Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

evaluate dh reaction and in-laws comments

39 replies

countrymusic · 01/03/2015 23:09

Hi,

dh's family has a habit of talking bad behind everyone's back, specially his mum feels she has being wronged by everyone at some point but she might be best friends with them in a matter of few days. I have minimal contact with her, even when she is visiting, I hardly talk to her (previous history of not getting along). I have heard that MIL's sister has apparently said that how worried she is that I don't know their customs and traditions and how will I ever pass it to my children. We have no children yet. MIL's brother said how I act as a guest when I visit MIL's home and not help with dinner etc. I have visit them for about about 4-5 days every 2 years. I feel so criticised and monitored that I don't even feel like attempting to do anything and go and sit in a room. The relationship is not harmonious to go and help them, its just a matter of visiting them with husband. They give so many errands to dh that he is hardly at their home with me. I have decided not to visit them again as I'm always going to be fault at something. My husband's uncle and aunty have not said these things about me to him directly, they all have been passed on by MIL. MIL can start a conversation with someone and use their response against you. So there is a doubt that MIL has said something about me to her sister and brother and telling just their response as if they are saying all these things themselves.

My husband listens to all such things and just says there is nothing like that, there is no need, people doing it aren't happy etc and tries to minimise the issue at hand. Since these things have been said in the past, my husband doesn't want to bring it up again and says whenever I want to discuss I only want to fight. He has told MIL that her own behaviour has made me distance from herself and had the talks. I moved past MIL's sister and brothers' comments but this time when she was visiting, MIL said to my husband that he has married the wrong women and how I have kicked her out of our lives. To what husband says he replied that he married who he wanted to marry.

I don't think that's the right response. He came to me telling me, this is what mum said and really this is what happened to her, isn't it. I'm so mad at him that rather than addressing what she said about being marrying the wrong women, he is more focused to the point that I have kicked her out of our lives and wanted an answer from me on that. I have asked my husband not to tell me whatever they have to say about me. It is all very upsetting, specially I don't talk to her and can't address the issue and it was said behind my back. Now its been one month since I am not intimate with him - may be I'm being unreasonable but his lack of strong response to her mum and instead asking me about it has been a sticking point. Now he says this is old stuff and if I'll hold onto things said in the past like I always have, I'm causing unnecessary conflict. But obviously everything said becomes things said in the past, am not sure how to deal with this. Do I just keep dropping such stuff, it doesn't matter what they say etc. I know my every day life is not affected but it does piss me off big time. wwyd?

OP posts:
countrymusic · 02/03/2015 11:13

That said, I could go on about MIL and it won't change a thing. So I have asked my husband to quit telling me all this. But gosh its hard to let go off this one.

OP posts:
Vivacia · 02/03/2015 12:01

Can you explain why you see so much of your in-laws?

BackforGood · 02/03/2015 13:15

I just want to be clear that when I made my original response, only the opening post was there.
All the information that's been given since would have given a very different response from me.

brightnearly · 02/03/2015 14:21

My sister married a man from the subcontinent and is experiencing similar problems - different languages, religions etc, and no desire on her part to play the part of a traditional DIL.
She has coped so far (but it's not been easy!) by resorting to some of the tactics mentioned upthread - unwavering cheerfulness, polite but firm responses that annihilate any attempts at gossiping or badmouthing, and, most of all, complete emotional detachment from MIL (pretend that MIL is just someone you sit next to on a bus).
And - to preserve her sanity - using every excuse possible to limit visits! Get a weekend job - volunteering role - etc etc.
It seems there are only ways to mitigate the impact, but the problem is not likely to ever go away.
Does your MIL view your husband's house as essentially hers?

rinabean · 02/03/2015 14:25

It's not rude, you were a guest and they were treating you badly. I don't have advice on the rest sorry. But I'm shocked people here were saying it's rude for a guest who is criticised for trying to help to not help

countrymusic · 02/03/2015 22:42

Vivacia
I have been visiting MIL's house once every 2 years. They would make husband know how rude I am if both were in India and I didn't visit his family.

brightnearly
For MIL, its her son's home and rightly so hers' too. She used to visit H for about a month and since retirement she stays for a lot longer with us in London.

Apart from MIL issues, I'm frustrated with my husband and would like a stronger reaction rather than standard diplomatic way to suppress the issue keep peace.

Thanks for the recent replies, so very kind of you all Smile

OP posts:
MorrisZapp · 02/03/2015 22:50

I've never yet seen a post on here complaining because a son in law or father in law sits on their arse and doesn't chip in with cooking, serving and cleaning.

Yet mils and dils are supposed to 'muck in'. I come from a background of equality, it's not normal for me to wait on seated menfolk. I'd feel odd doing it and I wouldn't know it was expected.

Sexism reigns.

Vivacia · 03/03/2015 05:37

I think it would be very reasonable of you to really cut down on those visits, or not have them at all.

BoneyBackJefferson · 03/03/2015 07:01

MorrisZapp

"I've never yet seen a post on here complaining because a son in law or father in law sits on their arse and doesn't chip in with cooking, serving and cleaning."

I can only think that you don't read MN during the festive period.

TheUnwillingNarcheska · 03/03/2015 08:05

I cannot believe how harsh people have been towards you Country.

The whole "being a guest" in your PIL's house is because you were never accepted into the family in the first place. If they had welcomed you with open arms then you wouldn't feel the way that you do.

I speak as someone who certainly was not welcomed into my in-laws family. In fact our engagement announcement was met with complete silence and then debrett's training kicked in and hollowed congratulations bestowed.

I think you need to be grateful that despite such a strong mother your DH has stood up for you, albeit in a less than enthusiastic way but he did defend you. Secondly, I think you need to do the whole overly polite, well mannered bit but still stand firm on your own beliefs.

TalkingintheDark · 03/03/2015 08:19

"If the culture you married into has all this formality around ... lowest ranking female etc, then you either respect the culture and knuckle down OR you realise that if you don't you will cause offence."

What the actual fucking fuck? Rhoda, that is one of the most fucked up things I've ever read on MN, utter fucked up shite.

Seriously. Respect misogyny and sexism? Respect the kind of culture that makes a woman a servant to her H and ILs? The same kind of culture that can lead to vicious bullying, abuse, and even murder? What exactly is there to respect there, Rhoda?

TalkingintheDark · 03/03/2015 08:26

Sorry OP not to address you directly, just a tad enraged there.

No wise words re your DH, although I can see why you're upset he didn't come out with a stronger response to a dreadful comment like that.

MorrisZapp · 03/03/2015 11:24

Boney, really? I've seen loads of women moan that their husbands don't help at Christmas, it's par for the course. But brothers in law and fathers in law? I have never seen anybody moan about their failure to bring a dish, help out in the kitchen, or take responsibility for present buying etc.

countrymusic · 03/03/2015 14:15

TalkingintheDark Rhoda has a SIL like me that her family thinks is wrong choice, including the husband. Its the same advice that anyone from my in-laws would have given me Wink

I felt awful after reading the first few replies but the next day was much better.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page