Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

I love my husband but I love my ex more

40 replies

Weasleykit1 · 24/07/2019 03:28

Myself and my ex have grown up together since the age of 2 (now both 32). We had a romantic relationship from the ages of 16-18 and broke up, he was my 1st love and I was his and he broke my heart but we lost contact for around 7 years, we both moved on with other people.
I got married and have three wonderful children (ages 12, 9 and 6) 2 of these children with my husband but things started to fall apart with my husband after a few years. He would pick faults with me all the time and pull me down and make me feel crap about myself. We didn't have a consistent sex life.
We have now been together for 11 years next month and married for 8 years next month and have, over the years, had a lot of ups and downs and even split up properly a few times.
The first time we split up was in 2012, not even a year into our marriage and during that time I bumped into my ex and we began a casual sort of relationship. Myself and my husband decided to work through things and I ended things with the ex. He moved on and stayed with this other woman for 5 years until she cheated on him. Myself and my husband split up again around 6 months before my ex becane single again and so myself and the ex found ourselves once again drawn back together into a casual thing, only this time I didn't have spare money to move out of the family home. My husband also had a casual relationship going on with one of his exes so we literally lived separate lives and only really lived in the same house (didn't sleep in the same room or bed at all and just remained civil for the children's sakes). My ex and I became more serious again and although there were elements of old times it was also fresh and new and we found ourselves falling for each other all over again and decided to make a proper go of things, he accepted and met my children and they all got along really well but out of the blue one day he changed his facebook status to "In A Relationship".
Now this may not seem strange but he wasn't a huge facebook user and we hadn't mentioned taking that step so I asked him about it and he exploded at me telling me I had led him on and that I had ignored him for weeks (we had been together only days before with my children at the park!) and that he couldn't be a side project for me. Two days later I hear he has completely moved out of the city and gone back to an ex he was with when we first broke up as teenagers, I was heartbroken and through it all my husband was an amazing friend and we became closer once again. He ended things with the woman he had been casually dating and we sat down and got everything out and dealt with things one by one and agreed to always communicate openly and honestly from then on and we were great for another year.
A year later my husband starts acting strange and I had people telling me they had seen him with another woman in his car, he would make excuses about working late and he didn't want to kiss me let alone even sleep with me and I got really down because he wouldn't talk to me so I told him I couldn't take it anymore and he seemed relieved. Once again we were back to being strangers who lived in the same house. And yep, you guessed it, the ex seemed to have a beacon and he made a reappearance. He had split with his other ex and moved back to the city. We met up as friends to catch up but the crazy chemistry we shared was there and we inevitably ended up back in a romantic and sexual relationship, this time we wanted to make a proper go of things and he explained he was scared of his depth of feelings for me a year before and he was afraid I'd reject him and go back to my husband so he did something stupid and regretted it but didn't think I would take him back if he had just explained. But we started spending more time together again and I would stay with him from Saturday afternoon until Sunday afternoon on alternate weekends and we would see each other a couple of times a week.
Things soon started to become a bit much for him again and he started inviting his friends round whenever I was staying over so we hardly got any time together whereas my husband had completely changed again. I decided I wanted to be single because I couldn't keep flitting between them both. 6 weeks later I found out I was pregnant with my 4th, it is my exes baby. I told my ex and I told my husband. My ex wants to be involved and wants us to be a proper family, my other children included and my husband wants to stand by me and be there for me and be a stepdad for my exes baby whilst not getting in the way of my ex being a father.
Now this is up to date and I have 9 and a half weeks left until baby is due. I still haven't decided if I want to be with either of them, although I see the ex regularly to shop for baby items and grab lunch afterwards, it is purely platonic at the moment and I live in the same house as my husband as being on maternity leave I can't afford to rent privately at the moment but again it is purely platonic.
Both are now arguing about who I should be with, who will be at the birth and which surname baby should have.
I love them both but in different ways and for different reasons but I know no matter what myself and my ex will just continue to be drawn back together and I do love him more than I love my husband.
So I'm stuck at the moment and don't know what to do other than just concentrate on my children and baby.
Does anybody have any advice, etc.at all please?

OP posts:
hellodarkness · 24/07/2019 03:55

They both sound awful. They have both had numerous opportunities to step up and be in a conventional, loving, healthy relationship with you but failed to do so for any length of time.

If I have understood correctly, you have separated from your dh several times and he has had affairs, at times being really quite cruel and distant.

Meanwhile, your on-off ex shows up from time to time - primarily when other relationships have failed - and claims on at least one occasion that he behaved badly because 'he was scared of his depth of feelings' which is obviously nonsense, and inviting friends round when he was meant to be with you.

In short, they both want you but not enough to behave how they should for any length of time. I suspect that at least part of the attraction for each of them at this point is the competition, and wanting to win.

Ergo my advice would be to be by yourself for a time, completely single. Keep them both at arms length and see which, if either of them, step up into the role of father.

Though something tells me that you won't do this. You haven't made a decision in all these years and are unlikely to do so now. If you can't be single, make your choice and go nc with the other to give the chosen relationship any time at all. Given that you love him more, and he is the biological father of your current pregnancy, this should be your ex imo.

Myfoolishboatisleaning · 24/07/2019 04:50

There’s a whole world of people out there. Why do you all keep getting back with exes? Do you always want your life to be so small? You all sound bad, I would not touch either of them.

RubberTreePlant · 24/07/2019 04:55

Be single.

BringMeAGinandTonic · 24/07/2019 05:44

I'd ensure that your ex is able to step up to the commitment of being a father, being a family and most of all, being present. He won't be able to take off to go be with another ex (or someone else) for a year or however long. To be a family, he needs to be present. So he needs to understand the father role and take it seriously.

I also think exploring yourself/your thoughts and having your own experiences for awhile might be ideal. You might find a world outside these two men that you never knew existed. It sounds like you have not experienced much else outside this world of these two men revolving in and out of your life. What if something else awaits you? Someone else? Or what if you just need to think a bit to truly see what you want so you can then settle with one of these men? I think if I were you I'd take a bit of time to just pause and focus on you for a bit. Come up to the surface for a bit of fresh air. :)

And I was reminded of Bridget Jones's Baby reading your post OP. I think it has to do with the whole competition thing going on among these two men while you're pregnant. :)

Whatever you decide though, I wish you and your baby the best. :)

OnlineAlienator · 25/07/2019 08:49

Sounds like you have a decent arrangement going on, with two men fighting over who gets to provide for you and the baby! And when one tires of you, the other is ready to step in and be attentive.

I'd get my own place and keep it going - with such excellent levels of childcare, this is a win Grin

Abstractedobstructed · 25/07/2019 08:54

I couldn't be bothered with all the drama, myself.

Neither of these men is properly committed to you.

You and your ex are not star crossed lovers. Bollocks was he "scared of the depth of his feelings for you". He found someone else he wanted to shag. You are a reliable pair of jeans he pops back on when he has nothing better.

It's all a bit...teenaged, isn't it?

sheshootssheimplores · 25/07/2019 09:13

Bloody hell 😦

user1493413286 · 25/07/2019 09:22

I think you need to be single for a good year to focus on your new baby and kids and work out what you want. I think you’re caught between what two men want and it’s not giving you the headspace to work out what you want. You’re at a time of high emotions and will be vulnerable post birth so I’d step back from making decisions about them both.
I don’t know how but you need to move out of the house you share with your husband or he needs to move out.
I also don’t think either man is treating you very well; you’re the person they keep coming back to and you deserve more than that.

Zoeputthatdown · 25/07/2019 09:27

What a merry-go-round, hope things work out for you all.

OldAndWornOut · 25/07/2019 09:30

This doesn't sound great for your children, bouncing from man to man.

