Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

How to decide whether to end a relationship?

9 replies

IamThis · 15/10/2018 09:46

Hi! I've been with my boufriend for a year and two months. I have in my life (I'm becoming 29 in a few months) only one "proper" relatiobship so far - it lasted for 1.5 years, but I was 18-19 then. Since then I have had some guys with whome I've had 1-2 dates or which have lasted maximum 1-3 months. Some of them left me, some of them I decided to end.
So then I started seeing my current boyfriend, for a year and two months now. He seemed decent and nice and reasonable and caring - compared to all the other guys. He really is. But he also has several aspects I do not feel comfortable or which cause me to feel not connected to him. I have worked hard on my past to become more brave, more outgoing, find or keep freidnships and find my self a hobby - to live as close to my inner dreams as possible (in the past I have been very lonely and thus rather modest and keeping myself isolated from life, although inside I always wanted to be outgoing, live and have fun). I worked really hard to accomplish this. Now, with my partner I rather feel that he holds me back or some kind of regression. He does support my hobby and he does not say I cannot meet my friends, but as he has no hobbies and basically no friends (anymore) he has a lot of free time besides work and I feel like he depends on me. There are also other things that I feel I must somehow hodl myself back and I cannot really live my whole potential. I would like to try new things and meet new people and maybe go to university again - but then I feel like I would abandon him because he has nothing to do besides spending time with me. He says its not an issue, but hes behaviour says otherwise. I just feel that it is not right. On the other hand, he has made some improvement, he is very helpful, caring, loving, etcetc. All a girl could dream of. But I feel like I'm losing my independence and my life. I have thought about leaving him, but then again he is so good to me as well and I really can't break his heart (especially that all his previous girlfriends have left him and since childhood he has some abandoning issues).
Maybe I have some kind of issue which hinders me loving and caring and trying to live my life as full with my partner beside me? How to figure it out? Maybe I have some kind of commitment-issues?
But I feel I have missed out so many things in my life previously due to my insecurities etc. And now I have gained all this confidence etc and I want to do all kinds of things, but most of them require me to do these things alone - going to university for example. And then he has nothing to do by himself and I feel like I should be spending more time with him. Currently, I have different goups of friends, but they live in different areas and we do not see often, but on average once per month for a few hours we meet. Sometimes more, sometimes less. I also have my dancing hobby, which involves training classes two times per week, rehearsing at home (which has come to minimum by now and which results in bad shape and that I'm not happy with my progress which mkes me sad), performances on average once per two months which also involve one-two extra rehearsels. To him, this has already been too much. I have cut down on performances etc, now he seems he accepts this amount, but I feel like if I should take any further things to do by myself, he would be upset again. And on top of that - I reallyreally need some alone time, but I cant get it. I would have to throw him out of our home to have some privacy. But he has nowhere to go. I do not know.. I made the mistake by moving in together with him two months ago. I figured it would solve the issue that "we cannot spend enough time together" - but it has made it worse in terms of me not having my alone time like never.
Im so confused. He has so many positive traits, but he has aspects which hinder me being myself (for example when sometimes I laugh hard and tears are falling, then he just walks away and leaves me by myself.. it saddens me, so I try to avoid such behaviour; or I am rather emotional in conversations and I tned to ask a lot of questions and interrupt, but I do not think it is too much, but he hates when he is interrupted and he is very slow talker and his thoughts are sooooo long and I have million of questions already so I cannot focuse anymore. So I try to avoid interrupting, as he has several times told me so, but this means that I just stare at one point and patiently listen to him and then say OK. Ths alos does not suit him because he says I am not attentive. I cannot find a balance, to be honest. He also does not ask questions, he does not ask about my past or my plans or my future dreams. He listens when I talk and remembers, but he does not ask any further. He says he does not know what to ask and also that if he wants to ask, he do not want to cause trouble to the other person, like maybe the other person does not want to answer. I have told him that it is not the case with me and he can ask me whatever and whenever and I would really like it. But nope, still nothing. Only minor improvements, but not enough). I think he would be great when we would have children - man who stays home and takes care of his family, he is a great cook and likes to cook (I do not like to cook) etc would be great. But I do not think I want children yet. He would be great during our old-age days. But at this point of my life - he holds me back I feel. He is not so active and outgoing. And if I want to be, then I have to motivate him too. But it also takes will and strenght to motivate myself, still. It is tiring to have to motivate another one too. But if I end it - maybe I will regret it later in my life, when I have done all I want to do and Iäm ready for children etc.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 15/10/2018 11:13

You will not regret ending this relationship. You are not suited for each other, it's obvious and as simple as that. Don't waste another day.

