My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationships

All first dates no second dates, and men texting after a date but not asking you out!

129 replies

TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 09:21

Looking for any feedback that goes beyond love yourself, get a life etc because obviously I have all of that covered. My self-esteem is fine & I walk away from men who aren't going to meet my needs. But that leaves me with a never-ending list of first dates.
I know I have done more than 50% of the rejecting so I can't really cry in to my mashed potato for one (yet) but the last four internet dates I've been on, three of the four have rejected a second date with me. The last one, we were really vibing on our date (although perhaps I couldn't exactly read the vibe) and it was easy and fun. We had a good on line rapport which ground to a halt the moment I got out of the taxi and put my key in the door. By the next day (I'm not a slow learner) I had deciphered through reverberating silence that seemed to deafen the internet that we weren't going to have a second date. Fine, Ok, I accepted that. But then he started texting me, but really boring texts, like he was deliberately working hard at being quite boring. If there was one thing he wasn't it was boring so again I had to deduce that he was trying to communicate through the medium of being really boring that we weren't a thing. I got that. Every time I put him to the back of my mind I got another text from him to remind me. I got two texts in a row (i'd ignored one) so it was like he was determined to remind me. I asked are we actually going to meet up? And he has disappeared.

Anyway, for the sake of clarification, I'm not using photos that are decades old (less than a year all of them), they're not photo shopped. I am not overweight. And yes I do have kids, but not tiny ones, and they all knew that before they met me (and the most recent one also had kids, older kids but he did have kids).

Ps, I'm not being really fussy with the ones I've rejected. I tend to reject men if there are awkward silences, misunderstandings, no humour, and they want to meet again Confused

So, that's where the name change comes from, there is just no over lap between the men who'd date me and the men I'd date.

Gonna keep trying etc but I was wondering if anybody had any tips for bringing these two circles closer together. Give me a venn diagram that overlaps slightly please universe!

OP posts:
Report
scottishdiem · 02/01/2017 12:30

"there is just no over lap between the men who'd date me and the men I'd date"

Perhaps but that suggests your criteria for the men you'd date is either limited/incorrect or the criteria that you present (to get the vibing) online and in dates is limited/incorrect. Or both.

DP and I never felt the immediate and fabled spark that so many seem to want on that magical first date. We even, at one point, had a break in our dating. But we are now married for 4 1/2 years and very much in love. We have grown into our relationship and its fair to say we are more in love than the day we married. And we met on POF.....

Report
Hellofromtheotherside16 · 02/01/2017 12:47

Have you had any feedback from the ones who didn't want a second date? I know it might not be entirely honest but it might give you a clue to what's going on.

I have let down a few guys after the first or second date, not because they did anything wrong, but because life was really busy my end and I told them that. (Not dated for ages now for that reason.)

Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 12:49

Im not terrifying at all. These threads always descend into what might be wrong with the op! Im definitely not too fussy. I go for personality more than height/job/meaningless status. I dont care if somebody is a welder if they're happy. I dont want to lower my standards as a solution as i feel im being very realistic. Any sense that they're bitter/violent/angry or blamers and i walk away with the good luck out there text.

OP posts:
Report
LesisMiserable · 02/01/2017 13:03

OP, me and my DP were talking about this last night. We've been together two and a half years and met on Tinder. We were at a NYE party when a woman who was looking into OLD started questioning us (literally) about meeting online, what do you talk about on a date, how can you be arsed going on different dates when they won't go anywhere, how will you know if you'll like them and they'll like you (you won't, obviously!) etc and basically our conclusion was probably annoyingly simplistic - when it's right for both of you it's just right. It flows both ways.

It doesn't matter what your standards or expectations or beliefs are.

In our case we messaged to and fro for about a month and spoke on the phone twice I think before meeting. We messaged as and when we felt like it and we didn't 'expect' each other to message a certain frequency of times per day/hour (seems to be prevalent on MN) . Sometimes we'd messaged for an hour or two through the day,sometimes once a day, whatever we just let it unfold. Eventually, he phoned. I had butterflies. A couple of days later he phoned again. We got on. We still had no plans as such to meet at that point.

A couple of weeks later I was attending a work thing where he lived (around 60 miles from where I live). I asked if he wanted to meet up. He did. We met. We laughed. We got a bit drunk. We kissed. We did other things. We fell in love.

Any number of variables could have occurred to mean that didn't happen, any tiny thing could have put us off each other, but it didn't so here we are.

When it's right for both of you it's just right and there's really no point trying to think about it any other way. I realise that's of no help whatsoever really!!

Also very important advice to some MN daters, when you've landed your fish in the net, don't keep poking at it and questioning whether you've really caught it, it's in the net already, relax, take your fingers off your phone…. Wink

Report
angieneri · 02/01/2017 13:07

Jumping in just to share my own experience with men going "boring" after the first date and then keeping in touch without looking for a second date. It was not OLD but still.

A couple of months ago I started chatting with a coworker of mine I've had a crush on since forever. At first he was super fun, witty, sent me pics of what he was up to, initiated contact first and so on. After a few weeks he invited me to a night out with other colleagues, after which we eneded up having a last drink alone and kissing for hours. It felt like we had a real connection, great chemistry and the conversation was spontaneous and interesting (at least that's how I felt).

After that night he initially kept messaging me a lot and seemes super keen. Then, slowly but surely, his texts got less witty, less fun, less frequent. He invited me to another work do with other colleagues where he proceeded to ignore me for the whole evening. And then he disappeared.

I will probably never know the reason why he lost interest in me, and I surely won't ask. I felt like there was a re connection, but clearly he did not feel the same, so I had to move on.

Sorry for highjacking the thread, just wanted to share this story as it is quite fresh and unfortunately still very much on my mind.

Report
LesisMiserable · 02/01/2017 13:08

Also should say, on that first date DP (the next morning ahem..) proclaimed "I'm definitely seeing you again" to which I replied…."ok…" Before the date was over he had arranged to see me the following weekend. Did I worry that he was just saying it and it would fall through? OK course I did. But it was fine and now despite still at present living 60 miles from each other we see each other every day one way or the other.

The point being, if they want to see you again, they'll say it out loud, unprompted on the date because they just do not want to risk you walking away. That's my experience anyway.

Report
rememberthetime · 02/01/2017 13:09

TwoCircles....I am a copywriter and having a so-called "cool" job does not in any way guarantee a cool date. Far from it. I have had messages from people who think I am a copyrighter and suggest I am in the legal profession! Others who make a massive effort to write in a fun and exciting way and then when I met them they were really boring.

One thing I have discovered though is that I need someone who can write well in their messages to me and is intelligent. Those two will be close to the centre of my venn diagram. Then they need to translate that to the date. That's where things get tricky.

However I like to the second date idea too. First dates can be so nerve wracking. You need to see the person in a more natural environment - where they are being themselves, not the person you hoped for. I think...meet so that you know you find them physically attractive. then meet them again to see if your personality clicks. Don't try to find out both at the same time.

But totally agree. Bitter about their ex, constantly going on about their divorce or break up, moaning about money or any hint of infidelity or abuse and you need to walk away quicksmart.

Report
LesisMiserable · 02/01/2017 13:14

remember I agree completely with that point.

As I said I first met DP in person on a night out together where we both got royally drunk and very silly and had an ace night out.

The next time we met the following weekend was a quiet meal and we both had to work a little to keep conversation going as we were both a lot more nervous sober, but we found common ground to chat about and it went well. We are both articulate writers and that is what attracted us to each other as there was no crude crap or 'morning beautiful' rubbish .. But after we got over the second date we were really just an item as all boxes were ticked for us both at that point Smile

Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 13:24

Remember, thanks!
Angieneri, the turning boring is a thing then. Do they think it is kinder than just saying no thank you?
Lessismiserable glad it worked out for you but id never invest so much time in to somebody i hadnt met. I like to meet them within about 10 days of the online connection. If i find myself explaining 'no, that was a joke' or if they make assumption after asdumption about me i lose interest. But i dont interview them for hours to decide if it's worth meeting. Just get a sense.

OP posts:
Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 13:27

hellofromtheotherside now that would be interesting. Perhaps ill ask one day.

OP posts:
Report
PamDooveOrangeJoof · 02/01/2017 13:32

I think they just have their fingers in a few pies like a pp said. When they think you may be THE pie to end all pies, thy crank up all the effort.
after meeting and deciding you are nice but not THE pie, they want to keep you warming in the oven (should they not meet a bigger better pie) but can't be bothered to make so much effort. Hence the boring.

Report
LesisMiserable · 02/01/2017 13:33

There's nothing wrong with meeting someone within 10 days OP. Personally I found not rushing into things and letting our bond build as 'friends' for want of a better word, just meant that when we did meet the physical attraction was the last thing to click into place because we already knew quite a lot about each other, so we had no doubts from day one that we'd found something really good and compatible.

(No interviewing took place Smile and I think if you class dating in such a perfunctory and business like manner as that and it comes across as that in your persona, that might be what's putting people off a second date)

Also you sound quite a strong, articulate and dynamic personality. Someone said upthread you may come across as intimidating, which you didn't agree with. I've also been told that I can come across as extremely assertive/intimidating which kind of threw me as I thought of myself as extremely sweet and approachable Grin Maybe soften your approach a bit (even if you don't think you should) , it might make a difference? It doesn't mean lowering your standards it means opening yourself up to someone new in an authentic way. Let them see your soft underbelly a bit (figuratively speaking ha!!)



