03/2021 16:09

I had similar experience in my marriage. And I had moved 3000 miles for him. MIL acted like he did me some kind of favour by marrying me .
I got a lot of passive aggressive remarks about how she was such a good wife and mother , pointing out my shortcomings. Yeah, like not giving a shit about how good at ironing she was or have a rigid shopping day. It was the first time I'm my life I encountered people would didn't like me much .
And also , my DH didn't make much effort to acclimatise me , never took me around to introduce me to anybody. I did make my own friends when I started working though.
Once the DCs came and she let me know that she considered childcare my problem and not to bother DH. I decided I wanted to leave and move near my own family. Best decision ever.
I am hoping to divorce him soon , but that is another story!

WisnaeMe · 14/03/2021 16:59

Moving closer to my Mum is an option, but I'm hopeful not to up-route DCs now that they've made friends at school etc. I'm optimistic that leaving him but staying quite local will be enough to set me free from feeling like the poor family member and give me the scope to find support in friendships.

I would recommend moving sooner rather than later OP, as others on here will tell you, the longer he attends the school near your STBX and InLaws, the less likely you will be allowed to move even if you wanted too.

You say you have no friends no support or anything there, you need to consider yourself as well as your child. Please consider moving home and soon. 🌺

HTH1 · 14/03/2021 19:04

@NerrSnerr

I agree that the issue is with your husband and not your in-laws. She sounds insensitive but you need to sort it out with him.

I remember when I had a toddler, was pregnant with my second and had awful hg. My husband had to do most of the parenting when he wasn't at work as I was really unwell. My MIL suggested that my husband goes to stay with her for the weekend leaving the toddler with me as he must be so exhausted. Luckily he told her thanks but no thanks.

My MIL suggested that her two favourite members of my family, DH and DC1, went to visit the in-laws (a flight away) while I and DC2 stayed at home! I wonder how it would have gone down if I had suggested that only FIL visited us while she stayed behind...
HTH1 · 14/03/2021 19:40

OP, I don’t think you expected too much to be welcomed into the family but, in the circs, I also think it would be much better for you (and easier on the DCs) if you moved back now.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page