Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Being the family scapegoat and caring for an ill parent

35 replies

24hoursofsun · 05/01/2020 19:40

My head is an absolute mess right now and I really need a bit of help to understand what to do. I have 2 brothers. We are all 3 now jointly caring for our very ill DF. At every turn, no matter what I do, they criticise and complain about me and it’s really taking a toll.

Growing up, I was always the ‘other’ child. My brothers were gorgeous, precocious and doted oh. For example, they would get new clothes because ‘at least they look cute’. Or I would often be excluded from fun activities for being ‘too old’. As an example, my whole family went to watch Disney on Ice when I was 11, but I wasn’t bought a ticket as I was ‘too old’. As the eldest, I had to take a lot of responsibility to keep them entertained, stop them fighting, help with homework, prep their clothes, plan their parties etc. I was punished constantly, much more than them. Once, when my aunt challenged my DM on this, DM said in front of me ‘they are so adorable I can’t bring myself to punish them, but I can certainly punish her’. In fairness, they were both extraordinarily cute kids and I was extremely awkward.

Over time this led to a dynamic where I was very bossy with them. From my point of view, any toe out of line led to punishments for me, so I worked hard to make everything right. From their POV I was an insufferable know it all.

Due to the immense amount of criticism and pressure heaped on me, I worked incredibly hard to ‘achieve’ in ways my parents valued. I got myself an outwardly perfect little family, a ‘high flying career’ which I loathe, a house etc. Every ‘achievement’ placated my parents for a while but increased my brothers’ resentment.

Now we are caring for DF and I’m damned if I do and damned if I don’t. If I do anything, I’m ‘controlling’ and bossy and they both get together and yell at me. If I don’t, either it just won’t get done or I’m not picking up enough slack.

As an example, DF needed an emergency dental appointment on a Friday. DB1 volunteered to book it. I explained the process and stepped away. Come 12 pm, no calls have been made. I panicked about the weekend coming up, called a bunch of local dentists and got an appointment that afternoon. DB1 abd DB2 proceeded to pile in about my ‘controlling’ ways.

Another example, my fathers medical team had asked us to be watchful for a specific symptom of deterioration. I Picked up DF from DB2’s house and I noticed the symptom. Asked DB2, who insisted it wasn’t there. Finally, I took a decision and called his doctors. Tests found that DF was deteriorating much faster than expected and needed medical intervention. DB1 and DB2 insist that the symptoms were unrelated, the deterioration was just a lucky catch and I was ‘controlling’ in ‘overruling’ DB2 and contacting the medical team.

We are now looking into medically assisted living facilities for DF. DB1 insisted he would ‘take the lead’ on Boxing Day. As yet, not a single viewing has been arranged. I’ve tried asking casually and was told to buzz off. I’ve tried setting aside time for a scheduled catch up about our options. Finally, today I searched some homes myself and showed a shortlist to DBs. I messaged them individually beforehand to ask if it was alright for me to search, as I had the day free. I’ve now had both of them yelling at me about being ‘interfering, controlling, dismissive’.

I just don’t know what to do. DF dotes on them both and won’t back me up. If I do anything they both pile on. DB1 is prone to massive yelling tantrums and DB2 interrogates Me aggressively. On most issues I back down, but I would hate myself if I knowingly allowed my DF to suffer or achieve a poorer outcome.

OP posts:
Triglesoffy · 06/01/2020 09:06

I’m going to tread carefully here, OP, and I am sorry if I sound insensitive, but do your DB’s actually care about your DF? Their casual approach to his healthcare is concerning.

24hoursofsun · 06/01/2020 19:47

@TileFloors

just as some figure to be both leaned on and made fun of.

You’ve captured my role in the family so succinctly.

I have had some therapy, which helped me see how some of the treatment I received as a child partially contributed to me getting into an extremely physically abusive relationship when I was very young, with an ex who needed to be ‘taken care’ of. I thought I’d addressed my feelings but I guess I haven’t fully understood the implications as I try to keep things light and surface level with my family usually

OP posts:
24hoursofsun · 06/01/2020 19:51

@Dacquoise you’ve understood the dynamic so well.

I did feel like a parent. From age 12 onwards I was responsible for filling in all school, passport and medical forms for my family. I was included and played referree in every fight my parents had, even about infidelity. At 11 my mum walked out for a day and left me to care for my brothers. On family holidays, I had to sit in front, navigate and find hotels whilst my DM and DBs slept and giggled and ate in the back. I guess I just didn’t connect all these things before but your idea that I was a stand in parent really clarified things.

OP posts:
24hoursofsun · 06/01/2020 19:53

My family always made out that I was so boring and stiff and anal that I just naturally adopted these roles

OP posts:
theoriginalmadambee · 06/01/2020 20:27

I'm sorry OP, you need councelling, I recognize the obligation you feel, but you and your brothers are so set in your family dynamics, this is costing you too much.

Tell your brothers it is up to them to sort things. It is not going to be your way, I know, but don't let this dynamic be self-fulfilling. When they find out you are not stepping in, they will start doing things. Not your way, not your speed. They can blame you, but not for being controlling, you need to let go of the control.

Where I'm from we have a term for people like this, don't know if you have it. 'The Practical Pig', sad to say it's me too. When my family needed help, they liked it, but would otherwise make little digs about being a busy body.

Hope things work out for you 💐.

Dacquoise · 06/01/2020 20:36

Good grief, their treatment of you was and is so wrong. I am wondering whether your mother really wanted the role of parent. Giggling in the back seat with the boys sounds like she wanted to be one of the kids! Perhaps she saw the role as boring, stiff and anal and has projected that onto you. It's weird isn't it at how they can exploit you as a mini adult at the same time as berate and humiliate you for the same thing?

However, what I have found as a fellow scapegoat (now AWOL) is that I am the lucky one in a perverse way. I have been able to break away and make a happy life for myself. I have continued to grow and evolve as a person. The rest of my family are trapped in their sad immature lives, crippled by fear, making the same sad mistakes over and over again.

I think scapegoats are chosen for their strength and talents not their flaws. They take the family 'crap' because they are strong enough. I really hope that you are able to get away and heal when you are ready. You really, really deserve better.

Dacquoise · 06/01/2020 20:40

And just to add I had exactly the same experiences as you, mini adult to my more favoured siblings, audience for my mother's many adulteries, counsellor for her problems, housekeeper, cook and childcare at the age of 12.

24hoursofsun · 07/01/2020 18:33

@Dacquoise just came back to say I’m sorry you went through all of that. thank you for sharing your experiences, it’s such a solace sometimes to know that you’re not the only one who survived a dynamic like this. Hope you’re healed and congratulations on making a better life for yourself.

OP posts:
75Renarde · 07/01/2020 19:07

OP I have also been through something similiar. Here is my reading if the situation.

Your mum is a narc. Your father probably isnt. Probably scoring high on empathic traits though.THATS why he cannot bring himself to tell your golden brothers to shut up.

You had an abusive childhood and you are still being abused. OP, gently, step outside of this awful narrative. They wont change. Your brothers are feeding on your father. It's time to step back.

Remember, your father supported your mother when she was abusing you. That doesn't make him a bad man but it does make him a weak one.

I'm so sorry.

Dacquoise · 07/01/2020 19:53

Thank you @24hoursofsun, I think it's very important to share and to validate others experiences. It can be done. Good luck whatever you decide to do. X

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread