Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Bf too dependent on friend?

75 replies

wontgetfooledagain123 · 07/10/2020 21:55

Use MN regularly but NC as details here could be outing. Apologies for length but didn't want to dripfeed.

I'm mid 30s and have a new bf (few months) who's the same age. We get on really well, the chemistry is great, and I really like him. I got divorced some years ago and now ready to settle down and have kids. He knows this, and we both agree this has potential and he has said that he'll be honest with me if he doesn't see a future as he doesn't want to waste my time. We're both happy with how it's progressing.

However, there is something that has me a bit concerned but I'm not sure if I'm just being paranoid. So could use some straight talking MN advice.

He has never had a gf before me. Which did surprise me as he's very attractive, good job, smart, funny, kind etc. When I asked him about it, he said it's because his job has unsociable hours (it does) and he's spent many years working and qualifying. He also lived with his mum till very recently but has now bought his own place and finally living alone. I assumed that living with his mum for many years may have put off some women as well. But he's been a good bf so far so his lack of relationship experience doesn't bother me.

However, I have now clocked that there might be another reason he has been single all these years. He has a very good female friend, who he met as the wife of an old friend. He and the husband were very good mates but he is now closer to her than him. Nothing strange there and I have many male friends so haven't thought anything about it till recently.

A couple of incidents made me wonder though: e.g she discusses things with him that she doesn't with her husband (e.g her worries about periods/not wanting to get pregnant etc). OR he send her selfies of himself when he thinks he's looking good at work OR he gets her to proof read his work emails before he sends them. Also he discusses with me a lot her worries about her husband's job fears. But when i went through something similar to her husband he wasn't that bothered.

I jokingly asked him if the reason he was always single was because she met his emotional needs and made a gf redundant. He admitted that other friends of theirs had said the same thing about their friendship. But there was nothing between them, she was just naturally maternal and cared about him. And he didn't have feelings for her.

The thing that really annoyed me is that he then told her what i had said about their emotional dependency, to get her advice on what to do!!!! He also admits he shares with her screenshots of messages I've sent and details of any little disagreements we have, to get advice.

I think I was willing to write off my own alarm bells as me being insecure, but the fact that her friends and his have said the same, makes me nervous. It feels a bit like there's a 3rd party in our relationship and the level of impact she has on him worries me. E.g we have unprotected sex now (am on pill) but he decided he wanted to use condoms because she had a pregnancy scare and seeing her anxiety over it made him want to avoid that problem. He didn't even ask my opinion on if it's what I wanted. Just sprung it on me during sex.

So, my question is, do you think I am right to be concerned about how close they are? Could it cause problems? Or am I just being paranoid and need a chill pill? Am just wary of time wasting/getting hurt. We haven't met yet but with covid etc we haven't gotten around to the meet friends/family stage anyway.

OP posts:
widespreadpanic · 07/10/2020 23:05

Nah, forget that nonsense. Even if the friend was a man I wouldn’t be down with this.

Dozer · 07/10/2020 23:08

Run for the hills!

CoffeeInAnIV · 07/10/2020 23:20

There's a crowd. Run, don't walk.

wontgetfooledagain123 · 07/10/2020 23:46

You're all telling me what I was afraid of :( Glad I wasn't just being insecure or paranoid though. Gutted as he is so nice in every other way but he's been that way with her for 10 years, doubt he will now magically establish boundaries with her for me.

I have often wondered how the husband feels. Surely it's weird that all your mutual friends think your old uni buddy and wife are too emotionally invested in each other. But I don't know the ins and outs of that relationship, and now it seems I never will.

@Blavatskyite - I never thought of it this way, but you may have a point.

OP posts:
namechangeforfriday · 07/10/2020 23:47

Hmm I dunno. I share screenshots of conversations with boyfriends (with male and female friends) so that wouldn’t bother me, I’ve always talked about relationship issues with friends as well and personal stuff. But I don’t tell the boyfriend I’m doing it or give him a running commentary! It’s the constant mentioning of her that’s weird and annoying. It doesn’t sound like he’s into her, if anything it sounds like the opposite - she’s into him, and he’s just got used to this dynamic. But I can see why him always talking about her is offputting and he needs to dial that back. But then if he stopped mentioning her would you always be worried about what they’re talking about? If it doesn’t sit right with you that’s enough of a reason to move on

wontgetfooledagain123 · 08/10/2020 00:03

@namechangeforfriday You're right, I have a worry that she might have some feelings for him too, or at least likes that he is always available for her, unhindered by a gf. It just all seems a bit odd.

And a pp did say that he would just get better at hiding it. And already I find him being very vague about what he's upto when we're not together. :(

OP posts:
SandyY2K · 08/10/2020 00:11

No chance. Don't waste your time with him.
Its obvious why he's been single at his age.

People in very demanding jobs working many hours still have relationships.

I'd only accept this if he was a placeholder BF and I wasn't interested in anything serious with him...because he wouldn't be around for long.

LilyWater · 08/10/2020 00:16

Get out now!! This will wreck any relationship/marriage...how on earth could it function if she's acting as a consultant in your marriage during any problems and more to the point he's facilitating it!! Whether or not one or both fancy each other is redundant.

LilyWater · 08/10/2020 00:18

@Dollyrocket

This would really put me off him and would unnerve me wondering what else she knew about me. Sharing your messages is such a breach of trust. Surely this woman’s husband must find the whole thing strange too.

I’d walk away now and be very clear why.

Also, him living at home with mummy till recently (at his age) would also be a major turn off for me. He seems to have surrounded himself with mummy’sConfused

Yes the message sharing and screenshots is quite scary and creepy. Like she's been elected Big Brother of the relationship!

I bet her poor husband has no idea Sad

BitOfFun · 08/10/2020 00:21

It's an issue now, and it will always be an issue. Don't waste any more of your time.

EarlyMorningRain · 08/10/2020 04:37

It feels a bit like there's a 3rd party in our relationship

There is, sadly, its you.

022828MAN · 08/10/2020 05:16

I would hate this.

shitinmyhandsandclap · 08/10/2020 06:50

He'd be there like a shot if she split with her husband

Blavatskyite · 08/10/2020 07:05

@shitinmyhandsandclap

He'd be there like a shot if she split with her husband
I doubt it. I think he’d run like a scared bunny if this woman stopped being his mummy and cheerleader, and the one he trots off to to analyse his girlfriend’s messages with, and herself said she wanted to be the one he had sex and commitments and a future with. He’d die in a panic! I mean, who would he go to for advice? Who would tell him what to do if he and she had a tiff? Who would proofread his work emails? Whose pregnancy scares would he discuss in reverent detail? Who would be his shoulder to cry on?

Which is not to say that he isn’t a walking disaster with mummy issues.

Blavatskyite · 08/10/2020 07:07

Oh, and I think he primarily has a girlfriend to give him something to talk about to his friend.

@EarlyMorningRain is right about the pecking order.

Thingsdogetbetter · 08/10/2020 07:22

We all share/rant/seek advice from friends, but while this is a bit OTT, it's not that weird. What we don't all do, is tell our partner we've done it and blindly adhere to said friend's advice. That's what's weird. He's been told by his other friends it's weird, but hasn't made any changes to his dependence on her. (Would be interesting to know if his dynamic with his mother was similar.)

He seems incapable of thinking for himself or making decisions based on anything other than her say so. He's been told it's potentially fucking up his ability to form other relationships, but 'chooses' to continue his dependence on her anyway. Is she even aware of how bizarre their dynamic is? What does this fulfill for her?

How far will he go with this? Who will decide if he takes his relationship with OP further, move in, propose, have kids? Will it be him and OP who decide? Or his friend? I foresee female friend having the last say on everything from kids to the colour of the cushions they buy.

Looks like he has some deep rooted feelings of inadequacy and abdicates all responsibility to her. Even if that changes because he finally realises how dysfunctional it is, it will be a long and painful road. Does OP want to be the one to have to drag him down it? Will he just swap his dependence to OP? Will he fall apart when he has to make his own choices?

LilyLongJohn · 08/10/2020 07:32

I think you'll always be playing catch up with them.

I have close friends but I don't continually rely on the for advice or share every little thing that's going on in my relationship. My primary relationship is with my dh. I know it's early days for you, but it sounds like his primary relationship is with his friend and that's unlikely to change as they have this odd emotional relationship

Middersweekly · 08/10/2020 10:01

It actually sounds like the friends wife and him are having an affair (emotional at the very least but possibly physical) and you’re the cover for it! Confused
10 years is a long time to be emotionally involved with someone when it isn’t leading anywhere. There are definitely feelings involved between the two of them. Also...living with his mum into his 30’s ?! So he’s had his mum in one corner and his friends wife in the other corner sorting his life out for him. This speaks volumes about his emotional maturity!
Head for the hills OP!

grapewine · 08/10/2020 10:05

He also admits he shares with her screenshots of messages I've sent and details of any little disagreements we have, to get advice.

This is not OK. For me this would definitely be the deal breaker.

TwentyViginti · 08/10/2020 10:13

Wonder if he shares details of your sex life and body for her to critique.

JaffaCake70 · 08/10/2020 13:21

You are the Princess Diana to their Charles and Camilla, look how that whole scenario played out. Get out now, take it from someone who has been in a very similar situation. I'll tell you a little bit about the relationship that I have just ended...

I met my ex two and a half years ago, the relationship was long distance, we lived a 90 min drive apart. He told me very early on that his 'best friend' was one of his ex girlfriends.

He had been in a relationship with this woman many years ago for around 8 years. They broke up when he dumped her for a previous GF who then promptly dumped him due to his heavy drinking). He only ever lived with 'best friend' GF for 6 months of their relationship. He lives in a converted garage attached to his DM & DF's bungalow, and has done for all of his adult life apart from that 6 months with BF ex.

BF ex then went off living in another country to lick her wounds. Fast forward a couple of years, my ex got very poorly, almost died, BF ex promptly returned from other country to help nurse him back to health.

They didn't resume their physical relationship, but I think this is when their emotional relationship started to form.

BF ex then got into another relationship, she has now been with this guy for around 14 years and they have children (she and my ex have no children together).

My ex has never had another long term relationship since BF ex, which amounts to around 22 years where he has had relationships similar to the one with me, where it'll last a year or two until the new GF gets tired of the inappropriately close 'friendship' with the BF ex and dumps him.

Examples of how weird my ex's 'friendship' with this ex was:

