Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Happy married but can't stop thinking about a guy from my past

17 replies

AllTheOtherNamesWereTaken · 25/02/2021 09:18

I'm basically looking to see if this is quite normal and hoping to hear it will pass?!

I'm honestly so happy I'm my marriage, we have a baby on the way and I really love my husband. This may be relevant, we have both discussed and know that our sex life is the worst part of relationship as we have such different preferences and there's only so much that it's going to get better for both of us. Were clearly both never going to get the sex we'd love but we're both at peace with this as the rest of our relationship and we'd never cheat.

I'll explain this as quickly as I can! About 10 years ago I met this guy and we got on like a house on fire, we had a couple of intense weeks of spending time together as we were both away on the same trip. It wasn't until the last few days we realised we liked eachother more than just friends and on our last night we had a short but amazing night together in a hotel. A couple of years later he was still saying wow about that night!

However he went to uni on the other side of the world and it was unspoken between us that neither of us wanted to go into a long distance relationship so we just remained friends. We stayed in touch then suddenly he disappeared for a year and I was confused thinking he'd blocked me on Facebook which was our form of communication. Then after year I got a message from him- he'd met a girl and deleted his Facebook. I was angry with him for not just telling me but he apologised so sincerely we began to be be friends again. However it hit me so hard and I really felt heart broken for a long time.

For a few years I'd see him 1-2 times a year and we'd love hanging out but we were never both single so nothing happened. I'd describe the chemistry/tension between us like in Hancock when they get close and all the popcorn starts popping!

Then about 5 years ago I met my now DH and this guy started talking to me so much less and we haven't seen eachother since (he didn't come back to the UK for the first few years). I reached out recently and said I missed being friends with him and he basically said you're married and I don't want to confuse or complicate that (I said I'm happy married and it wouldn't). He was perfectly happy to speak to me when he had a long term gf and let me be hurt by hearing about the relationship but now he's single and I'm not he doesn't want it the other way round which seems unfair to me.

He now lives in the country again and I find myself often thinking back to that night and fantasing about more. I'd never act on it but I just can't stop thinking about it, it's probably just lust is this normal for people without their ideal sex life? And it's probably worse because a relationship was just out of reach with him for so long?

I imagine you're all going to say to steer well away! I'm just going to leave him be and concentrate on my own life. I'm mostly just wondering if any of you have a similar situation of thinking of an old flame and if/when it passed?

OP posts:
AuntieStella · 25/02/2021 16:22

It passes faster when you start making a conscious effort to,stop thinking above t him.

When you find you are, stop yourself. Note that you were thinking about him, then tell yourself it's wrong, and deliberately turn your thoughts to something else.

With a bit of practice, you will be able to end this useless thought pattern.

And yes, he's said the friendship is now over, so respect that and leave him alone. It doesn't matter whether he was 'fair' - you've moved on

Cockenspiel · 25/02/2021 16:30

I would think this will keep coming up for you, given that you've decided to stay in (and bring a child into) a relationship which is not fulfilling your (sexual) needs.

More to the point, why would you decide to marry and have a family with someone who doesn't meet you needs? You clearly aren't 100% happily married, you've simply 'settled' - which is fine, many, many people do, but being in denial about it isn't going to change anything.

As for this other bloke - he can choose to not be in contact because you're married, that's totally fair enough and his choice and to be honest is pretty admirable really. It's clear that you massively fancy him and still have feelings, so why you'd want to reactivate a 'friendship' is very questionable and also very unfair on your current partner (and unborn child).

AllTheOtherNamesWereTaken · 25/02/2021 16:56

I can definitely understand that about you saying about settling. It honestly doesn't feel like it though as everything else in our relationship is great and I personally think it would have been mad to throw that away just because we have different preferences in the bedroom. I imagine this subject had many of its own threads!

I'm basically interested to see how many people have that "the one that got away" feeling and if/when it stopped for them.

I'm definitely going to leave it be with guy

OP posts:
AllTheOtherNamesWereTaken · 25/02/2021 16:59

@AuntieStella

It passes faster when you start making a conscious effort to,stop thinking above t him.

When you find you are, stop yourself. Note that you were thinking about him, then tell yourself it's wrong, and deliberately turn your thoughts to something else.

With a bit of practice, you will be able to end this useless thought pattern.

And yes, he's said the friendship is now over, so respect that and leave him alone. It doesn't matter whether he was 'fair' - you've moved on

That you that's great advice and I've started doing my best to do this, just need some more practice at it!
OP posts:
GinIsNotOriginal · 25/02/2021 20:50

I can relate because I have this kind of thing with man- only I’ve chosen never to have another relationship or DC until I meet somebody else whom I feel as passionately about. Settling would waste my life and their’s. But it’s too late for that now as you are married and pregnant- all
I can say is try to stop Yourself thinking of
Him. Try cbt style exercises? Keep a diary of when you think about him and see if there are any patterns/triggers. Also write a list of all his bad points! Even if there’s only 1, re-read it again and again. You can move on- if you don’t then you will live your life unhappy and your DC will be aware of mum’s ‘one that got away’.

GreatDashingBicycle · 26/02/2021 01:36

Am fairly sure many people have a "one that got away" if they're honest with themselves. However, you have to water you own grass and it's very true that the grass perhaps only seems greener with this other dude because you're not living the monotonous day to day life with him but a fantasy one in your head.

seensome · 26/02/2021 03:06

It passed when I got divorced from my husband and I was able to have sex with men i fancied. Being in a marriage that you don't have the passion in, makes you crave the man you did have that with.

SmeleanorSmellstrop · 26/02/2021 06:15

Can I ask why you wanted to be friends with him when married? Be honest with yourself - was it genuinely a platonic friendship you wanted with a man who you have so much chemistry with and who you can't stop fantasising about years later? Or did a part of you want to keep him around just incase things didn't work with your husband, or because you couldn't let him go as you still have feelings for them? If either of these, I'd think there's a chance that you COULD some day end up cheating on your husband with him. A friendship with him would have been totally inappropriate considering the chemistry and probably sexual tension between you two. Idk. That part stuck out to me.

I think you need to stay well away (which it sounds like you're going to so good for you) because you're sort of in dangerous territory already. We have all had a person we daydreamed about or a 'one who got away' as a PP said. But paired with your unsatisfying sexual relationship with your husband and your previous desire to maintain contact with him, there is a risk of moving into inappropriate behaviour/being really disrespectful to your husband, if not actual cheating.

I think your sexual issues with your husband might result in a lot of fantasising on your part over the years! So if you really love your husband and can overcome/ignore the sexual problems then I'd recommend you sort of find a way to overcome fantasising/control your thought patterns (like a PP suggested)/find a way to distract yourself, as I'd imagine that sexual issues will get worse and not better as time goes on and so this might be an ongoing issue for you.

I'm not saying you should leave your husband over this, just that it's worth being aware of as it's perfectly natural to dream about or crave a good physical relationship.

MMMarmite · 26/02/2021 06:34

Yeah it's normal to fantasise about whatever's missing in your current relationship... or at least, I do it too.

I'm wondering if you've considered an open relationship? Seems like you and dh are both very open about the fact you love each other but aren't very sexually compatible.

Not necessarily to have anything to do with the old flame, that might be too emotionally complex. But it seems a shame to both limit yourselves sexually for ever.

MMMarmite · 26/02/2021 06:44

My most recent relationship the sex was lovely, but I missed the emotional closeness and we-can-talk-for-hours aspects of my previous relationship, which we'd ended partly due to bad sex! Maybe I'm just bad at being content with my lot Sad

tigertubbie · 26/02/2021 06:58

You know in the Great Gatsby when Gatsby can see the green light from Daisys house so he just always looks at it thinking she's so near yet so far.

That's what having "the one that got away" on social media is like.

In reality he's probably flawed in many ways but you never learned about them and instead you just focus on the green light.

You say you love your dh, so try and focus on that instead. Pregnancy and becoming a mum can also plays with your hormones. If you need to fantasize about someone, try to find a hot celebrity or a random stranger you see on the street/supermarket where the line between fantasy and reality is a lot clearer.

Shoxfordian · 26/02/2021 07:15

Sex is the part of the relationship that makes it romantic and not platonic. I wouldn’t be able to make the huge compromise you’ve made in denying my sexual desires to stay with someone who might well be very nice but is essentially your friend.

