Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

serious moral dilemma

37 replies

moraldilemmaNoxxx · 05/09/2006 13:21

Obviously I have changed my name for this, but I am a regular and am not a troll.

A friend of mine split from her dp earlier this year. He basically was never there, always out with his mates and was never there for her or his dd.. He wasn?t a horrible person and they stayed on fairly good terms but she just doesn?t love him any more. Things are made somewhat difficult for her by the fact that her dp is my cousin, and most of her friends round here are related to him, or friends of his, in some way. But most of us weren?t exactly surprised about the split and have no ill feeling towards her. But since they have split up she has met someone else and now the rumour is doing the rounds with the family that she actually split from him because of this other man and that she was actually seeing him before they split. She assures me she wasn?t, but tbh I don?t care either way, it?s her business, but I don?t have any reason to not believe her.

Then recently she came to visit me, our dd?s are similar age and play together. While she was here she told me that just after her dd was born, her xp started staying out a lot, and after some digging around, she found text messages on his phone and emails on his computer, all to another woman. She confronted him about it but he denied everything. She said she tried to make the relationship work, and that as far as she knew whatever he was up to had ended, but things were never the same after. To this day he denies ever having cheated on her.

I have just been to the shops, as I walked across the car park I saw my cousin get out of his car, as he walked over to the shops a woman came out, she had a baby with her, I?d say he was about 18 months old. When she saw him I distinctly heard her say to her little boy ?look, there?s daddy?. To say I was shocked to hear this is an understatement. My cousin picked up the little boy and gave him a big cuddle, something I?ve never even seen him do with his dd, then he put him down and went into the shop and the mum went off on her way. He hadn?t seen me, so I turned round and went home because tbh I don?t know what I would have said if I?d seen him.

But what do I do now? My cousin (friend?s xp) has a child by another woman which was conceived while they were together. Not only that, it appears that he and this child have maintained a relationship, obviously I don?t know if he?s still involved with the woman, and meanwhile my friend has been made out to be the cause of the relationship break-up.

I?m not sure whether telling my friend is adviseable, after all, no-one saw me, so if she finds out she?s not going to know that I know, but should I let my cousin know that I know? If I?ve seen this then surely it?s just a matter of time before someone else potentially does? This child will grow up and then will say to someone about who his daddy is? Is it fair to have this child in secret? Fair to the child that is?

Help.

OP posts:
Needtoseelight · 05/09/2006 21:52

Adding support to catsmother. If it were me I'd be more upset to find out a friend knew something and hadn't told me - and the truth will out eventually - after all, your friend's DD has a half brother. Not quite the same thing but I had a bf long time ago who was always accusing me of cheating and when we split up bad-mouthed me to my friends. I later found out he'd cheated on me twice from a 'real' friend, I understood she didn't want to hurt me or get involved but I wish she'd just told me at the time - if you're really friends,she might be angry for a while but she'll understandand appreciate you telling her eventually.

oxocube · 06/09/2006 08:13

Upsetting but I would stay out of it, esp if your friend is now happy in another relationship.

hermykne · 06/09/2006 08:17

whats the big deal in hidding it if hes not with either woman, is it the mainteneance thing?
surely he cnat be afraid to tell the truth and move on.

hermykne · 06/09/2006 08:18

ok friend is anouther relationship.
so even more reason to just wipe the slate on move on - unless he wont pay her more

nailpolish · 06/09/2006 08:18

i agree its none of your business

for your own sake stay out of it

Mumpbump · 06/09/2006 10:06

Unreal! If it were me, I'd tell him that I felt I ought to tell my friend because keeping a secret a big as that is bound to have an effect on your friendship, but that you will give him the chance to come clean first since it will be worse if she hears it from someone else. If your friend is seriously thinking about getting back together with him, then I would tell her. I almost got back together with an ex, but figured out that he was seeing someone else (after we split, but he was still telling me how much he loved me and wanted to get back together). The worse thing was actually knowing that our mutual friends knew - I felt like a real idiot when it all came out. If she's not getting back with him anyway, then it probably doesn't matter so much.

kama · 06/09/2006 10:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Holidaymum · 06/09/2006 10:25

Surely your friend has a right to know that her dd has a half brother? I'd talk to the cousin agian and insist he tells her if not you will! Yes he needs to make sure both his kids are provided for equally too.

I too got the blame unfairly during a break up and its not a nice position to be in, I wanted to scream and shout about my exes hidded past infidelities but am not that type, instead I put up with the rumours and ended up in counselling.

She deserves the truth as do the rest of his/your family. But give him the chance to sort out his mess first.

bubblez · 06/09/2006 10:27

OMG I went offline and missed the fact that you had talked to your cousin.

Well now you know for sure all the seedy details. I agree with glassofwine and others who have said that you should advise your cousin to come clean and if he doesn't then tell your friend. If this was just his 'ex' then it would be a different story but this is your 'friend', others are right she will not forgive you if you know this and keep it from her.

What would you do if he manages to convince her to get back with him? He just admitted that he cheated on your friend for practically the whole duration of their relationship? He also admitted that he wasn't being 'protected', what if he's given something to your friend? Really I think that the question that would swing it for me would be, If I was your friend would I want to know?

wartywarthog · 06/09/2006 12:19

he must tell your friend. what a tosser! and start being a bit fairer.

your friend should know the truth, esp. if he's banging on about getting back together. what an untrustworthy bloke! but i'd get him to do it.

mimi1uk · 06/09/2006 12:43

i would so want to know and if one of my friends did not tell me i would not really conider then to be a friend!, if i knew i would tell my friend he lost his rights when he started messing around with peoples lifes, and only thinking about his dick, sorry makes me so angry! u should tell her she has every right to know!

mimi1uk · 06/09/2006 12:44

also if u or he does not tell her, then when it does come out and these things tend too and things get heated between ur cousin and ex partner ur name could be thrown in well such and such knew etc etc then u would look like a part to it all as well

New posts on this thread. Refresh page