Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Mother buys all sisters gifts

12 replies

12jenny12 · 18/04/2015 18:22

My sister who I only see once a year, if that and don’t have a close relationship, with always sends expensive gifts for me and my now adult children for Christmas and Birthdays. Her adult children also send gifts for my adult children. They always come via my mother. I always send just cards for her and cards and gifts for her adult children although nothing matching her generosity as we can’t afford it. On occasions I have forgotten or been late with a card and my mother has gone ballistic.

To cut a very long story short I have now discovered that for the past 40 years every single card and gift from my sister and her children has been bought, wrapped and paid for by my mother. My mother has even written all the cards. My sister has always been the golden child, but I am in shock. My mother does not know I know this and neither does my sister. It also makes me so angry that I have felt so guilty over the years and felt it was a habit that should have been long forgotten, but kept on due to my mother’s nagging and my sisters supposed generosity.

I have no idea how to handle this. My mother is 83 and my sister is 60. I feel I have been manipulated all these years and it hurts. My sister must know as we always thank her for any gift via txt/email. My mother is a very difficult woman and even at her age will probably deny all knowledge. Where do I go from here?

OP posts:
MyRightFoot · 18/04/2015 18:32

i wouldnt say anything. im guessing if your mum didnt do this, your sister wouldnt bother, as you say youre not close. im reading this as your mum would like her two girls to be close and she has kept up the pretence. maybe she feared putting a stop to it because then you might take offence. no point in rowing over this, your silence will keep an old lady happy. at least you know what sis really thinks of you.

GnomeDePlume · 18/04/2015 18:32
  1. This pantomime stops
  2. Contact your sister and say that as you now know it is all make believe that it stops now.
  3. Tell your sister that as she has been complicit in this for the last 40 years that she can tell your mother that it is over.
  4. Breathe

I would guess that your mother is trying to manufacture a relationship between you and your sister. She is also trying to maintain the status of your sister by being generous.

You never know, without this charade getting in the way you and your sister might be able to get on!

MiddleAgedandConfused · 19/04/2015 00:27

How did you find out?

AvaCrowder · 19/04/2015 00:33

If she was trying to improve your relationship she would have bought expensive gifts for your sister and her family from you too though.

Speak to your sister.

FATEdestiny · 19/04/2015 00:41

You haven't spoken to your sister or your mother about this. What makes you so confident it is true?

How did you make this discovery?

I would recognise my mothers writing. Didn't you?

My own brother is often a bit useless and my Mum buys the gifts that he gives to family members. They are from him though, he gives Mum the money. I find nothing terrible in the fact this happens (except that I wish my brother was less useless and my Mum pandered to him less, but not the actual gift exchanges).

VenusRising · 19/04/2015 00:47

Follow the money Jenny. Where did your DM get the money for the presents?

Often I give people money for presents for nieces, and cousins, and they buy them and wrap them.

Your sister might have given your mum money for presents, and your mum might have bought them on her behalf for your family. You don't know all the facts.

I'd relax about going nuclear, it's not useful to anyone, and will disrupt the harmony of your family.

If you have problems with the dynamic of your birth family, maybe talk to someone about it, but I wouldn't go postal on your DM or your sister, as you only know a small part of what's going on and are inferring a hurtful scenario which may be untrue.

Find out more about it before you allow yourself be enraged/ betrayed, if that's what your reaction is going to be.

daisychain01 · 19/04/2015 02:39

I would recommend checking the facts with the person you found out from, and get them to tell you how they know it for certain. For example how do they know it was every single present for the last 40 years? Did they help your DM buy all the presents?

Don't get egg on your face by jumping to a false conclusion is what I'm saying.

Joysmum · 19/04/2015 08:29

If you are sure this is funded by your mum, stop the pretence now by telling her she can save herself the money and stop and instead just write cards from each family to the the other if she must as you won't be bothering with cards anymore now you know your not in their thoughts enough to even do that so will be match DSIS's indifference.

12jenny12 · 19/04/2015 09:48

My nephews new wife told me. My daughter sent her an email at Christmas thanking her for the expensive coffee machine they bought and she had no clue about it. She confronted her husband as she was annoyed he spent so much and he said my mother buys and pays for all the gifts "so he doesnt have to worry" and even has a book with all the gifts in so she doesnt send the same thing twice. She thought it was very odd so thats why she told me. Last week my daughter recived a birthday card from my "nephew and his new wife" with £50 in and she confirmed the handwriting wasnt hers or my nephews. She said she thought it was odd we send them cards and gifts when they don't bother and now she knows why.

She thinks my mother is very controlling and lots of stuff came out. All my sisters family go for dinner evey Sunday and my motehr always goes on about how good they are to her and lover her so much they visit every week.. In fact if Sunday dinner is missed my mother goes crazy and they are all scared of her, including my sister. She also expects a daily phone call from them all. My nephews wife is sick of it and wants to stop the weekly all day visits. I feel a bit sorry for them all to be honest as my mother has never liked me and makes no such demands on my time.

OP posts:
NameChange30 · 19/04/2015 09:54

It sounds like your mother is very manipulative. Look up the book Toxic Parents.

What do you want to do now? Do you want your mother to stop sending the gifts or would you prefer not to say anything?

ginmakesitallok · 19/04/2015 09:57

I don't think your mum will be doing this to make you feel bad or guilty. Perhaps she feels guilty because as she sees it your sister gets more of her time than you do? (Lucky them?!). Perhaps she thinks that as you always send gifts they should too, and if they can't be bothered she's taken it upon herself to play Santa?

I would ask your mother about it, as calmly as you can.

tribpot · 19/04/2015 09:58

It sounds like being the golden family and the scapegoat is exhausting and emotionally draining. I hope the nephew's wife does put a stop to some of this behaviour, it sounds dreadful.

From now on I would send cards but no further gifts. I would thank each family member personally for the gifts given in their name so that your mum knows she's been rumbled. As her goal is not to give nice things to you (although in fairness the presents don't sound awful?) but to make you feel guilty and less successful than your sister, she may stop when it no longer has that effect?

I don't think I'd confront her about it, that allows her to feel attacked and make this your fault. Just quietly undermine her and go about your business. It's her choice to make, but you can choose how you respond to it. The whole thing seems very bizarre.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page