Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Have I done the right thing??

15 replies

JustCallMeBridget · 24/01/2015 17:58

I was married for ten years but we married young and things didn't work out sadly. I met someone else and we left our marriages for each other.
There followed an amazing relationship - passionate, full of love and sexual attraction but it was also dysfunctional and absolute hell at times. After 18m of trying to make this thing work, we split and didn't speak for about 2m. The fallout from this relationship was enormous - it shattered both our families and it was just huge. Basically public arguments which got very heated and on one occasion actually ruined his aunts 60th birthday party. I was blamed entirely and there's no way his family would accept me 'back' easily.

Then we gradually got back in contact and much to my utter distress, He had already moved and had a new g/f. I know she's not The One and is basically a rebound and for that reason I decided that I was OK with contact, knowing he was in a casual relationship with someone else.
By this stage I'd received a MH diagnosis and appropriate medication for it which removed a lot of my reckless, erractic behaviour. I'd basically been suffering from this illness they think for the best part of ten years and a lot of choices and behaviours were partly the product of this. He was very understanding, but also struggled to get past certain things that happened.
There followed a month or so of increased contact, nights spent together, long, tearful conversations and discussions as to our future. I cannot stress enough how much I truly LOVE this man. In every way possible. The bond between us is exceptional - people don't have that often - and we both knew how it was. It's only ever been him since the day I met him.

BUT - not only did he have a new g/f but he is also tied up in her world in lots of ways which it's very difficult to extract himself from (can't say what for fear of outing). At the same time he was very honest in saying that although he loves me deeply he is simply not ready to be in a relationship with me yet. He needs a chance for a clear head to sort his life and business and get everything back on track. So we reached an agreement (after several tearful conversations) whereby we would end things for the moment, go NC and that he would be back in touch at some point in the future to see what the situation is then. I agreed through having no choice if I wanted him in my life - and this man was my best friend, my lover, my everything. I adore him. But I can't do it. I can't have him and yet by leaving it 'open' I can't get over him which leaves me in a horrible no mans land of emotions. I do understand his situation and thoughts but at the same time I think that if he loved me properly he wouldn't be able to walk away from me like this?? And it's not reasonable to seriously expect someone to be waiting for you until you're ready?? He says it isn't like that, but essentially that's exactly what he's saying "You can't have me now but you might be able to in the future". I agreed, but with misgivings and tonight I have ended it permanently. I can't live like that and in terms of my own self-respect I can't allow it.

It's the hardest thing I've ever done but I was going round in circles of: OK, I can handle this - no I can't - wtf does he think he's doing?! - I'm worth much more - but I love him and the relationship between us is amazing - ad infinitum.

So have I done the right thing? Or should I have left the door open? I would so genuinely appreciate wise advice from others - and someone to tell me that my heart will mend one day! Because this pain is almost literally unbearable.

(Sorry for the mammoth post)

OP posts:
Lacoba66 · 24/01/2015 18:11

You've done the right thing in my opinion. Now that you are getting help for the condition that you say you have had for at least 10 years, you possibly need to let go?

Personally, I think he is a coward and using you! He can use all the excuses he wants, but he is keeping you hanging on for something that he can't/ won't actually commit to, but will not have the decency to let you move on.

On that note... Why? Why are you hankering after a man that quite clearly doesn't have your best interests at heart.

Surely you are worth more?

JustCallMeBridget · 24/01/2015 18:14

Well exactly, that's why I sent the final text. I'm just struggling with the realisation that something so perfect is not going to be allowed to be :(

Thank you for your reply :)

OP posts:
BitOutOfPractice · 24/01/2015 18:19

It's not perfect though is it. It sounds stormy, angst inducing, hard work and not terribly happy. I think sometimes people mistake stormy and difficult for passionate and star crossed.

You have absolutely done the right thing

CaffeLatteIceCream · 24/01/2015 18:21

Yes, I think you've done absolutely the right thing.

You've stripped down his "deep and meaningful" emotional twaddle into what he's actually saying...which is "I don't want you right now, but you may get lucky and I'll want you in the future".

Bugger that.

People who want/love another person WANT THEM. RIGHT NOW. None of this "lets see how I feel later".

It's the worst kind of emotional manipulation, and you are worth considerably more. I am glad you know that...so many women don't.

Will you feel better? Eventually, yes. Guaranteed. But you need to accept the need to mourn the end of a relationship that meant a lot to you. It hurts like hell, and will do for a while, but it will fade in time and you will move on from this.

QuintlessShadows · 24/01/2015 18:23

But it wasn't perfect. You both cheated on your partners and ended up together. You were arguing a lot, you ruined his aunts birthday with your temper and lack of control. He has moved on and has a new girlfriend.

What makes you think it was perfect!

He was a passionate love affair and rowing partner, and he now loves somebody else.

Jackiemagazine · 24/01/2015 18:28

This may be a bit harsh but I mean this in the kindest way possible - you were his exit affair. He may well have loved you, and may well still love you more than current gf, BUT you're parcelled up as "part of a problem" (his marriage breaking down) and not "part of a solution" (being with someone who on the face of it is more classic wife material.) You were the passion, but she's his safe bet.

Let him go. It gets easier in time.

CarbeDiem · 24/01/2015 18:32

Yes, you've done the right thing. 100%
Don't think about opening that fucking door to him again.

MagpieCursedTea · 24/01/2015 18:40

You've done the right thing.
I was once in a similar situation. Desperately in love and really quite ill (undiagnosed bipolar). We had a messy break up and I eventually got diagnosed and treated. It was too late to go back. I managed to spend years over romanticising what was a passionate but very dysfunctional relationship.
Once I'd managed to let go of the ex, I built an stable and loving relationship with my now DH.
It's hard but the best thing is to work on yourself and enjoy your new found wellness.

AndTheBandPlayedOn · 24/01/2015 18:40

You did the right thing.
You have saved yourself potentially years of frustration hoping, expecting, praying, begging, etc him to ..."be ready". Are you ready yet? Can you hear me now?
Imho, sorry, but he could not have loved you that much, because if he did, he would be eager for a relationship and not let you get away. Sorry, but it was such a line of lip service.

He wanted you on stand by. In a big picture kind of way: Not nice, imho, no matter how agreeable he presented himself during your time together.

Or he wanted to break up with you but manipulated it so you'd do the breaking up and not him. Wuss.

Or combine the two and he wanted to break up with you but, hey, wouldn't it be wonderful if we hooked up later, you know, whenever, I am horny ready?
Five star jerk.

The pain will pass. The bond you had with him has been broken. Yes, that is going to hurt. But you did the right thing in not letting him degrade you. Well done.

HelloItsStillMeFell · 24/01/2015 18:43

I think that if he loved me properly he wouldn't be able to walk away from me like this??

Well you said it, I'm afraid. He left his wife apparently for you and yet he's 'not ready to be with you' ? Confused

I think he's been a bit freaked out by your intensity and the volatility in the relationship, and quite possibly by your MH issues and they way they have manifested themselves and he's trying to extricate himself without actually telling you straight. It's like the relationship equivalent of a parent slowly edging towards the bedroom door while still holding a sleeping child's hand. He's afraid of what your reaction will be if he tells you straight that he's out. What is the MH condition you've been diagnosed with? Is Bi Polar or Borderline PD?

Bu the simple fact is, he is with someone else now, so whether it's a transitional thing or not, he's clearly moved on and you sound somewhat in denial about that.

It all sounds a bit high drama, this relationship, doesn't it? Relationships like that rarely go the distance. Perhaps he's accepted that and he's trying to nip it in the bud for both your sakes.

pictish · 24/01/2015 18:44

So the deal is, you hang on in there, a silent, concealed yet fully accessible option for him, just in case he decides he might want you in the future, while in the meantime he stays with his gf and sees how that goes.

Sounds like a sack of shit to me. He doesn't love you deeply. I'm going to be charitable and say that at best, he is trying to let you down gently. Otherwise he's just having a laugh isn't he?

You have done the right thing.

HelloItsStillMeFell · 24/01/2015 18:45

I managed to spend years over romanticising what was a passionate but very dysfunctional relationship.

Yes, this is exactly what is happening here as well.

pictish · 24/01/2015 18:53

You are deluding yourself as to the perfection of your relationship with him. It was the result of betrayal and deceit in the first place, and ended up a series of horrible rows. It was a mess really.

He has moved on. He has a girlfriend. Don't tell yourself she's a minor detail that will inevitably get swatted aside - he has made his choice, and it's her, not you.
If he wanted to be with you, he would be. It really is as simple as that.

SexOrTaxRelief · 24/01/2015 19:16

Your largest paragraph hits me like a diamond bullet!

Love and passion can be like drugs but you have fought through the mist and fog and with feet firmly on the ground and reached some mature and admirable conclusions. Many people would not do that.

Your relationship is not equal. You are second best to him, and he does not share your passion. It is hard now, but you have enough in you to get through this and if you keep growing (in my opinion you are a person who can do that) you will find a more worthy love and another passion one day. Reading your post again, you have an amazing heart, and keep it strong and passionate and it will attract another one.

Oh, and people do have strong bonds, and passion and spontaneity. Its not about what is the norm, what other people do, what the % probability of X or Y is. It can happen again. Why not?

Just take your time and be you.

JustCallMeBridget · 26/01/2015 20:10

Thanks everyone :) Sorry to take so long to come back.

I guess I knew what you're all saying, really. There are lot of bits to the whole situation that I should have objected to as well.

My gut feeling is that if he wanted me, he'd be taking me (no pun intended) and the fact that he's not shows that he's prepared to risk losing me. Which, if he loved me.............

Bottom line - I am worth more. A lot more.

Thank you all again :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread