Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Help me work out how to interact with my sister......

4 replies

PlumpPartridge · 30/05/2014 16:04

The backstory:

I'm 32, DSis is 25 and our mum died 2.5 months ago after a brief illness (metastatic breast cancer which we thought had gone away. It hadn't).

I live in the South of England with DH and our two DC (3yo and 2yo) and both myself and DH work FT. DSis is currently taking a break from her uni course (made this decision when she realised DM was ill and will be returning in September) and is working part-time in a deli in the small town where my mum lived. DFather is not from UK originally and was here for DM's treatment but has since moved back to his home region (not his actual country but we lived there as a family for a long time). So I am 4 hours away from DSis and DF is even further than that. She has a good circle of friends, she tells us (haven't met any save one or two) but isn't dating anyone that I'm aware of and has no DC. We have other relatives in the small town (our aunt and grandfather).

The problem I'm having is related to the fact that DM let DSis get away with what I considered to be quite rude behaviour - avoiding relatives, acting like the world revolved around her, etc. DM was DSis's major defender whilst the rest of us got progressively more and more pissed off at her childishness and selfish attitude (i.e. not participating in the once-in-a-blue-moon social visits, sitting there sullenly and not engaging when she did turn up, suddenly being sweetness and light when she wanted company from you but leaving as soon as her friends made her a better offer, etc). We didn't demand affection on tap, but an indication of occasional willingness would have gone a long way.

As a result, I feel that DSis is probably the most affected of all of us by DM's death. I feel like I want to try and look after her (because she is my little sister and I do love her) and so I do occasionally call/text/FB message to check in. She's generally less than enthusiastic when I get in touch and will reluctantly respond to my attempts at conversation, but she complained to DF that he didn't call her enough the other day Confused and he was a bit bewildered because he says that she never seems to want to speak to him either. The rest of the family would like to be friends with her but are somewhat tired of her attitude and have more or less given up trying to make contact.

I worry about her, because in some ways she is very very hard on herself and criticises her own behaviour relentlessly, but in other ways she completely explodes at even a hint of implied criticism, as in:

Me: "Oh, I went to see DAunt today. She asked how you were doing."
DSis:"Oh yes, I KNOW, I haven't seen her in a while"

I don't want to have conversations with her that she'll use to beat herself up with afterwards, but I don't want to constantly be swallowing my bile at her not-so-passive-aggressive arsiness either. She treated DM like that and DM's advice to everyone else was to 'just ignore it because she's so lovely when she's happy'.

Sigh. I just don't know whether to persist in trying to talk to her or to just leave her the fuck alone.

Any advice would be appreciated.

OP posts:
Jackie0 · 30/05/2014 16:24

You can't really force her to have more regular contact but I think it would be a mistake to give up on her. 25 is still pretty young and perhaps she's a little immature even for 25. It's complicated with the mixed messages about complaining your df isn't calling enough and then not really engaging when people do call, it sounds like she's a bit down , which given the circumstances would be understandable.
I have a younger sister and I would be so upset if I were in your situation. My gut feeling would be to tell her I love her and I'll will always be there for her with as little or much contact as she wants.
You don't have to let her say rude or hurtful things to you without challenging her on it. Don't let it escalate. Tell her she's upsetting you talking like that, ask her why. I think sometimes people spout nastiness because they are in so much pain themselves. Or I could be being too charitable and she's just a brat . Either way don't let her disappear from your life, the damage could be irreparable.

PlumpPartridge · 30/05/2014 16:31

Thanks for the reply.

I think she is in pain and desperately needs some sort of help, be it counselling, anti-depressants or simply a hug. I desperately wish I could help her to help herself, but the mere fact of being her older sister seems to mean that I'm the last person she wants to accept help from. I have tried and tried to treat her like I would my friends, not to be condescending, to be friendly, to be flexible, but every time she acts like I'm being this total uber-bitch and I really don't think I was.

I've asked DH and other bystanders at the time and they all seem equally perplexed by it, so I don't think I'm just horrible to her. The trouble is, that seems to be what she feels.

ARGH

OP posts:
Jackie0 · 30/05/2014 16:42

This situation sounds heartbreaking. Other than telling her you love her and you're worried about her it's hard to know what else to do. I'd be tempted to contact her every two weeks or so to keep the lines of communication open and hope that this wall she's building around herself is something that will be resolved when she's ready. I'm so sorry plumb, you sound lovely. I'd really hold out hope that thus is a temporary rocky patch for your relationship.

PlumpPartridge · 30/05/2014 19:42

Thanks Jackie, that is pretty much the conclusion I'd come to. I just don't know what else to do and was hoping I'd missed something.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page