Musti · 15/10/2018 11:17

Bloody hell. Leave him. He sounds controlling and you're already changing your (reasonable) behaviour.

lifebegins50 · 15/10/2018 11:17

You are tolerating too much. 29 is a perfect age to find yourself and meet someone more suitable.

He maybe hurt by a break up but you are not responsible. Not being able to freely express yourself because you talk differentely to him or are more emotional will lead you to feel depressed.What you suppress does not go away.
Only settle down with someone who you can be yourself with.

ravenmum · 15/10/2018 11:27

It sounds like the only reason you are staying is so as not to make him unhappy?

In which case, one of you will always be unhappy.

AttilaTheMeerkat · 15/10/2018 11:32

What do you get out of this relationship now?.

You cannot act as a rescuer or saviour in a relationship, neither approach works. I would end this relationship asap because you and he are not fundamentally suited to each other.

Whose property are you both residing in; yours or his?.

If he holds you back as you state he does, he and you would patently not be great during the old age days either (even if this relationship did last that long which is very unlikely so I wonder why you mentioned that at all). Ok so he cooks; that is no big deal here. Your bar should be set a lot higher than it currently is; this is what happens when you settle for second rate in relationships. This is really second rate.

IamThis · 15/10/2018 11:48

Thank you all! I think the reason why I am with him, is that I have dreamed of being with someone. I know for sure I can be myself, I am happy being alone, but eventually I would like to have a husband and children. And I guess the reason why I keep holding on to him is that he has been the best possible match so far - he has the best qualities compared to all the other guys I have been dating. To find such care and love is difficult I guess. And as I have read - everyone has negatives, relationship means work, you must compromise and so on. This is why I have tried to think and work and compromise. And also, I feel like maybe I am wrong here. I mean, at the beginning I saw many flaws of him and we have discussed these things (not all perhaps) and somehow he then has made me feel that his flaws 1) can be improved, which he in small amounts has done and 2) should be considered by me as things that won't change and I should compromise. And then he has brought out some of my flaws as well, which seem reasonable. Overall, as he seems to be so reasonable when we argue or discuss, then I have grown to doubt myself - that maybe I am not right, maybe I am too headstrong, maybe I can't relax and see the other person as he is. So I keep on trying. I feel inside that he is not the one, but then my age comes to my head and all those articles and advice that "everyone has flaws and no one is perfect and compromise and work is needed in every relationship" - so maybe if I end this relationship, then all the other men I could find have some other kinds of flaws which are even worse. I mean, if I must deal with negative sides and flaws anyway, then why not to stick with those that I am already familiar with, knowing that at least he would be a good father. Maybe.
I get so confused. My heart says I should quit it, my head says that keep on trying.
Moreover, yes, I put my self in a situation where we live in MY apartment, he gave up his rental apartment. I would have to kick him out of my apartment if we broke up, but he has nowhere to go. To rent a new apartment - he would need a lot of money (broker fee etc), which I am pretty sure he hasn't currently. Moreover, he had a very good price previously, now the prices have gone up and he would have to pay a lot more every month for a rental. And I feel so guilty. However, I know that I would not jave doscovered many of these aspects of him if we had not moved in together..

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 15/10/2018 12:09

Misplaced guilt is NEVER a good reason to stay in a relationship you know is not right. He's a grown man. Finding a place to live is his concern, not yours. The sooner you move on with your life the better.

ravenmum · 15/10/2018 12:18

Him having to pay for a new flat is irrelevant. You are not going to settle down and have children with a man because otherwise he has to pay for a new flat.

You wanting to have children is also irrelevant. Or do you just want anyone with sperm?

His being the best so far is also irrelevant. Try out two more and the next one might also be the best so far.

Sure, we all have to compromise. But with some people it does not feel like compromising. You've not met that person yet.

Your "heart" is your subconscious, and your subconscious has noticed something.

ravenmum · 15/10/2018 12:20

he seems to be so reasonable when we argue or discuss, then I have grown to doubt myself - that maybe I am not right
You will doubt yourself more and more, every year.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page