Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

DH was abused by his brother

4 replies

Goatcoat · 10/02/2015 14:19

I've namechanged and will be deliberately vague.

DH's brother was sexually abused by their uncle as a kid. This only came out a few years ago and DH doesn't know the full details. Him and his brother aren't close, and in fact we are NC with him at the mo. He is an arse, and is using his abuse as a reason for his awful behaviour over the past 20 years. This may well have jaded him but even PIL are skeptical about the abuse claims and aren't 100% sure it's even all true.

DH told me last night that he can remember 2 incidents with his brother that he "can't decide if it was normal brotherly curiosity or something more sinister". He can't remember how old he was, possibly 8 or 9 (his brother is 3 years older). He's not upset about it as such, but he's confused and angry.

When his brother told of his abuse, DH said that things fell into place a bit more with regard to these 'incidents'. As I say, he doesn't know the detail of his brother's abuse but is angry over the possibility that his brother may have repeated the uncle's alleged actions on DH.

DH feels really burdened by this "secret" now. He doesn't want to talk to his parents about it as he thinks they have enough to deal with various other crap the brother has caused over the past few years. He is full of hate for his brother over this crap from the recent years (and, I suspect, because of what his brother did to him) so wouldn't talk to him about it. He also doesn't know if a) he wants to piece it together and b) what good it would do to remember/know/understand more anyway.

I'm distraught that my lovely DH has been a victim in all of this too and I suspect the impact of it all is going to hit DH slowly over the coming weeks/months/years. I'm seething with his brother but there is also a part of me that feels desperately sorry for the confused and abused soul that he is and that if those things were being done to him as a kid, it's conceivable that he could also do the same - with or without understanding it was wrong.

Obviously I've said to DH that I'm here to talk only if/when he wants (he can be a pretty closed book sometimes - which kind of makes sense now). He's sad at the mess of the situation and had, until recently, remained loyal to his brother despite disagreeing with his actions and behaviours "he's my brother after all" but I think that's changed now.

What the hell does he/we/I do from here?

I don't want this to eat away at him and don't think he should shoulder the responsibility of protecting his parents, or brother, from this but can totally see that he can't really go anywhere with it.

OP posts:
pocketsaviour · 10/02/2015 14:42

I'm so sorry for you to both be having to deal with this.

Sadly it's not unusual for children who are being abused to re-enact the abuse on another child (usually younger, usually the same sex as the abuser.) So I would not discount the brother's allegations about the uncle.

It's possible to feel sorry for someone for what they have been through and still hold them to account for their actions against others. Being hurt by others doesn't give us some sort of get-out-of-jail-free card. You can sympathise with the guy's problems and still be angry with his behaviour (then and now) to your DH.

What does your DH feel he wants to do now? Would he consider counselling? You said that he wouldn't talk to his brother about the abuse, but do they have much interaction normally?

Goatcoat · 10/02/2015 15:41

I don't think DH knows what he wants to do next, if anything tbh. I think he wants to get the timings/age clear in his head (I think to ensure that it will tally up with the same timings/age his brother says his abuse abuse occurred). But I think he feels "then what?"... If it does tally, it will make "sense" as to why but it won't change anything.

The brother has behaved pretty horrendously to his family, us included and plays the victim very well. It feels a bit unfair to say this, because he has been the victim of something hideous. But you're right, it doesn't excuse him.

DH has been low contact for 10+ years and no contact at various times, including now. His brothers mental health has been precarious for a while now too and I don't think DH feels it's right to "remind" his brother and wouldn't want to make him feel worse. And again, wonders where the benefit would be?

I think DH can cope with the incidents themselves and can rationalise (if that's the right word) them into "he did it because the uncle was doing it to him and didn't know right from wrong and was fucked up" - but he's cross that it's a dirty secret that he's been lumbered with.

OP posts:
Goatcoat · 10/02/2015 15:44

And I think he's frustrated because, for as long as he can remember -once again, it's all about his sodding brother. Poor old X. And actually now he's been affected by it all too, he's just stuck with it.

OP posts:
Goatcoat · 10/02/2015 21:51

I'm really sad that my wonderful DH has had this hanging over him for so long.

He says he feels utterly drained today.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread