Im 28 and 35 would in no way put me off.
Maybe youre simply not suited to OLD? Im not and you sound very much like my BF. He has said similar things to you, as well as mentioned the women he has spoken tos attitudes leaving much to be desired.
One woman ghosted him until her friend commented he was fit and then she was interested again.
Others wanted to know highly personal details within a couple of messages, and would pester for nudes (he doesnt like sending them).
Personally ive only ever turned to it if i was absolutely desperate for a quick shag and even then it was disappointing. Plenty up for it but none able to perform well even then.
I think its a minefield of damaged or incomplete people who would do better turning to a therapist than to a dating site,with anything better being few and far between.
Both BF and I get lots of attention in real life, to the point we both seem to attract some rather bizarre obsessive behaviour, so its almost certainly nothing to do with your looks or "value" as a provider.
Do yourself a favour. Take all the time you spend on OLD and use that time in the real world. Youre far more likely to find a compatible partner and if you meet them through a mutual hobby you won't have to worry about thinking of something to do together.
The psychological trick of these websites is to keep you clicking just in case your dream partner is just over the next page.
They most likely arent because the sort of person you really want isnt spending their life behind a PC screen, behind a glossy, carfully chosen and edited representation of themselves. Theyre out there doing actual fulfilling activities. Even the ones on OLD who claim to have hobbies. Most are just listing things they've experienced.
Cant even count the number of men whove claimed to have an interest in horses to me, and turned out their great aunts cousin twice removed had an ex racehorse they couldnt handle nevermind do anything resembling a hobby with.
Ive only met one man who delivered on the hobby side and turned up with two massive malamutes in tow, to go with my two siberian huskies.
And he was bloody married.
Fuckers. Go out. Get a hobby or just spend time in public enough and youll get attention and offers that way.