  1. On our first ever date (in my city) she rang him while we were out at a bar together, he proceeded to chat to her, laughing and joking, for around 15 min's, while I sat and twiddled my thumbs. This was her first instance of 'I'm here with you both, just so you know'. I wish I'd have picked up on this first red flag and ran! After this he would often take calls from her on 'our time', which was very frustrating seeing as I only ever saw him fortnightly for the weekend. She would think nothing of ringing him late at night or early in the morning, he would always take the call. One Sunday morning she rang and I heard her say "has 'my name' gone home yet?", obviously wanting the latest gossip on whatever my latest issue was, as I had a lot going on in my life at the time. When he said that I hadn't left yet, she made an excuse and hung up the call. I know he told her things that I didn't want anyone to know because he slipped up a couple of times, this resulted in me not telling him anything about my private life for fear of him gossiping about it to her. Not being able to tell your partner about things that are going on in your life because you can't trust them to keep that information to themselves, is no foundation for a relationship.
  1. On my first ever visit to his town, he took me to meet BF ex.... in retrospect this was extremely disrespectful of him. Imagine, taking your new GF to meet your ex GF on her first ever visit to your city!! Why didn't I run? What was I thinking?? He was definitely showcasing me for her seal of approval. Sick and creepy on both of their parts.
  1. My ex and I went on a skiing trip with a group of his friends (she wasn't one of them). I'd never been skiing before, I hated it, was terrified. On the second day I took my skis off on the slopes and proceeded to walk down the mountain (sounds childish I know, but I was genuinely terrified of breaking my neck!). He left me on the mountain side stating 'unwritten rule, you take your skis off, you're on your own'. When I got back to our hotel room (after an hour of trudging down snowy mountains) I noticed he'd left his mobile in the room. After a while it pinged with a text from BF ex saying 'I'm sure she'll be fine if she tries again tomorrow' or words to that effect. He had obviously gone straight back to the hotel room and texted her about my lack of prowess on the slopes.
  1. One day I noticed a package on his table with a load of tins of this grease stuff he uses for his hair, it had the BF ex's address on the package. I asked him why it had been delivered to her address (which is literally a two minute walk from where he lives) he said, 'oh she orders it for me because I don't have Paypal). Mothering or what? I mean, set up your own Paypal, it takes two minutes! She would also draft letters to companies for him and other such admin type jobs.
  1. The final nail in the coffin came a couple of months ago when I was at his flat. I'd not seen him for a few weeks and we were having a lie in, just chatting, not doing anything sexual (that had died a death anyway). At around 9.30am she rang him and asked him to go and view something with her (property connected). He complained a little bit, said he was still in bed, but didn't make issue with the fact that I was there (which she already knew anyway). She then proceeded to basically beg him to go, stating 'I don't know what I'm looking at, you're a builder, I need you to look at it, oh come on, you promised me' etc etc. He got up and went. Granted, he wasn't gone for long, but when he got back he told me that she had pulled into the pub car park on the way back and said 'come on, let's go for a beer'. It was 11.15 in the morning. He didn't go for the beer but for me it proved that she was trying to sabotage our relationship.

At this point I was past caring. That same day I gathered all of my decent stuff together and packed it. Unbeknown to him, I had no intentions of every putting myself through that crap ever again.

On a phone call a few days later I asked him what he was up to, he said he'd been out for a drink with the BF ex, it was the final straw. I put the phone down. I did speak to him a few days later as he was calling relentlessly. He had nothing to say about the situation apart from 'I could kill you, she's just a friend'. I told him that I had no problem with them being friends, but that the friendship seemed co dependent and inappropriate.

Looking at the situation now with hindsight, all of the red flags are there with my ex. The fact that he still basically lives with his parents at the age of 49. The fact that his Mother does all of his laundry and cooks his dinner every night (she's in her 70's and he let's her wait on him hand and foot). The fact that since he's been furloughed, he's been living off his Mother and Father because his previous job was cash in hand. Zero responsibility for himself. This guy was a man-child, he had never grown up. Yours sounds exactly the same.

Don't get me wrong. I wasn't in the slightest bit jealous or threatened by this ex, but the fact that my ex was involving her in our lives to such a large degree (discussing some very private issues of mine with her) was not acceptable to me. The fact that towards the end of our relationship I felt that he was prioritising her over me sounded the death knell.

Do yourself a favour, get out of this situation before it even starts, it will not go well I promise you that. It is an emotional affair that they are having, she is Mothering him and he loves it (just like my ex did). There is probably nothing sexual going on, but an affair such as this is just as disrespectful and hurtful.

Your guy, and my ex, don't actually want an adult relationship with a woman, it is too much responsibility for them. Look how he has had to ask her for advice about your quarrels (just like my ex did on the skiing trip). These 'men' can't handle adult situations, therefore they use these women as a 'crutch'.

