Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Do I contact my ex? She was the love of my life but I felt like I had no choice but to leave.

40 replies

Jim311 · 14/02/2019 15:31

Whenever I was with my partner it was amazing, just two people madly in love, but whenever I wasn’t around she was different (I felt like she would push me away), distant and she just never seemed to want to spend time with me (we’d see each other once – twice a week and she often wouldn’t spend the night). She also seemed very hesitant to do anything that wasn’t just the two of us, shying away from nights out with my friends and family. She told me she liked her ‘recharge time’ and that I should respect that, but she never seemed to respect the fact that I’d like to spend a couple of nights a week together. We fought all the time when we were apart but when in person we never argued, not once, we could barely let go of each other’s hand, even food shopping she would hold onto my arm and every date felt like the start of a relationship, she was such a shy person but around me she couldn’t control herself and she’d say as much, even on our last date before I left her we couldn’t get on an escalator without stopping to kiss. We talked about children, where we’d live, we went on holiday together, (for my last birthday she paid for us both to go to Italy) but every time we’d get back she wouldn’t want to see me for a week saying she'd want to 'get back into her routine'. She said she loved spending time with me but it exhausted her mentally and that I was like a drug. She was so happy when she was in my presence, that no one made her feel the way I did but when she wasn’t around me she was miserable. I couldn’t understand why she wouldn’t just spend more time with me, she said I was her best friend and I believe that as she doesn’t have many. We are very different, I’m out going, open, honest and I make friends incredibly easily, I love my sports and to be out and active. She’s more reserved with a very small group of friends, she’d much rather spend her weekend in bed watching Netflix but she adored my energy and spontaneity, I’d meet her up after work, pick her up and spin her round like a movie, she’d get so embarrassed but she loved the way I a made her feel. We talked about moving in together but she’d flip from looking at places for us to making silly excuses constantly. The whole thing destroyed my self-esteem and sense of worth and after 3-4 months of this I ended it saying I loved her but she made me feel worthless and all I wanted was for us to spend more time together and I couldn't be in a relationship that made me miserable. She was devastated and said I was the love of her life. I told her that was it for me, I couldn’t be friends with someone I felt so strongly about and that for the sake of both of us I wouldn’t contact her again, she was crying so much but I couldn’t understand, I was breaking up with her for reasons entirely within her control and not mine, she could have fixed this! It’s been a month and I’ve been true to my word, I’ve done no contact, removed all reminders of her from my life, started playing tennis and piano lessons to distract myself and keep busy, making me a better version of myself but I miss her terribly, she was my best friend as well as my partner and I’d planned to propose to her, we’d even talked about the ring she’d wanted. The question is do I contact her or do I leave it for her to contact me. She knows how I feel about her but a part of me wonders if she’d want to try again, but then I remind myself that when I last saw her I told her the reasons I was leaving and she never offered a solution, I can’t fix the problems as I can’t make her want to see me or move forward in this relationship.

OP posts:
NotTheFordType · 14/02/2019 15:37

No, don't contact her. Especially not on International Racketeering Day.

How long were you together?

Jim311 · 14/02/2019 15:40

2 years

OP posts:
hellsbellsmelons · 14/02/2019 16:07

The whole thing destroyed my self-esteem and sense of worth
Why would you want to put yourself through this again???
Please raise your bar and don't go backwards.
Look forward.

Petalflowers · 14/02/2019 16:14

Don’t contact her. The relationship hasn’t worked, and you should accept that.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 14/02/2019 16:17

The question is do I contact her or do I leave it for her to contact me.

I don't think either of you should contact each other. Sorry, but you said yourself the relationship made you feel worthless, so why would you want to?

And she sounds cold and distant and disengaged. I think you did the right thing by ending it. There is a reason for going NC.

Yes, it's hard but it helps in the long-run.

NameChangeNugget · 14/02/2019 16:22

Just don’t. Not worth it

HappyLife21 · 14/02/2019 16:23

Nope. No good will come of it in the long term. Like you say, she could have continued the relationship by saying she wanted to spend more time with you, but she clearly does not want to spend more time with you.

Respect that and move on.

ravenmum · 14/02/2019 16:29

I was breaking up with her for reasons entirely within her control and not mine, she could have fixed this!
By changing her personality, you mean? You're clearly very different people, maybe that's why she was unsure about the relationship.

Gina2012 · 14/02/2019 16:31

The question is do I contact her

No

The question is why the fuck would you put yourself through something which made you unhappy a lot of the time? Why?

Jim311 · 14/02/2019 16:40

What makes it hard is I have no bad memories of her in person, we never ever argued when we were together. Our last date before I went to break up with her was incredibly romantic. She even acknowledged that she'd push me away and she couldn't explain why she did it, she was so devastated when I ended it and I want to see if this time apart might have given her some space to think about everything.

OP posts:
Gina2012 · 14/02/2019 16:41

and I want to see if this time apart might have given her some space to think about everything.

And be who you'd like her to be?

pumpastrotter · 14/02/2019 16:44

If you felt worthless why would you want to be with her

and I was breaking up with her for reasons entirely within her control and not mine, she could have fixed this! is game playing, you can't be angry she's not following your narrative how you want. You were going to propose to her but broke up with her instead? They're very different paths...