Mythreefavouritethings · 25/07/2019 09:30

Seriously, be on your own for a bit. You are about to bring a child in the world, this sort of drama-filled love triangle is not healthy. Take some time away from this, start to think about things and reflect rather than switching to one or the other of these men. They are not solutions when something goes wrong for you. Develop some healthier coping mechanisms and focus on making a plan.

AE18 · 25/07/2019 09:37

My gosh I've never heard of people swimming in the same waters so much? Why do none of you date someone new? To be in a state where the two of them are pragmatically arguing over who you should be with is ridiculous and sounds like a Rom com - if they loved you they should be more bothered by the concept of the other person rather than calmly debating the matter, and if you really loved either of them, you would know who you want to be with. You don't seem like you particularly want to be with either of them since they're both offering and you haven't taken either of them up on it, so obviously you should just be single.

DEFINITELY don't stay with your husband, because you've made it clear you love someone more than him so it would be very cruel. But it seems to me like you're not all that bothered about the ex either, or you'd be with him now. I think you just need to put the past in the past and wait to meet someone you actually love enough to know you want to be with them. When you love someone properly, it's not such a complex decision.

Branleuse · 25/07/2019 09:42

neither of these men are right for you. You could literally choose any bloke off the street and theyd probably be less shit than these two jokers.

QueenoftheBiscuitTin · 25/07/2019 09:43

I wouldn't choose to be with either of them. Stay single and give your kids some stability.

SomeAfternoonDelight · 25/07/2019 09:45

Be single OR Find a third man fuck them two off and stay with him. I don’t know how you’ve coped 😂 I did this when I was 19 and it was hard enough then never mind with kids etc involved

Doyoumind · 25/07/2019 09:45

This sounds exhausting. You exist as your own person, you know. Who are you independent of these men? I don't think you know.

This whole set up is wrong. You need time away from both these men but your situation makes that difficult.

It doesn't sound like your ex will commit and be what you want. Your DH must be crazy to consider bringing up his child. Given the number of separations previously I can't see it lasting.

Can you accept that perhaps you need neither of these men in your life?

SlightlyMisplacedSingleDad · 25/07/2019 09:46

The best advice I can offer is that you'll probably need to go to America. Because Jeremy Kyle has been cancelled over here...

SlightlyMisplacedSingleDad · 25/07/2019 09:48

Or, more constructively.....just this once, maybe put your kids first, and try to get a bit of stability in their lives rather than forcing them to live through the latest instalment of your sexual merry go round.

Be single. Focus on your kids.

Goodnightchristopherrobin · 25/07/2019 09:49

Both men sound toxic, I’d steer clear and have some time alone to work on yourself. You deserve more Flowers

picklemepopcorn · 25/07/2019 10:13

Both men had the chance to be in a committed relationship with you. Neither of them stepped up.

Go it alone. Do the freedom programme and stay single until your kids are older much older

username1724 · 25/07/2019 10:19

Just stay single, be you for a while, the most important thing right now is this baby. It sounds like the 2 men in its life are not all the reliable so this is on you to grow the bond with baby with no distractions as you will inevitably be its consistent. Dont rush, dont jump into things, do what is best for your children for now, and that is adjusting to a fourth child/sibling.

Enclume · 25/07/2019 11:04

Punctuation and paragraphing would garner you more replies.

I tend to think that you don't really love either of them.

Yeahnahmum · 25/07/2019 11:12

You have kids op
Act like it

What the hell are you all doing?

kennyjenny · 25/07/2019 11:25

Please be single and focus on you and your children.
My mum was like this when I was young and I hated it. She ended up staying with her husband (my dad) but always complained after did she do the right thing.

CmdrCressidaDuck · 25/07/2019 11:36

Well personally I think you should all grow the fuck up, but if you haven't done that after three kids and God knows how many breakups and affairs, fuck knows a fourth baby won't make the difference.

You don't love your husband and your ex is a loser. He never stepped up before and he won't now. Time to hit self-destruct on both of these relationships and figure life out on your own.