Can I ask, has your guy shown any immature tendencies in other areas. My ex liked to drone on about fisticuffs that he'd had in his youth. Also, he was very immature when it came to the opposite sex. He would make the sort of comments that a teenage boy would make, 'oooh, tits on the telly!' and suchlike. He told me a story of how some woman had invited him to squeeze her breast after she'd had a boob job about six times during our relationship. I've a feeling he'll dine out on that story for the rest of his life LOL.

Ultimately, these men are not a good prospect for a secure future. Please please heed my warning. I have no doubt at all in my mind that if you choose to pursue this relationship you will end up just as frustrated and irritated as I was after two and half years. Don't waste the time like I did. Get out now with your pride and self respect intact.

I know my reply is long. This is for two reasons.

  1. It has been cathartic to write about something that is still quite raw for me. I really hope sharing my situation helps you to walk away from this crappy situation.
  1. If by any chance my ex's BF ex is on MN and happens to see this post and recognizes herself in my reply, I want her to know that I'm grateful to her for showing me that I was not a priority in my ex's life. I thank her for bringing this to my attention sooner rather than later as I could've wasted many years on this man who, ultimately, will never grow up and take responsibility for himself, never mind for a partner or children. I'm truly indebted to her for services to The Sisterhood!!

OP you may not even read my entire post, but if you do and you've got this far, I wish you nothing but love in your life. Dump this guy and go and find someone who deserves you xxx

P.S. I have a date tomorrow night LOL xxx

JaffaCake70 · 08/10/2020 13:40

@Blavatskyite

I would peg him as having been single forever because he finds it easier to delegate ownership of his emotional life to a woman who ‘mothers’ him and requires no commitment in return. It’s a bit like the kind of person who stays living at home well into their thirties, despite being in relationships, because someone cooks their dinner and they can watch tv in peace. Both fundamentally juvenile. He takes your tiffs to her like a five year old bringing home craftwork from school, or getting a grownup to tie his shoelaces.

I would find this about as attractive as a cup of cold sick. Quite apart from not particularly wanting my private communications with my boyfriend being shown to and analysed by someone else.

This comment is everything! This is my ex in a nutshell. I wish I'd spoken to @Blavatskyite two and a half years ago, it could have saved me wasting my time on an immature, 49 yr old, man-child!!
Blavatskyite · 08/10/2020 13:49

@JaffaCake70, I wasn't either of the people in the type of scenario you mention, but it all feels very familiar. I swear I know that man you describe him very well! but with the variant that the one I knew moved through various intense 'female best friend' relationships which lasted several years, not just one.

I liked him very much when I first met him (he's clever and funny and good company) but with hindsight, and now knowing far more about him and his marriage, I think he was (consciously or unconsciously) grooming me to be the next 'female best friend', as the previous one had moved to another country and clearly couldn't provide the intense levels of support and 'checking in' he was used to any longer, plus he didn't seem to have the imagination/energy to stay in touch with friends who weren't right on the spot, or to have more than one friendship at a time.

(His emotional clock seemed to have got stuck during his undergraduate years, and he'd never quite moved on in his head from long, late-night talks in pubs over fifteen pints and confiding everything and then getting up with a hangover for a tutorial, despite being in his fifties and married with two kids and a professional job. After a while, I realised that all the people he talked about as friends were his undergraduate friends and his undergraduate girlfriend, even though he hadn't seen them in decades and made no effort to keep in touch, and that he had made no friends at all since his student days.)

I made it very plain that I didn't want to be the third wheel in his marriage, then moved on from the job through which I knew him, and moved to another country. He's now divorced and he may be in the market for both a new relationship and a new female best friend.

Consider yourselves warned!

Blavatskyite · 08/10/2020 13:51

X-posted with you @JaffaCake70 -- it sounds like we encountered the same type. Sorry you had to deal with it. I can only imagine how awful he must have been to be in a relationship with.

Thelnebriati · 08/10/2020 13:58

I've been there, I found out when he asked the other person to talk to me about something that was bothering him. They ended up together for a while.
Run like the wind!

Swipe left for the next trending thread