Just

Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 18:34

I think it worked for you but it's generally acknowledged to be a pointless venture to invest too much time in to somebody you haven't met. IF you were just looking for a 'friend' truly, then maybe it'd be ok.

I'm not intimidating, really. I'm very polite in real life (as I've been on this thread). I'm just trying to see the humour in the situation. Also, I've been single for 9 years now so the problem is that the usual advice that's doled out such as get a life, love yourself, I'm not aggressively rejecting it out of defensiveness, nope, I've been on my journey, lol, I'm out the other end, I do love myself and I'm very used to being single. I am capable of being vulnerable. I am honest enough to say to somebody that I need their help or honest enough to admit to people that I am at times lonely and I would like a relationship. I think that's quite a vulnerable admission from somebody who is confident and financially secure.

I've learnt a lot in 2016 and I'm putting it to good use (the most recent date, this time last year I would have wasted time chasing him). Now I see things clearly. So many lessons to learn!

OP posts:
Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 18:37

Pam yes, in a coquille de noix, that is it my friend. I just have to wait until I'm somebody's most tempting pie. And if I like the cut of their strides, we might get to a second date. I hope.

OP posts:
Report
triskellionoflegs · 02/01/2017 18:54

I think it's a personal choice how to get to know someone, and neither meeting fast or slow is better. Your strong views on this OP, do suggest a little that you're a little certain you know best. I mention this as it may be relevant to your dating issues..

it's generally acknowledged to be a pointless venture to invest too much time in to somebody you haven't met. IF you were just looking for a 'friend' truly, then maybe it'd be ok.

You may need to accept that people have different view, which can be equally valid, and spending several weeks getting to know someone as a person may be needed to meet someone who is right for you (why would that be a pointless venture?!).

Report
Newbrummie · 02/01/2017 19:13

I'm off the market now but I think back to when I was newly single and less jaded therefore more honest and demanding. I used to add them on FB immediately, soon as they had my number because I wanted them to see my life and see if that worked for them. If I'd done that with the last few I dated I would have got the measure of them bloody quick and if they'd refused I'd have known they were married which at least 3 of them were I discovered later.

Report
Mintychoc1 · 02/01/2017 19:26

I would ask the boring guy why he didn't want to meet again. You have nothing to lose, and you may learn something

Report
AhYerWill · 02/01/2017 19:54

I'd second giving another chance to those that are keen where the only issue is a lack of "chemistry" (clearly bin off the scary/downright weird ones).

IME the more genuine guys can take a while to warm up and be themselves - the ones with great banter are often the serial dater/players, who seem super keen and then fade away.

Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 19:56

I am curious but I wont ask. He is half-hearted at best so im glad he's taken himself out of the running. If they are in two minds about you and you shut down their half-hearted time wasting, they always reappear. Ill ask him when he pops back up again.
As if by magic a man who wasting my time back in april til i walked away, he popped back up yesterday to wish me happy new year. I took the bait and i replied but i pulled an iamboringnow on him. I was quited stilted in my good wishes. Sincere though they were.

OP posts:
Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 20:00

As for messaging people for weeks/months before meeting, it is all fantasy or filling in the gaps before you meet them in real life. Saying that i do have a pen pal on the go but he probably has avoidance issues. Lots of avoidants love a good cyber relationship.

OP posts:
Report
Newbrummie · 02/01/2017 20:02

TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap - exactly as do the married ones ....

Report
HandyWoman · 02/01/2017 20:02

Eek! The last 3 were married? Horrific! Good lord.

Agree with OP 3 weeks of messaging before meeting is a lot. Think that's a general consensus.

Messaging for ages can build up a totally unrealistic picture of someone. I think LesisMiserable was fortunate that after messaging that long it all worked out.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

HandyWoman · 02/01/2017 20:05

Luck has so much to do with it. Once your twat radar and rhinohide are functional it's just all about luck, tbh.

Report
UncomfortableBadger · 02/01/2017 20:14

@twocirclesthatdontoverlap Gosh, this sounds so familiar. Basically this was exactly my position, five or so years ago.

Lots of "nice" dates with "nice" chaps and although second dates were mentioned/discussed/agreed (at their behest!), they never came to fruition. I began to wonder if I had horns and scales!

Then went on a date with my now DP and everything changed. No fuckwittery, no confusion, no game playing - we just REALLY liked each other. It just felt different; I couldn't even explain why. We wanted to spend time together and both made sure it happened.

Not a very helpful post, I know, but do hang on in there. It worked for me Smile

Report
TwoCirclesthatdontoverlap · 02/01/2017 20:24

Eek new brummie, never thought of that in the case of my 'penpal'.

Learning lessons as you go along and waiting for good luck now!!

I dont go for obvious players. I go for quite ordinary men, i think!

Glad it worked out in the end badger and handy!

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.