Honestly, the gushing about how great of a bf you were, and coming from someone who is also quite introverted and needs their own space, you sound very suffocating. I love my DH, we're very affectionate when together, but I would go mad if we spent every spare moment together and I'm incredibly grateful for the few nights a week we do our own thing, your ex is probably thankful for the breathing space which is why she's not chasing you the way you want.

Jim311 · 14/02/2019 16:54

"someone who is also quite introverted and needs their own space, you sound very suffocating"

I get that, the problem is she'd make plans then cancel them, sometimes on the day saying she needed her recharge time which is fine, the problem is it doesn't feel very considerate when I might have booked something.

She never actually told me these things, it was almost like she expected me to be a mind reader!

OP posts:
Jim311 · 14/02/2019 16:57

I think the hard thing is coming to terms with the fact that we love each other but just not compatible, I don't think it's unreasonable to want to spend 1-2 nights a week with your partner and she'd agree, but it was always words and never actions :(

OP posts:
MumsyJ · 14/02/2019 16:58

Nope, walk on by OP!

pumpastrotter · 14/02/2019 17:00

I get that, the problem is she'd make plans then cancel them, sometimes on the day saying she needed her recharge time which is fine, the problem is it doesn't feel very considerate when I might have booked something.

Sounds like social anxiety. It's hard to get over someone you love but it really sounds like it's for the best, OP

AgentJohnson · 14/02/2019 17:02

No, do not contact her! You ended it because you were incompatible on a fundamental level.

Breaking up was an understandable selfish decision, contacting her ‘to see if she had changed’, would be just plain selfish.

She wasn’t a charity case and wasn’t broken, she just didn’t have enough of the personality traits you were looking for in a partner.

Read back your post and try to step out of the blind spot that was your wants. There’s something very ‘I was the best thing that happened to her and she just wasn’t appreciative enough’ about it....urgh!

ravenmum · 14/02/2019 17:09

I have no bad memories of her in person
You've just listed various bad memories you have.

Did you just pretend to break up with her to make her feel bad and act more like you wanted? Or did you actually break up with her?

Petalflowers · 14/02/2019 17:12

I wondered about social anxiety as well. You admit in the op that you swung around like in the films, which she didn’t like.

You’ve given her space to ‘think about it’. It sounds like you expected her to come running back to you. However, she hasn’t read the script, and has stayed away. That is very telling.

You obviously wanted more from the relationship,then she did. Ie. You expected to spend a couple,of nights per week with her. She obviously found this too much. Is she a people pleaser. Ie. Saying yes to things to please you, (but then backing out for whatever reason).

I think you wanted her to be someone she isn’t.

Middersweekly · 14/02/2019 17:26

@Jim311, I agree it sounds like she is quite introverted and does need time alone to recharge her batteries. I don’t know her background but by the sound of it she’s been hurt badly in the past and perhaps doesn’t want to become reliant on a man. She’s clearly not sure what she wants out of a relationship at the moment and felt things were moving too quickly or at a speed she wasn’t comfortable with. If you are looking for a full steam ahead relationship then I would not contact her again. If you’re willing to take things one step at a time and appreciate she needs space then it may be worth trying again.

Jim311 · 14/02/2019 17:41

@Middersweekly

I know, deep down I know that, the problem is she'd be the one to talk about getting engaged etc, she even told me how many kids she wanted and asked if I'd be happy to have one in the next year or 2 as she always wanted a young family. I'm 31, I'm ready for a family and I told her that. We'd been together 2 years.

She did say her last relationship broke down because they never saw much of each other. One week she'd want to spend 4 nights with me then the next she wouldn't want to see me at all! She was actually shocked that I ended it even though I'd been saying for months I wanted use to start spending 2 nights a week together. That doesn't sound like a lot. She always told me what I wanted to hear but she never acted on it.

I broke up with her not out of a knee jerk reaction, I'd be thinking it for 2-3 months, I just kept waiting for her to do what she said she was going to do. After 3 months I realised things werent going to change. I did no contact not to win her back, but because I know it's what I needed to do to make sure I didn't try to win her back. I've deleted all her contact details and I don't have social media, it would be an effort to find a way to contact her which makes it easy to stop myself.

I guess I'm just having a moment of weakness. Thank God for this forum, just as way to let it out!

Break ups suck 😭

OP posts:
Orange6904 · 14/02/2019 18:35

Did you tell her any of what you've posted here before breaking up?

Knackeredmommy · 14/02/2019 18:48

Well done for keeping up the NC. She didn't offer a compromise or solution, she hasn't tried to contact you. You'll end up here again because it doesn't sound like she wanted to change the way things are and you're not happy with that.

category12 · 14/02/2019 19:04

The reasons you broke up would still be there if you got back together. She wasn't interested in changing the things that bother you, and I don't think what you were asking of her was in line with her personality - so basically you want her to be someone she isn't. Which is never going to work.

You're not compatible. Leave it.

Travisandthemonkey · 14/02/2019 19:37

You deserve better. Stay strong
The push pull is a horrible way to treat someone, it makes you start to doubt yourself and you feel like you’re slowly going mad and that’s designed for you to want them more. And they don’t have to give much back.
She sounds like she is totally unsuited to you. And you will meet someone who doesn’t give you all this bullshit drama.

You can’t spend the rest of your life with someone you are fundamentally mismatched with

Swipe left for the next trending thread