Hardly a surprise you’re thinking of someone else. I don’t think suppressing your sexual desire will work in the long run, eventually you’ll either meet him or someone else and unless you’re having sex.with your husband, you may well have it with someone else

PurpleFlower1983 · 26/02/2021 07:34

Unfortunately I don’t think you have anywhere near the perfect relationship with your DH as you’ve clearly settled. The difference between great friends and the one we want to spend our life with is passion surely. Some people are happy without it, others are not and it seems you are not. You do need to distance yourself from ‘the one who got away’ but will you replace that fantasy with something/someone else?

Seadad · 26/02/2021 10:31

I'm not sure I really understand why you both can't improve your sex life? Are you saying you aren't attracted to each other? Is he gay? Are you just not attracted to him but he is to you. Or is this about particular kinks?
But agree with others that you can't plan your life around thus arrangement- your current obsession might be the first of many!

AllTheOtherNamesWereTaken · 26/02/2021 12:11

@Seadad

I'm not sure I really understand why you both can't improve your sex life? Are you saying you aren't attracted to each other? Is he gay? Are you just not attracted to him but he is to you. Or is this about particular kinks? But agree with others that you can't plan your life around thus arrangement- your current obsession might be the first of many!
Ah I think I was a bit strong with what I said about our sex life, yes it's the worst part but that's compared to everything else- not that it's terrible. We have regular enough sex, we fancy eachother and both enjoy it. It's more that we have kinks that the other one can only go along with to such an extent as neither of us can be convincing we're loving it when we do the other person's thing. So we'll never have the best mind blowing sex but we both feel that what we have is enough. It seems insane to me to break up a great relationship because one element isn't 100%- surely barely anybody would be married or with somebody long tems if everything had to be fully perfect.

I'm encouraged by what some of you have said about "the ones that's good away" not actually turning out to be the best relationship. I think a lot of my thoughts/feelings towards this guy are habit/fantasy because I missed him for so long before I met DH and there's no way of me knowing what an actual day to day relationship with him is like. All of our time together has been a whirlwind and one off days out of the blue. Back then I was never tempted enough to try to cheat and I was the single one whereas he wasn't, so the fact now I'm the married one gives me confidence I'd remain faithful to DH.

But I do agree with what some of you have said it's not ok on my DH to try and keep in contact with this guy. It's the click we have as a friendship I was wanting but it's complicated when other feelings are mixed in there. I think it's taken my posting this and seeing your reactions to realise it's a good thing he's stepped away

OP posts:
Seadad · 26/02/2021 18:13

Surely you can improve on the enthusiasm with which you can embrace what each if you enjoys? If it's in return for indulging the other then I don't think you should write it off- people can get into things with practice too.
And yes - the other guy - it always starts as you describe and it always crosses a line and another and it never ever ends well. There are pages of misery on this site devoted to the distress caused by a bit of excitement from the attention of another. Dont go there OP. Like hard drugs - you think you can handle it - you can't!

allz · 17/10/2021 18:37

not judging you at all. you have my deepest sympathies. I came to this site just now by searching info round the web about diff types of adultery. I haven't yet found the exact type I'm looking for. but through the links I clicked, I just landed on this one, never saw this site before, and since you say you specifically were looking out for someone who knows how you feel, and how that goes or whatever, well I relate to you a lot, in diff ways, and I hope my words will be received well. in no way do I mean to be harsh. I am telling you what most people will never consider. that being said, I am not great at knowing what to do about my feelings. I can mostly define it and I can commiserate with you about how much it sucks to miss someone from the past... someone with whom you had such a deep connection, it doesn't always feel like it's just in the past, even if you haven't communicated for years.

I hope I've adequately showed where my heart is coming from. now I'll tell you what I think of your situation.

it is obvious what some of the underlying issues are, here. continuing "friendship" with a man even after you are married to someone else, is a surefire way to invite strife into your marriage. it seems harmless almost, for guys and girls to be friends. but the truth is, there is always tension on one end or the other. one always likes the other or they wouldn't be hanging out. that's just how it is. it took me a long time to accept that no opposite-sex friendship was 100% platonic. so imagine how that can impact your marriage, you having guys that you talk to on the side. I imagine your husband also has girls he talks to, as just friends, right? no, it is not 100% platonic. take a hard look and be honest. I got so used to being friends with some guys for many many years, that I took for granted my knowledge that they had liked me for a long time. since they were okay with being friends, and "didn't hit on me," I thought these were healthy relationships where we could goof off and confide in each other like we always had. but now I acknowledge that yes they filled the gaps in my ACTUAL romantic relationships. when things went south with my boyfriend, I could call one of these guys to cry to him and act like I want advice. when I was merely bored, I could call one of these guys to keep me interesting company. when I wanted someone to share an experience with, someone to hang out with, one of those guys might be the person id call. but I was ignorant, it is true, and I took for granted that the only reason these guys wanted to hang alone with me was because they hoped it might eventually develop into something more. even when we both had a relationship, we would hang out, calling it friendship, but deep down these men were holding out the chance that if their current relationship didn't work out, I might still be around to try again to get with me. many of these facts were unconscious. I only for about 6 years have been working to face the truth square in the face.

now that I've explained my stance on opposite-sex friendships, can you think of how many friendships like that, that you have? what's the bare-bones truth? regardless of the comfort level of the friendship, did one of you like the other at any point in time? likely the answer is yes, and that is why the friendship has lasted, deeeeep down.

regardless, right now we are talking about someone you did have a romantic connection with. it's a mutual attraction, ill-fated, as long-distance was never going to work from the beginning. yet you gave your body to him, and vice-versa. I am nowadays of the belief that sex is a truly sacred act of bonding, which should be reserved for marriage alone. I had sex with many men before I got married, including my husband, we didn't wait, either. and after all my "experience" I've got to say it all was a waste. it inhibits the sexual connection between my husband and me, and so do his own past experiences. and I struggle regarding a very certain ex-boyfriend. thoughts of him are what sent me searching just now for diff types of adultery. I am tired of the feelings I still have for the man from over ten years ago. we conceived a baby. I was a brainwashed 18 year old still in high school, and I thought abortion was a good idea. so I did it. that was bad. I was already so tainted from experiences even before THAT guy, and then the abortion just really threw the biggest hammer down on it all. I could never be remotely the same after that. that guy and I lasted 2 years in the end. we made such plans together, hating the corruption in the world and wanting truth and wanting to do our part to fix things. we were a good team in that regard, young and naive, passionate and just simply trying at least. my husband is even better than he was, truly. but I am haunted by the first man. we haven't spoken since like 2009, and it wasn't a good convo. I know I must move on. I get afraid that these feelings wont go away. so what do I do? my husband is amazing. we have sex issues as well. not the same as yours but it doesnt matter- sexual struggles of diff people often have quite common denominators. they boil down to misuse of sex some time in the past, whether it was a choice they made, a choice someone else forced on them, or what-have-you.

as for you, you are still blinded like I was, thinking opposite-sex close connections are harmless at their core. it's a lie. that's a strike against your sex life, for sure. my sister is going through a divorce right now, and she had many platonic friendships, claiming they are nothing but that, and that if her husband found someone else, she'd say, "go, be happy!" and that she would genuinely be happy for him. I knew this was a lie. a few years later he made a "friend" of his own, someone who was my sister's friend first even, and he flew out to have an affair with her, she moved over here and got a job and apartment, and convinced my sister's husband to have a divorce and be with her instead. my hard-headed sister is devastated now. there are more contributing factors to their dissolve, but I always knew it was secretly wearing on her husband that she had so many guy friends who she even KNEW liked her.

so why do we do this? why do we insist on keeping the attention of other men when we have our spouse or significant other?

I think it hugely comes down to insecurity and lack of trust. but for good reason! this is where your innocence comes in. our souls are sacred. we have been harmed. we have also been misled by our elders as to how we shall navigate life. our virtues are tainted by default. we think we are doing a good thing, only to find destruction at the end. that's where you are. you gave too much of your sacred soul, the deep longing in your heart to belong to someone and KNOW it's true and that you're the only one they hold, and now you pay the price. same as me.

with these men, we gave a lot of ourselves. but we didn't give all. and now we are yet more divided, often having little to offer our husbands in bed, and vice versa. it totally goes both ways, too. his past and present opposite-sex relations are impacting the bedroom, having little to offer you back, either.

this is NOT a matter of "preferences" in bed. it's a spiritual problem

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread